Messi's the Federer to Ronaldo's Nadal/Djokovic. Watching Federer at his best playing against a lower rated player will make you feel bad for the other guy, looks incredibly dominating, several levels above anyone, pulls off whatever he wants when he wants and the opponent looks completely helpless... watch prime Djokovic playing against a lower rated player and it will look like a fairly even match with few moments of magic where he ends up winning regardless of how well he's playing. They'd win just as often as eachother, but one will get more recognition for it.
The difference is that in tennis Djokovic/Nadal can surpass Federer's titles count and it will hold more weight because it's an individual sport while for many people it doesn't really matter what Ronaldo ends up accomplishing since it can be dismissed by putting more or less emphasis on the other 10 players on the pitch. Messi and even players like Neymar are definitely more naturally talented than Ronaldo. But if anyone thinks Juve/Barca/PSG are more likely to win the Champions League or Portugal to win the Euros with them instead of Ronaldo then they haven't been paying attention. Luckily for Ronaldo the biggest tournaments in football are structured to favour adaptability, mentality and physicality over consistency and flair. Probably unfairly so, but it's the way it is not just in football but in most sports.
On the other hand I don’t think Barca would’ve won CL with Ronaldo instead of Messi these last two seasons
Ronaldo is incredible but also insanely
Fortunate that even in matches where he is invisible in the finals (euro final, 2014, 2016 and 2018 CL final, nations league final) his teams still win every single time.
No player in history gets that fortunate. Obviously Ronaldo was a massive reason for those teams reaching the those finals, but the fact that even when he plays poorly in a final his team still gets a trophy is an insane amount of fortune
As the tennis analogy I disagree, I feel like Ronaldo could be more like Nadal but in regards to Djokovic he has a SUPERB head to head vs nadal and federer. Ronaldo has a poor head to head vs Messi but of course football is a team sport as it should be.
Ronaldo has also fared poorly in those domestic titles in la liga where there is much less luck involved and over a 38 week sample the best team usually wins the league.
Even zidane said La liga is harder than CL, but obviously CL means more.
Ronaldo has had several teammates show up in big moments although Ronaldo was the one delivering them for his teams a lot of the team. When Ronaldo plays poor though his teams still have a good chance of winning, when Messi plays poor his teams are dead in the water. It’s a luxury for Ronaldo to have had other teammates be able
To step up in the few times he couldn’t deliver. Even though Messi has had some incredible teammates, outside of the 6-1 psg match, I can hardly recall a Barca
Player outshine Messi in an important match in the past 4 years or so.