TheMagicFoolBus
Full Member
Nope you're right a 36 year old CB who's never played in the PL is of course one of the best CB's in the league, in fact considering what you guys are saying about your attacking players + this now one of the best CB's in the league then surely you'll be competing for the title? I mean surely nothing less than that can be acceptable given how good all your new players are right?
I understand your point and some skepticism is healthy, but which CBs in the PL currently could you see putting in the performances that Silva was last month? For me that list starts and ends with VVD. Yes he's getting on in years, but he's still very fit, he's used to playing in a high line for PSG, and all recent evidence points to him remaining a very very good defender (if not quite elite).
I think he'll require a period to adjust at minimum, but if he is able to come to grips with the league then I think he's up there with Laporte as being the 2nd or 3rd best CB in the PL. Granted that's a big if, but he's certainly not played badly in the CL which suggests he can cope (apart from when PSG were managed by that buffoon Emery).