Are we allowed to agree to sign players outside of the window?
Wut? You do know McTominay is pretty much 1st name on the team sheet when fit? Hes been brilliant this season and we havent looked the best in midfield without him.
I think it's pretty evident that our first choice XI for next season, if no transfers in or out but everyone healthy (so basically our current squad with no injuries) is:
Rashford-Martial-James
---------------Pogba-------------
-------Fred---------McTominay
but that's still no better than a 5th-6th place team if everyone stays healthy.
Pogba and Rashford are definitely good enough but the others need competition. McTominay and James I think would be our 5th CM and 3rd winger if we had the squad we need to be getting 75-80 points and competing for 2nd or 3rd, never mind putting up a 90 point season and competing for the Prem.
Striker-Martial
Rashford-
RW-James-Greenwood
Pogba-Fred-#
10-
DM-McTominay
Nobody else has shown they're good enough to be in our first team, though one of Gomes or Chong could be the 12th guy in the front group who gets cup and bench minutes, like a lot of teams do with a talented youngster.
If Fernandes signs, I'd say he's the #10 even if he can play deeper or wider and we're missing a proper #6, RW and striker.
In order of priority of "first choice" players we need to upgrade on, I do think Fred vs Martial vs McTominay vs James is a good question. I lean towards Fred and the energy he's provided this season. Martial has the most talent but I'd throw James ahead of him if Rashford wasn't playing well at LW, but James hasn't looked quite as dangerous a goal threat on the right. McTominay has done well this year but he's not really a proven #6 (though I think that's his best position considering his size and his strengths and weaknesses as a passer) and it's unclear if he's good enough on the ball to play further forward for us. He walks into the team at the moment as a competent all-around midfielder, but going forward, if I was planning out the squad I'd have him as the backup #6 and #8 to a proper DM we sign and either Bruno or a new midfielder who has the ball skills to play further forward.