I keep reading Welbeck is technically gifted. Which I am struggling to make a decision on. There is something just not right. This is hard to explain, because I haven't really seen anything like it before.
I think his coordination is just off. I haven't seen it before in a player but at times he can do some great touches and dribble amazingly good and then others the ball will just bounce off him. It is carelessness. Clumsyness. Casualness. Inconsistency. This is my problem with Welbeck - and also his average football brain. However, he is a great athlete, with an ability to do the passing finishes as Datura mentioned. Combine this with the inconsistent great skill and touches and there is a good player. I don't think he will make it at United but will probably end up staying in the Premier League. I keep trying to think of a similar player, who will look careless but just as brilliant in the same match, but for now I struggle.