BBC: United hold talks with Mourinho

Would you be happy to see Jose Mourinho become next United manager?


  • Total voters
    1,749
Status
Not open for further replies.
First or third being the other great one?

I'd have it as one great season (2nd one), one good considering it was first season, and one very poor one.

The first season, +100 goals and 92pts, they are only 4pts from Barcelona. The next season Barcelona register 91 pts.
 
There is obviously something wrong with chelsea but the results mourinho was getting in the first half of the season was just shocking. I mean LVG is bad but what Maureen did with Chelsea that is in a league of its own. That it hapoened after they were champions that makes it even worse. If a manager then cant have the full support of his players I have serious questions about his people management skills.

He is a very antagonizing person and if things arent going his way he can be outright toxic. His decisions in the transfermarket are outright weird, alienating a player like KDB in the proces. He is not a manager that likes to give young players a chance and exciting young players is about the only good thing about united atm.

There are plenty of reaso.s why maureen isnt an obvious choice for the job. Also there are other alternatives out there than eitjer LVG, Giggs or Maureen.

This has been said multiple times (about him not giving youth a chance), but look at the clubs he has been at, 2 of them especially. Chelsea and Real Madrid have the most trigger happy owners in Abrhamovic and Perez ever. They demand instant success and maybe that's why he didn't want to risk it. I fully support that when he comes here he will be given the licence to bring in youth more and will do that.
 
This has been said multiple times (about him not giving youth a chance), but look at the clubs he has been at, 2 of them especially. Chelsea and Real Madrid have the most trigger happy owners in Abrhamovic and Perez ever. They demand instant success and maybe that's why he didn't want to risk it. I fully support that when he comes here he will be given the licence to bring in youth more and will do that.
I agree. I wouldn't base any managers success or lack of after managing those two clubs.
 
The first season, +100 goals and 92pts, they are only 4pts from Barcelona. The next season Barcelona register 91 pts.
Can't believe a 92pt season with 100+ goals, winning the Copa del Rey (after 2 trophyless seasons if you ignore the supercopa which I assume is like a community shield) and reaching the semi final of the CL for the first time in 7 years is now only considered only a good season and not great!

Mourinho seems to be held to extremely harsh standards
 
The first season, +100 goals and 92pts, they are only 4pts from Barcelona. The next season Barcelona register 91 pts.

Pellegrini was sacked for getting 96 points the season before. They both did a decent job but the points total is deceiving - getting above 90 points in England is incredible but getting it with Real Madrid in La Liga isn't an amazing achievement, it's expected.
 
Can't believe a 92pt season with 100+ goals, winning the Copa del Rey (after 2 trophyless seasons if you ignore the supercopa which I assume is like a community shield) and reaching the semi final of the CL for the first time in 7 years is now only considered only a good season and not great!

Mourinho seems to be held to extremely harsh standards

Maybe it is because before Madrid he was seen as the one living being able to stop Barcelona but when people realized that he couldn't, they decided that it was because he wasn't great anymore instead of acknowledging that Barcelona are freakishly good.
 
Pellegrini was sacked for getting 96 points the season before. They both did a decent job but the points total is deceiving - getting above 90 points in England is incredible but getting it with Real Madrid in La Liga isn't an amazing achievement, it's expected.

Pellegrini had a a great season and he was sacked because Perez considered that his personality wasn't special enough for Madrid.
 
Can't believe a 92pt season with 100+ goals, winning the Copa del Rey (after 2 trophyless seasons if you ignore the supercopa which I assume is like a community shield) and reaching the semi final of the CL for the first time in 7 years is now only considered only a good season and not great!

Mourinho seems to be held to extremely harsh standards
Some people even want to blame him for the incompetence of Benitez, apparently Rafa did so badly because Jose burnt out the players winning Serie A's only Treble ever.
 
Pellegrini had a a great season and he was sacked because Perez considered that his personality wasn't special enough for Madrid.

I think he didn't deserve to be sacked but great is too much. Barcelona got 100 points without a manager for the half the season, it's easy enough to rack up the points with the amount of money they've spent on their squad at Madrid and Barça.

Mourinho had a good season, mostly for getting Madrid to a further stage of the Champions League than they'd reached for a while, but I don't think it was a great one.
 
Pellegrini was sacked for getting 96 points the season before. They both did a decent job but the points total is deceiving - getting above 90 points in England is incredible but getting it with Real Madrid in La Liga isn't an amazing achievement, it's expected.
Let's ignore the small problem of going out of the CL in early March.
 
Pellegrini was sacked for getting 96 points the season before. They both did a decent job but the points total is deceiving - getting above 90 points in England is incredible but getting it with Real Madrid in La Liga isn't an amazing achievement, it's expected.
It's not as easy as you make it out to be. Barcelona during this period have been one of the best club teams of all time so maybe it has changed the perception. Their points are the ones in the brackets

76 - Cappello (76)
85 - Cappello (67)
78 - Schuster/Ramos (87)
96 - Pelegrini (99)
92 - Mourinho (96)
100 - Mourinho (91)
85 - Mourinho (100)
87 - Ancellotti (87)
 
I think he didn't deserve to be sacked but great is too much. Barcelona got 100 points without a manager for the half the season, it's easy enough to rack up the points with the amount of money they've spent on their squad at Madrid and Barça.

Mourinho had a good season, mostly for getting Madrid to a further stage of the Champions League than they'd reached for a while, but I don't think it was a great one.

What's he supposed to do?

He lost out in the league and champions league to one of the greatest sides ever.

Even Fergie would have struggled against them. But carry on Bob trying to put his achievements down.
 
What's he supposed to do?

He lost out in the league and champions league to one of the greatest sides ever.

Even Fergie would have struggled against them. But carry on Bob trying to put his achievements down.

I'm not putting anything down. I said he did a good job in his first season.

There's a different between a fair evaluation and rewriting history to arselick. He did about as much as could have been expected in his first year, hence it was good. Not going beyond expectations isn't great.
 
Because I predicted this shit season before it happened. When he got to Chelsea. Because I don't see Mourinho as being a manager with a long term plan. At all. He will throw everything at the current season. He manipulates his players into utter cocks, gives them this hatred for everyone else and runs them into the ground.

He would come next year, spend millions, get rid of some talented players who weren't up to his standard right now and then in two years when they're all fecking sick of the absolute cretin he will leave and we will all ask "was it worth it?"
Rediculous.
 
Ranieri did a good job and laid the foundations but Mourinho turned that Chelsea side into a machine.
Probably true but could we say the same for Mourinho and le decima for Madrid. What about the foundation SAF left for Moyes, Houlier for Benitez, Rogers for Klopp. Every manager leaves something for the next wether it's a foundation for success or failure and I think it's kind of irrelevant when talking about the success of one person.
You are dead right, Mourinho turned them in to an organized machine after the scattergun approach to signings when Abramovich came in. That is his quality but clubs like Chelsea and Madrid cannot sustain this because some players are more important then the manager in the eyes of the owner or president.
I do feel United is set up perfectly for what Mourinho has been searching for, a big reason why he has always been respectful and complimentary towards us. He will find a home here and will uphold the traditions of this club. We are very lucky and the future is bright.
 
Well Mourinho/Chelsea and Liverpool/Barca obviously despise each other.

Liverpool stopped Mourinho 's Chelsea from reaching a CL final twice.

Mourinho stopped Liverpool in 2014 from winning their 1st league in 24 years at a time when they actually looked unstoppable.

Chelsea and Barca also have enough CL history between them.

Barca advanced to CL final in 2011 by beating Mourinho 's Madrid in semis.

Barca Won 2 league titles while he was at Madrid, he also won 1.

He won the CDR in 2011 and as a result stopped Barca from winning another treble

And the most crucial one:
He stopped Barca reaching the CL final in 2010 when a potential Barca win in the final would have meant Barca winning a CL in Bernabeu AND winning 3 CLs in a row.

A bit funny actually all that.
So a lot of subjective opinions can result when these parties comment on each other.
 
Everyone reacts differently. A supposed excellent man manager like Mourinho seems like he's very poor at working with players who don't have the same personality as him...no? If he was as good at managing people as everyone says he would be able to work with players like Lukaku and De Bruyne, not cast them aside at the first opportunity.
Same with Ferguson and Pogba, Benitez and Alonso, Wenger and Van Persie, Rogers and Suarez. I could honestly on forever. De Bruyne probably should of been kept but Chelsea cashed in, something they have been doing very regularly the last few years. Lukaku's performance yesterday said it all, very good young player but his goals and best games came playing for West Brom and Everton, what does that tell you about his level at this moment in time.
 
Jose's first order of business should be a sit down with Dave to tell him he's going nowhere before those Madrid twats get in his ear at the Euro's.
Or sell him for a world record, 90 million should do it. Worth it in my opinion as David will win them more games than Bale.
 
I despise him but no one has really given a reasonable reply to why a manager would prefer Demba Ba and co to Lukaku or Oscar to De Bruyne.
Steve Gerrard Gerrard
He slipped on his fecking arse
He gave it to Demba Ba
Steve Gerrard Gerrard.

That.Is.Why.Mr.Loblaw.
 
Just to settle my curiousity.....

If Mourinho becomes United manager, does that mean there will be United supporters on here, that actually like a Liverpool manager above a United one?

:wenger:
 
Just to settle my curiousity.....

If Mourinho becomes United manager, does that mean there will be United supporters on here, that actually like a Liverpool manager above a United one?

:wenger:
It's not hard

If Gary glitter managed Liverpool it would same answer over Jose for me
 
Or sell him for a world record, 90 million should do it. Worth it in my opinion as David will win them more games than Bale.
Not for a GK. He probably has a 30 million release clause after that debacle last summer.
 
Just to settle my curiousity.....

If Mourinho becomes United manager, does that mean there will be United supporters on here, that actually like a Liverpool manager above a United one?

:wenger:

Brave new world..
 
Just to settle my curiousity.....

If Mourinho becomes United manager, does that mean there will be United supporters on here, that actually like a Liverpool manager above a United one?

:wenger:
Presumably that is already the case with the clowns that want United to lose the Cup final and/or top 4 place so Van Gaal gets sacked?
 
Sorry but, I find that ridiculous.

It's a bit of a stupid over exaggeration to prove a point for certain!.

Imagine if Rafa or Dalglish became our manager.

Don't tell me, some would still prefer them to Mourinho! :lol:
 
It's not hard

If Gary glitter managed Liverpool it would same answer over Jose for me
How come you hate him so much?

The only manager I find annoying was Dalglish for his behaviour in the Evra-Suarez thing. I can't really remember Mourinho doing anything to make him so hated unless you are a Liverpool, Barcelona or Arsenal fan where the list is probably quite long

I find Mourinho extremely likeable, I don't understand the hate towards him. He's a character, he's not boring, and he's a great manager.
Same here. He's always been respectful to United and he is funny

 
Not for a GK. He probably has a 30 million release clause after that debacle last summer.
If Chelsea can get 50 mil for David Luiz Ed can get at least 60 for De Gea. We are selling our best player after all, a truly world class keeper with 15 years ahead of him.
 
It's not hard

If Gary glitter managed Liverpool it would same answer over Jose for me
You are saying you would rather a child molester instead of probably the best manager in the world to manage our club? Never mind Rashford and TFM, the 12 year olds would be on the bench, how is that for giving youth a chance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.