I think Willy has clearly been the best keeper this season from what I've seen. That's mostly basing it on watching him a lot. Haven't seen any Italian domestic games. Willy has been brilliant. Thoroughly impressed. Don't think he'll get the credit he deserves. It will probably be someone obvious like Buffon.
These whoscored ratings are pretty rubbish. According to them Andy Carroll is the 10th best performer in the PL.
I'm sorry but that's too easy to just dismiss it as rubbish... Every ranking system will have its flaws, depending on how certain aspects are weighted, but for the most part WhoScored ratings provide a decent picture of reality. Especially notable considering the broad scale on which it operates (top 5 leagues in Europe).
Earlier in the season RVP and Cazorla had alternated at #1 (both in the 7.90 range), and now they've dropped off a bit and Bale and Súarez have gone slightly ahead. Who here would disagree with that progression?
Currently for the PL:
#1 Gareth Bale, 7.94
#2 Luís Suárez, 7.90
#3 Santi Cazorla, 7.81
#4 Robin Van Persie, 7.72
#5 Marouane Fellaini, 7.63
#6 Jan Vertonghen, 7.54
#7 Chico, 7.54
#8 Steven Gerrard, 7.54
#9 Adel Taarabt, 7.46
#10 Andy Carroll, 7.44
#11 Rafael, 7.43
#12 Wayne Rooney, 7.42
#13 Christian Benteke, 7.41
#14 Leighton Baines, 7.40
#15 David Silva, 7.37
#16 Moussa Dembélé, 7.37
#17 Patrice Evra, 7.35
#18 Dimitar Berbatov, 7.34
#19 Michael Williamson, 7.34
#20 Sandro, 7.33
(The fact that there is a huge bias towards goals in the calculation method makes it quite surprising to see so many defenders in the top 20.)
And yes there are some "bizarre" inclusions (keep in mind though that Carroll has only been rated on 15 appearances so if he has a couple of low scores in a row he'll drop far faster than those around him with more apps), but no system is perfect.
From looking at the stats I can think of a couple of aspects that could have overrated his performance ratings: he comfortably leads the category Aerial duels won per game, he's 15th in Shots per game, he has a decent amount of Key passes per game, etc. etc. The only terrible thing about his performances statistically is *unsurprisingly* his Passing accuracy (59% lol)
Taraabt was also one of the stranger ones to me, but he leads the division in Dribbles per game, 4th in Key Passes per game, 5th in Shots per game, 5th in Accurate throughballs per game, 14th in Accurate crosses per game and he doesn't have a terrible Passing accuracy (81%).. all of that in the worst team in the league.
All that just to point out that you should take WhoScored ratings with a pinch of salt, but I've found it incredibly interesting and mostly useful.