Another reason why we shouldn’t be hesitant selling Maguire, Lindelof, and McTominay. We don’t want to move on from deadwoods and stuck with deadwoods even though there is an opportunity arises to sell them.
Conor Gallagher | AtletiGO?
- Thread starter ::sonny::
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have four new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting.
A new Odds or Evens competition is starting now. Click here to read the rules and message Damien to submit your eight players by 14th September 2024
A new Carabao Cup prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for round 3 which begins 17th September.
A new Champions League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 17th September.
A new Europa League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 25th September.
For Odds or Evens you have until the 14th September to submit your players. Submissions will be open for the next 6 days, 10 hours, 55 minutes, 29 seconds, and will close on Sep 14, 2024 at 12:30. -
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) get the depressing job of reviewing United's 3-0 loss at Old Trafford to Liverpool. They discuss what went wrong, Casemiro's day to forget, and the pressure now on Erik Ten Hag. They also take some time to give McTominay a proper farewell, and give their overall thoughts on the Summer Transfer Window.
Everyone loved him last year.
I thought we’d be lucky to get a £30m for him again, which we had rejected last summer but £45m is quite a mad fee for a player I don’t think is quite at the level we need.
I’m not sure it’s the right move for him. It’ll be good to have a reason to continue rooting for Everton though.
He had a great season and was Palace’s POTY. He’s a good player. It’s quite an overpay for Everton but they’ll be getting a good player if this deal happens.
I think if Dyche gets it right and we stay up it could be a pretty good move for all parties. Onana - Garner and Gallagher as a future midfield is pretty solid I think.
Yeah could work out well for everyone. It does sound like the lad prefers Newcastle though, and there were rumours of them sniffing around him earlier this month.
Definitely fits the Howe profile. Wouldn't be surprised if he goes there due to Shelvey leaving and United not letting McT go.
Everton hasn't learnt anything. 45m for Gallager is a waste of a tight budget now. They have bigger priorities now.
Chelsea make a 105m bid for Fernandez. Gallagher is off.
Everton are the ideal club for us to sell him to from our perspective. Us selling him to Newcastle who will be a top 4 rival in the years ahead is ill-advised. With a coach like Howe and consistent playing time week after week I think Gallagher becomes a very good player.
stupid if Newcastle get involved, Maddison’s contract ends next year
whereas for Everton, buying big club garbage is what they do best
whereas for Everton, buying big club garbage is what they do best
Decent player. Always seemed to graft for Palace and has a bit of quality on top. Everton need both of those things to get out of this mess. I think swapping Gordon for Gallagher on similar terms can only be a good thing if it goes through.
You'd have to be mad choosing Everton over Newcastle right now tbh.
Obviously the player wouldn't, but Chelsea would.
Ouch. Tough luck Chelsea
The Fernandez bid makes me think Chelsea is going to try and force him out. Even if it isn't to us I can see him leaving.
I'd take him for 20 mil
I don't think they would do anything to force him out. If the lad is against going to Everton and no other bid comes in for him, then I guess he stays. Wouldn't surprise me if Newcastle came with a similar offer on deadline day though.
Agreed. He's a lower-to-mid table player who needs the right set-up to shine. Looked well off the standard required for Chelsea this year.
Fascinating just how high the fees are that these sorts of English players command.
Chelsea haven't got much choice really. They HAVE to sell players now or they'd have several high value assets rotting.
By force him out what I mean is make it clear to him his options at the club are going to be limited and that if he doesn't go it's likely he will be on the bench more often than not. I would be really surprised if he's happy staying to 'fight' with those odds.
I think he can hang around until the summer and still get decent playing time. I don't think there's any need to give him ultimatums like that. He built a good reputation for himself at Palace and before that, and to be honest, has been decent-ish this season. I'm sure Everton, Palace etc will be back in for him in the summer if he doesn't go anywhere this window.
Tend to agree with that, with Enzo coming in and all the other signings they have made, he'll probably realise he's better off elsewhere if he actually wants to play.
With a relegation clause saying he must be sold if they get relegated and someone bids £x I don't think its necessarily a bad move. Could be he'll hold out for Newcastle in the summer though?
I could see Palace coming in with a loan and obligation to buy if certain levels are achieved.
We will see. I think you’re on a fine line in terms of FFP at the moment and though you have a few sellable assets, Gallagher is one that provides you with pure FFP profit. Right now it’s a case of Chelsea not really needing/wanting? him and a club like Everton pretty desperate to have him or a club like Newcastle being fairly interested. I think that 40m is a bit inflated due to us being desperate but in the summer there isn’t really that scenario and it will more likely be a case of you trying to flog him leading to a probable lower price. I think this is the best opportunity for Chelsea to get a bigger fee for him.
No, think you should reread my post. I said that clubs will be try to sign certain players; I didn’t say I wanted them to go.
Also, do United keep all their academy players? Do you think United have no soul because they don’t keep all academy products?
Oh yeah for sure I don't disagree with literally any of that but I was entertaining the scenario that he flat out refuses to join Everton if we accept the bid. As a fan of the club but also a big fan of Gallagher, I would rather sell him for a lower fee (say 30m?) to a club he's happy with than give him ultimatums about playing time if he stays to force him to a club he doesn't want to join. With Dyche though, I definitely think he'll have you organised and well drilled so Gallagher going there might not be such a bad thing but I get it, he doesn't want to give up the potential CL football he can get with Chelsea (and Newcastle).
Last edited:
That’ll be funded in part, by the sale of Gordon.
He isn’t deadwood. He can get better with more game time. If that does happen it would be a good deal for both clubs. It’s not like he is a McT who has shown zero aptitude and little to no progress in the time he has been in the first team.
club is a joke if Colwill is sold
How do these cnuts keep getting top dollar for their castoffs?
That, I agree with. Even Chalobah. No need to sell good HG players that actually fit into the team really well. I understand it with Gallagher because as good a player as he is, and as much as I like him, he's got a glaring weakness that stands out like a sore thumb in our team. Colwill is a gem, and Chelsea went out of their way to insist on a loan (I think we ended up paying more for Cucurella to avoid having to sell him to Brighton), so I would be shocked if if there's any talk of him going anywhere. Rumour has it he's about to sign a new 6 year deal.
Transfer deadline day loan to Palace. You read it here first. Here we go!
Come on, mcT actually performed for a big club in big games. Gallagher had one good season for palace but mostly looked like a joke in your first team.
I think this could happen, though a straight loan doesn’t do us much good. If there’s a buy obligation in the summer then I think we’d do it.
They are the worst club in the world, not only England. Paying 40m for a 15m pound player is pure stupidity.
What progress has Gallagher shown???
Which isn't happening.