Sunny Jim
Full Member
The guy has been superb, plays like he has a sixth sense. He knowe what to do before things actually develop. He won me over.
When can we start discussing him as one of the best centre-backs in the league?
When he grows a couple of inches and puts on about 20 pounds of muscle?
For some people, that's the only way they'd recognise a CB.
Barca don't have to 50 mil to offer for a CB.If he keeps us this level, Barca will offer £50M in the summer
Louis, is that you?What I love seeing how quickly he transitions the play into attack by making a good pass. One second he'll be winning the ball in his own half, the next second, a winger/full back or CM would have the ball and we shall be attacking again. Seems unreal at times.
And it's even funnier that he bought a Daley Blind pretender for 50mGuardiola would suck his dick to have him in his team. It's like we have a bonus midfielder playing him at the back.
Good player to have against weaker opposition as he's a decent defender and got excellent ball playing abilities. However, against the top teams his lack of athleticism will put us into trouble. Redmond was already showing how you can exploit the gap between Shaw and Blind due to the latter's lack of pace. I hope Mourinho pairs Smalling with Bailly or else Aguero will have a field day.
Aguero is more likely to have a field day with Smalling than Blind, Blind is much better at reading the movements of the player and where he wants to go than Smalling who has pace and strength and just goes in the straight line in for Aguero. Smalling is also going to get exploited every time he gets the ball against Peps high pressure because he is not very good on the ball, contrary to Blind who will calmly bring the ball out of tough situations. Besides if that is the problem then you just put Bailly to manmark Aguero, if that is what you're worried about.
Good player to have against weaker opposition as he's a decent defender and got excellent ball playing abilities. However, against the top teams his lack of athleticism will put us into trouble. Redmond was already showing how you can exploit the gap between Shaw and Blind due to the latter's lack of pace. I hope Mourinho pairs Smalling with Bailly or else Aguero will have a field day.
He exploits between Blind and Shaw? One of the fastest fullbacks in the premiership? Kind of tells it wasn't really a lack of athleticism that allowed Redmond to exploit, even though he didn't really exploit anything.Good player to have against weaker opposition as he's a decent defender and got excellent ball playing abilities. However, against the top teams his lack of athleticism will put us into trouble. Redmond was already showing how you can exploit the gap between Shaw and Blind due to the latter's lack of pace. I hope Mourinho pairs Smalling with Bailly or else Aguero will have a field day.
So height deals with off the ball movement now does it? Incredible how important you seem height will be against the shortest starting XI in the premiership.He scores with his great off the ball movement. Smalling is by far better at reacting to those due to his height and athleticism.
Good player to have against weaker opposition as he's a decent defender and got excellent ball playing abilities. However, against the top teams his lack of athleticism will put us into trouble. Redmond was already showing how you can exploit the gap between Shaw and Blind due to the latter's lack of pace. I hope Mourinho pairs Smalling with Bailly or else Aguero will have a field day.
It almost seems like they've written him off and are desperate to find reasons not to rate him.Forgetting completely about the run last season where blind put lukaku in his pocket followed by aguero the next week? People overrate physicality and height so much on here.
It almost seems like they've written him off and are desperate to find reasons not to rate him.
They will point to every single mistake he makes (they are few and far between) as a justification of how he isn't good enough, whilst ignoring the fact every defenders makes mistakes.
A star on and off the pitch
If he was two or three inches taller he would be perfect.
Who's better looking, Blind or his girlfriend?
He exploits between Blind and Shaw? One of the fastest fullbacks in the premiership? Kind of tells it wasn't really a lack of athleticism that allowed Redmond to exploit, even though he didn't really exploit anything.
So height deals with off the ball movement now does it? Incredible how important you seem height will be against the shortest starting XI in the premiership.
What does that even mean? Jumping isn't considered off the ball movement in football mate, just a heads up. Ultimately, Blinds vastly superior positioning negates any lack in physical deficiency, which is ridiculous over emphasised by the way. Redmond didn't create most of their chances anyway, that's just nonsense. You're making yourself look foolish now. The chance you're actually referring to (27 seconds in the video) was actually Bailly and not Blind that lost Redmond, have a rewatch and then you can admit you were wrong. Just to help, here's the match highlights, care you point out all the chances Blind conceded?Shaw was marking their wide midfielder, which leaves Blind 1v1 to defend against a pacy Redmond. Redmond created most of Southampton's chances exploiting that. Blind is a decent player, but don't mistake solid team defending for his individual defensive prowess. We'll be cut apart against top attacking sides.
Ever heard of crosses? Off the ball movement isn't always vertical. Incredible how you'd forget that. Smalling is the one who carried us in defense last year sliding all over blocking shots & crosses. Also your suggestion that height is a weakness against short teams is dumb because not only is Smalling taller and stronger, but he's also much faster. As a defender he is light years ahead of Blind. The only negative being that he will struggle against the press due to his woeful ball playing skills.
As a former doubter,it takes a lot for people to change their opinion on a player .I know, its just lazy. The judgements for daley become extremely strong if he does one tiny thing wrong. In reality he is superb in the position and he offers us so much that no other defender could on top of his commanding defensive displays. The same thing happens with tony v, he is not a proper right back apparently and they would rather have a 'natural' rb in there. I love watching blind defend and for my money he is superior to smalling in the position and in great form, has to play.
There is middle ground between The issue only comes for game like vs Southampton where Blind was tested by more traditionally CB role in more typical PL game where teams putting more crosses into the box and having physical imposing forwards.
Good point on the press. But I'm not worried about Aguero dribbling past two players and scoring. Let's be honest that's not how he scores. He scores with his great off the ball movement. Smalling is by far better at reacting to those due to his height and athleticism.
Furthermore our entire back line is based on zonal marking, so I doubt Mourinho would change a system that has been working well before a huge game.
It's just a toss up between what Mourinho fears more, Smalling inability to pass around the press, or Blind's lack of pace against Aguero and Sterling. Might be Phil Jones time as he wouldn't be great, but would provide the most balance between defense and ball playing.
You only talk about ball that Blind anticipated. Around 60th mark, Blind was caught out near post for a cross that Southampton player knock on (Mata then blocked Nathan Redmond) Around 75th mark again, Long knocked a ball at near post and Blind had to play catch up.
so 2 examples where most defenders would be in same position as blind.You only talk about ball that Blind anticipated. Around 60th mark, Blind was caught out near post for a cross that Southampton player knock on. Around 75th mark again, Long knocked a ball at near post and Blind had to play catch up.
That's not my original point, was it? Point was Blind would be more suited in his line with an aggressive DM and a ball player CB partner like Hull game when he was flawless. Nobody is perfect but my last post is to refute the claim that all stats are reliable and insightful in football match. That 100% duel won was misleading that Blind couldn't anticipate in 2 near post knock from Southampton, meaning he didn't contest while in fact he should have contested for that as a CB.so 2 examples where most defenders would be in same position as blind.
Sometimes, you know the other team attacking play could be so good that our defenders get caught a bit. I mean otherwise there will be a team who never conceded any kind of chance at all let alone goals.
And smalling never got caught out in any situations since you said he is better at off ball movement?
You only talk about ball that Blind anticipated. Around 60th mark, Blind was caught out near post for a cross that Southampton player knock on (Mata then blocked Nathan Redmond) Around 75th mark again, Long knocked a ball at near post and Blind had to play catch up.
The half chance Clasie widely blasted to the stand. Blind was caught out of position to press. The press didn't work then he went chasing Van Dijk trying to block the cross but failed. Had Clasie decided to cross over the Blind's unoccupied position for unmarked Long, then that would be free shot toward goal since Long was inside with Blind and Van Dijk down near the touch line.
Why is the red text?
There is no secret? Ok so tell me what other team did it?That's not my original point, was it? Point was Blind would be more suited in his line with an aggressive DM and a ball player CB partner like Hull game when he was flawless. Nobody is perfect but my last post is to refute the claim that all stats are reliable and insightful in football match. That 100% duel won was misleading that Blind couldn't anticipate in 2 near post knock from Southampton, meaning he didn't contest while in fact he should have contested for that as a CB.
Sometimes these kind of small detail can decide the big game. There is no secret that teams often tries to exploit near post (Blind's side) with that kind of play.