Is he playing as front 3 or attacking 3 behind striker?
Daniel James has 8 goals and assists in PL, in 18 games (2nd most by ManUtd player). That's a decent record, not a record that's worth criticism. If he keeps up this form, it will be 16 goals and assists in a PL season and that's a very good record for a winger. This is excluding his penalties, which he has won few of them already.
He’s not being criticised. He’s just not being celebrated as he’s not meeting THE standard. He may we’ll be exceeding HIS standard, and fair play to him, but that doesn’t automatically mean because it’s his best, it’s the best we can hope for.
I’ve heard of the trio referred to as the front 3 very often. A combination of 8 goals and assists at the halfway point isn’t enough. Not just for him, it’s not enough for anyone who wants to start in our front line weekly. He’s scored 3 goals, which is about what I’d expect from Maguire at this stage. There is no way that you can spin 3 goals at the halfway mark as enough.
And if he’s in the ‘3 behind the striker’, then so is Rashford. It’s not a criticism of him. It’s just the standard. If you can’t meet it, you shouldn’t be starting here. It’s not a criticism. People are saying we don’t need a winger because we have one who has scored 3 goals. Then they wonder why we are not winning enough games.