villain
Hates Beyoncé
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14,986
Yeah I think I've been overly presumptuous in discerning what you are trying to say, I apologize, you are right there needs to be a line drawn. Fundamentally Migos/Thug/Future etc. rap more than they sing, but they do associate with melody a lot. What's happened is guys like PartyNextDoor, Bryson Tiller have twigged what those guys do and now their R&B builds on that which muddies the waters for urban music in general. I don't like the notion of sub-genres like trap etc. because I think it's an unfair reduction of what the artist does and I think it allows people to decry specific styles of rap as ignorant and unintelligent.
Exactly the lines do get muddy, I will happily listen to PND over Thug/Future because that's just my personal preference. Drake is another who builds a lot of his sound by combining melodies and raps.
I think you don't like the notion of sub genres because you are such a fan of the very music it would fall under, but ultimately it is a sub-genre. Trap is certainly better than mumble rap which definitely undermines it.