Bruno Fernandes | United not interested due to doubts over passing ability

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have no idea about this guy, however reading about the release clause and as above prices that Sporting are quoting above the release clause I could make a good guess at what is happening. Roughly...

One of us and City at least must have a genuine interest, but not necessarily both of us. Possibly an offer has been made close to or above this clause but not accepted immediately. Sporting have released to the press about us and City being interested trying to get us to bid against each other above the release clause, ala Fred and Sanchez, where we seem to be trying to gazump one another.

Bruno just wants to leave Sporting having been stopped last year, and is growing frustrated at the goings on, so his agent has now leaked the release clause, in an attempt to speed up/force the move?

That's my guess anyway.
 
Dan600 said:
I have no idea about this guy, however reading about the release clause and as above prices that Sporting are quoting above the release clause I could make a good guess at what is happening. Roughly...

One of us and City at least must have a genuine interest, but not necessarily both of us. Possibly an offer has been made close to or above this clause but not accepted immediately. Sporting have released to the press about us and City being interested trying to get us to bid against each other above the release clause, ala Fred and Sanchez, where we seem to be trying to gazump one another.

Bruno just wants to leave Sporting having been stopped last year, and is growing frustrated at the goings on, so his agent has now leaked the release clause, in an attempt to speed up/force the move?

That's my guess anyway.
Click to expand...
The only thing is Bruno was not stopped from leaving last season he chose to come back despite having multiple offers from clubs in England and Spain.
 
SportingCP96 said:
The only thing is Bruno was not stopped from leaving last season he chose to come back despite having multiple offers from clubs in England and Spain.
Click to expand...

Apologies. I misread your post, similar view on the situation that aside I guess.

Cheekiey said:
I've only seen Us interested in him not City?
Click to expand...

Was on the news now feed earlier from sport witness:

http://sportwitness.co.uk/man-city-open-talks-signing-send-official-back-offer-ahead-shy-man-united/
 
Dan600 said:
I have no idea about this guy, however reading about the release clause and as above prices that Sporting are quoting above the release clause I could make a good guess at what is happening. Roughly...

One of us and City at least must have a genuine interest, but not necessarily both of us. Possibly an offer has been made close to or above this clause but not accepted immediately. Sporting have released to the press about us and City being interested trying to get us to bid against each other above the release clause, ala Fred and Sanchez, where we seem to be trying to gazump one another.

Bruno just wants to leave Sporting having been stopped last year, and is growing frustrated at the goings on, so his agent has now leaked the release clause, in an attempt to speed up/force the move?

That's my guess anyway.
Click to expand...
I don't see city prioritising a player like fernandes right now. Theyll be after at least one holding player and forward players if it's true about Mahrez, Gabriel Jesus and even sane wanting to leave. The links to João Felix and Rodrigo would make more sense.
 
SportingCP96 said:
Pretty much especially with agent leaking the news about the clause which before hand was not known to the public.
Click to expand...

Could also be a tactic to hurry us up. Anyway, it would be criminal if Woodward was balking at the price, Bruno isn't even expensive according to modern day standards.
 
70m is big money. Sure his stats are staggering yet let us not forget it's a league in which even Rojo looked decent in it
 
Wait, his release clause is 35m? I thought it was 100m? Where is this news from?
 
Scholsey2004 said:
I don't see city prioritising a player like fernandes right now. Theyll be after at least one holding player and forward players if it's true about Mahrez, Gabriel Jesus and even sane wanting to leave. The links to João Felix and Rodrigo would make more sense.
Click to expand...

City may be after a CM if Gundogan is not renewing his contract before end of the season. His contract expires in 2020, so City will try to sell him this summer.
 
golden_blunder said:
That’s not what the resident sporting fans are saying. He’s one of those who cancelled his contract after players were attacked in their dressing room. When he re-signed his clause was lowered

https://www.google.ie/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/sport/amp/football/44489158
Click to expand...
Cancelled his contract because of safety concerns but then renegotiated and agreed a new contract by the following day? Doesn't make sense. I'd put money on him being on exactly the same contract with exactly the same release clause.
 
Scholsey2004 said:
Cancelled his contract because of safety concerns but then renegotiated and agreed a new contract by the following day? Doesn't make sense. I'd put money on him being on exactly the same contract with exactly the same release clause.
Click to expand...
Read back in this very thread what the resident sporting fans are saying
 
golden_blunder said:
Read back in this very thread what the resident sporting fans are saying
Click to expand...
Not everything people say on here is accurate. IMO this is one of them. We're not getting Bruno fernandes for €35m euros. Sporting will have sorted this out.
 
Scholsey2004 said:
Not everything people say on here is accurate. IMO this is one of them. We're not getting Bruno fernandes for €35m euros. Sporting will have sorted this out.
Click to expand...
Do you believe that Alderweireld is available for 25m?
 
Scholsey2004 said:
Not everything people say on here is accurate. IMO this is one of them. We're not getting Bruno fernandes for €35m euros. Sporting will have sorted this out.
Click to expand...
It’s on Portuguese media that they are trying to get him to sign a new contract with a €100m release clause in it. So if we do indeed want him we need to strike ASAP
 
Scholsey2004 said:
Not everything people say on here is accurate. IMO this is one of them. We're not getting Bruno fernandes for €35m euros. Sporting will have sorted this out.
Click to expand...
You must not know how incompetent the Sporting board is.
 
golden_blunder said:
It’s on Portuguese media that they are trying to get him to sign a new contract with a €100m release clause in it. So if we do indeed want him we need to strike ASAP
Click to expand...
From what I've read, the Portuguese papers are all saying that he has a €100m release clause.
 
United Pro said:
From what I've read, the Portuguese papers are all saying that he has a €100m release clause.
Click to expand...
I've been web browsing as well and all the sources I'm seeing are talking about a €100m release clause. We'll certainly pay less than that if we get him but €35m isnt happening.
 
United Pro said:
From what I've read, the Portuguese papers are all saying that he has a €100m release clause.
Click to expand...
Scholsey2004 said:
I've been web browsing as well and all the sources I'm seeing are talking about a €100m release clause. We'll certainly pay less than that if we get him but €35m isnt happening.
Click to expand...
I can't access A Bola or Record's archive or premium content but there was a screencap mentioning a €35 million clause because Fernandes agreed an “emergency deal” with the club following the whole Bruno de Carvalho fiasco (which led to the likes of Dost, Gelson, Patricio, Carvalho also terminating their contracts with Sporting and Gelson eventually agreeing a free agent deal with Atlético). Apparently, this was all confirmed by his agent, too.

Capture.png


Though if Bruno does leave, he might just renegotiate a slight increment as a gentlemen's agreement to ensure that Sporting aren't fleeced (they have already lost important players for peanuts and supposedly aren't in very robust financial shape). A figure approaching Bernardo Silva's €50 million move from Monaco would be fair value in the current market.
 
Invictus said:
I can't access A Bola or Record's archive or premium content but there was a screencap mentioning a €35 million clause because Fernandes agreed an “emergency deal” with the club following the whole Bruno de Carvalho fiasco (which led to the likes of Dost, Gelson, Patricio, Carvalho also terminating their contracts with Sporting and Gelson eventually agreeing a free agent deal with Atlético). Apparently, this was all confirmed by his agent, too.

Capture.png


Though if Bruno does leave, he might just renegotiate a slight increment as a gentlemen's agreement to ensure that Sporting aren't fleeced (they have already lost important players for peanuts and supposedly aren't in very robust financial shape). A figure approaching Bernardo Silva's €50 million move from Monaco would be fair value in the current market.
Click to expand...
Fair for who really. He is worth more then 50M in todays markets. You see average perm players going for stupid money.
 
SportingCP96 said:
Fair for who really. He is worth more then 50M in todays markets. You see average perm players going for stupid money.
Click to expand...
You're right, transfer fees have skyrocketed in general — we signed Fred for a comparable amount of money and he hasn't made a considerable impact, and even a youngster like Militão went for €50 million from Porto. So it would not be a very fair deal for Sporting Club (more like a small bonus), and they should ideally ask for more if the reported clause is updated.

However, I was talking only from a United supporter's perspective — it would be fair value figure for us, because Bruno is not the cleanest fit for the current team given Pogba's presence as a #10/#8, and I wouldn't want to spend more than €50 million on him unless we change our style quite significantly or Pogba leaves in the summer market:

https://www.lequipe.fr/Football/Art...2?hootPostID=3bc8981bd5a25fbaf52d31d28ddecec7
 
SportingCP96 said:
Fair for who really. He is worth more then 50M in todays markets. You see average perm players going for stupid money.
Click to expand...
We'll assuming the release clause is in fact now €35m then €50m would be incredibly fair. That's 15m in good will.
 
devilish said:
70m is big money. Sure his stats are staggering yet let us not forget it's a league in which even Rojo looked decent in it
Click to expand...

Decent is the right word. Rojo never impressed that much, even if you ask Sporting fans. The Man Utd offer just come out of the blue, because he actually had a quite irregular season that year.
 
André Dominguez said:
Decent is the right word. Rojo never impressed that much, even if you ask Sporting fans. The Man Utd offer just come out of the blue, because he actually had a quite irregular season that year.
Click to expand...
More importantly the 'good world cup' curse.
 
JJ12 said:
More importantly the 'good world cup' curse.
Click to expand...

Milan Baros career peak is still probably Euro 2004. International squads competitions sometimes just have random regens stepping up during that competition, just to return to their own selves at the new club who got impressed by their performances at Euro/World Cup/Copa Ameria/African Cup/etc
 
Scholsey2004 said:
We'll assuming the release clause is in fact now €35m then €50m would be incredibly fair. That's 15m in good will.
Click to expand...
35M because of the interim president. 35M 50M is peanuts for the best player in the league.
 
SportingCP96 said:
35M because of the interim president. 35M 50M is peanuts for the best player in the league.
Click to expand...

A 3rd tier league though in fairness, the buyer is taking a huge risk that the player can step up to a much faster, more physically demanding and much more competitive league, players from better leagues have moved for less.
 
Devil may care said:
A 3rd tier league though in fairness, the buyer is taking a huge risk that the player can step up to a much faster, more physically demanding and much more competitive league, players from better leagues have moved for less.
Click to expand...
I would say 2nd tier considering our main clubs regularly go far in Europe and we are a very defensive league so players with good numbers are usually the business.

Look at the dutch league they are an actual third tier league where no defense is played and you can't really Judge a player based on there numbers there.

Either way in todays market signing the best player in the 6th best league in the world 35M would be nothing. Look at Militao who in only one season in Europe went for 50M.

Also reports again in Portugal today of Man City and PSG interest in Fernandes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.