@noodlehair well, for one he didn't get a stupid red card.
First player off the teamsheet under Mourinho.
He was naff again yesterday. Stupid moment that should have cost us a goal, countless times he wandered off out of position and someone else had to cover. Bafflingly large number of times he got sucked into challlenging for a ball with Wickham despite having zero chance of winning it. Can someone explain what it is he actually did well?
One thing that's really started to annoy me with him is when he picks up the ball, strolls slowly about 40 yards out of position with it, then just plays a hospital pass to someone next to him. Please can someone explain to me as well what goes through his head for him to think this isn't a stupid thing to do?...because he does it multiple times a game and it achieves nothing aside from allowing the opposition to counter attack.
If he had any functioning braincells he'd actually be a really useful player...but he just chases the ball with no regard for the situation or anything else that's going on, and when he has the ball he seems to completely forget what position he's playing in and often either plays a hosptial pass or just lofts it up the pitch to no one. One of his strengths is supposedly his distribution yet he must be among the worst in our team for using the ball poorly or taking too long with it.
I know people on here like him but if I was manager the very first thing I'd do is make sure he wasn't played at centreback anymore, under pretty much any circumstance. There's definitely another case of the Kagawa/Mata effect on here where people will just invent another version of reality so they can pretend he played well. If you take him out of the team and put a competent centreback in his place this season, we'd be comfortably in the top four, and would have gotten through the CL group stages.
People that come out with crap like "He's been our best centreback this year" I dunno. They either say it because they have no idea how a game of football works, or because they think saying it makes them sound clever and like they know more about football than anyone else...probably the same people who used to keep tellling us all LVG was a tactical genius who could not be questioned.
I think Blind will continue as a CB, and we will sign a partner for him. Smalling will be the one benched.
Mourinho was fuming before about how many touches it took for Matic to control a ball, Smalling is far worse than that.
We will build a solid base in front the defence (i.e. two defensive midfielders + Rooney), and Blind will continue as someone who can start attacks from deep.
Absolutely no chance. Agree on the Smalling part though, his technical deficiencies will astound Mourinho and I expect him to be replaced eventually.I think Blind will continue as a CB, and we will sign a partner for him. Smalling will be the one benched.
Mourinho was fuming before about how many touches it took for Matic to control a ball, Smalling is far worse than that.
We will build a solid base in front the defence (i.e. two defensive midfielders + Rooney), and Blind will continue as someone who can start attacks from deep.
He also loses more than a half of his aerial duels (which is a disastrous stat, really - especially for a centre back)The only thing he is lacking in is pace but many players have made excellent careers without having a lot of pace.
I can't remember ever conceding a header because Blind lost a header.He also loses more than a half of his aerial duels (which is a disastrous stat, really - especially for a centre back)
Well, then I fear for your memory.I can't remember ever conceding a header because Blind lost a header.
That was more down to shocking organisation than anything else. Nobody in the defence knew what their jobs were and it showed.Well, then I fear for your memory.
The third West Ham goal is a header with Blind losing the aerial duel. And the second one, while not technically being a lost header, because he didn't jump, is still partly his fault - he was on the way of the cross and should've cleared it (or, at least, make an attempt), which he didn't because he lacks in this particular department.
That's not the only one, that's the last one. I won't bother looking further back though, you'll just change your statement againThe fact that people can only point to one match also suggests he's a Much better centre back than people think on here.
When did I change my statement. I think Blind is a really good centre back and is better in the air than he's made out. There's no need to start accusing me of changing anything because I disagree with you mateThat's not the only one, that's the last one. I won't bother looking further back though, you'll just change your statement again
I think we should have played with that midfield, it looks balanced. I can see Mourinho buying one midfielder.Could he maybe be the Carrick replacement we're crying out for. I say give him a crack at pulling the strings from deep and surround him with energy such as:
Schneiderlin - HerreraAlas, it leaves no room for Rooney. Still I'd like to see it.
Blind
Absolutely no chance. Agree on the Smalling part though, his technical deficiencies will astound Mourinho and I expect him to be replaced eventually.
Actually think our squad is more geared for 433 but no I expect 4231 meaning a new number 10 is probably on the cards.I think we should have played with that midfield, it looks balanced. I can see Mourinho buying one midfielder.
Do you think Mourinho is going to play 433 instead of 4231?
Thinking somewhere a little outside the box, I'd like to see him as a pressing player playing between AM and DM. Winning the ball around the middle of the park and quickly getting it forward. He has a good engine and he loves chasing the ball, I don't really want him playing in an anchor role mainly because of this. He gets a lot more protection from that position from having two CB's behind him. (This season he's been out of position loads of time and had licence to be miles out of position constantly which has triggered me out of existence all season.) Playing CB he's gone ball chasing or wandering off into no mans land in and around the box a few times and it has really cost us.Interesting to see what his role will be next season. Don't think he'll ever step near CB again with Mourinho as manager. Backup LB and backup DM, for me.
I see you haven't changed from when you said this a month ago. We shall see, in my personal opinion you'd have to be laying firmly in the chaise lounge to want to pursue Blind at CB next season.I think Blind will continue as a CB, and we will sign a partner for him. Smalling will be the one benched.
Mourinho was fuming before about how many touches it took for Matic to control a ball, Smalling is far worse than that.
We will build a solid base in front the defence (i.e. two defensive midfielders + Rooney), and Blind will continue as someone who can start attacks from deep.
I can't remember ever conceding a header because Blind lost a header.
If Jose dumps him into bench fodder it will be a big loss for our first team. He's a wonderful footballer and comfortably our most underrated player.
Thinking somewhere a little outside the box, I'd like to see him as a pressing player playing between AM and DM. Winning the ball around the middle of the park and quickly getting it forward. He has a good engine and he loves chasing the ball, I don't really want him playing in an anchor role mainly because of this. He gets a lot more protection from that position from having two CB's behind him. (This season he's been out of position loads of time and had licence to be miles out of position constantly which has triggered me out of existence all season.) Playing CB he's gone ball chasing or wandering off into no mans land in and around the box a few times and it has really cost us.
I think he could be a similar player to Herrera, but on the offensive end I think Herrera has more in his locker. Blind on the defensive and pressing end, more in his.
I see you haven't changed from when you said this a month ago. We shall see, in my personal opinion you'd have to be laying firmly in the chaise lounge to want to pursue Blind at CB next season.
edit: I suppose he won that header but a proper commanding CB heads that out onto the 14th green of the Sinfin Golf course. Though above, rightfully pointed out his horrifying display in the West Ham game.
Really? How about 3-rd WH goal? That was like just maybe two weeks ago. And 2-nd goal was also Blind's fault, but that more to do with his shity positioning.I can't remember ever conceding a header because Blind lost a header.
It'd be really unproductive. He's like a taller, slightly more physical version of Blind.Hopefully we don't waste big money on Stones though.
Agreed, but Jose likes his big, strong, powerful centre backs. Which Blind isn't.
Big may not be the right word. Strong, powerful is still true though. Replace big for athletic and it's closer to truth.Really dont get people saying that. Its a myth imo
Carvalho wasn't even vaguely close to being a big, strong, powerful centre back
Samuel was fairly meaty but i was under the impression most people regarded him as a good player because of his use of the ball more than being a traditional lump of a defender.
Ramos isn't a big, strong, powerful centre back and neither is stones.
Think its probably likely he'll be moved back to midfield
but he wont be getting replaced by Huth or that type of player.
Big may not be the right word. Strong, powerful is still true though. Replace big for athletic and it's closer to truth.