TheLord
Full Member
- Joined
- Nov 25, 2018
- Messages
- 1,821
3. Null and void the season.
In this scenario you are essentially saying let's go back to the summer of 2019.
No promotions or relegation from the current season would stand. No prize money would be paid out. Season tickets and match tickets would be null and void so would be open to full refunds. TV money would not be paid out.
You're making it sound like doomsday for the "null and void" situation.I agree the "null and void" phrase sounds a little eerie and undermines the enormous effort of everyone involved in the season thus far. The word "curtailed" or "ended abruptly" or something similar should be used instead. Now, on to the main point:
Why do you argue prize money will not be paid out at all? That is a ridiculous statement. Why would season tickets have to be refunded in full? What is the basis of that assumption? Almost 75% of the season has already been played out. The broadcasters have already recouped about 75% (of course, this is not as straightforward as linear arithmetic, but anyway) of the total revenue from this season. Why will they be entitled for a full refund from the Premier League? Clubs should also refund season ticket money only proportionate to the number of games remaining (Cashley and Levy may refuse to do so, but that is another story.) Why would anyone be entitled for a full refund?
Yes, in an ideal situation everyone wants the season to be completed, but when you cannot do that in exceptional circumstances, the Premier League, like any other large business enterprise, has to choose the option that provides the best long-term financial outlook. The upcoming 2020/2021 season is much more lucrative than the current one and the Premier League has to ensure the new season completes without disruptions. Nobody really knows about the second wave of SARS-CoV-2, so let us not start making assumptions about its impact on the new season.
Mathematically speaking, no team has won the league, no team has been relegated and no European places have been decided. So, terminate the season, void the season's current league standings, distribute TV money equally (see below) among teams (yes, the big teams won't like it), and start the new season afresh. I don't think there will be a lot of transfer activity, so the core of most teams will remain the same next season.
(p.s. TV money is divided among teams based on several factors like merit money, facility fees, domestic TV revenue and central commercialisation. By equal distribution, I only mean the part attributed to merit - i.e., league standings).
Lawsuits from teams that have been denied promotion or were on course to receive huge prize money.
There may be lawsuits from teams in the lower tiers who were denied promotion, but they pale in comparison to the storm of lawsuits that will follow if you relegate the bottom three clubs based on current standings, or allocate European spots based on current standings. That is unthinkable.
There is not a single solution that will please everyone - the idea is to find one with least legal, social (including public health) and economic ramifications. Terminating this season and steadfastly getting on with the next, whenever it is safe to do so, is the best option among all bad ones.
Last edited: