Bastian Schweinsteiger | Signed for MUFC - confirmed.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I heard about the issues he had with Pep, but others at the club have had those problems too, which isn't surprising given their tactical changes. I didn't think it'd be enough for a club legend and the club to part ways. Bayern is pretty no-nonsense about their salary structure and about unhappy players. Nonetheless, it seems they would've done more if he was still the Schweinsteiger of old. Ultimately, we don't know what happened behind the scenes though.

We are not getting that player but I do hope we'll get an experienced leader with good skills on the ball that works his arse off and can continue to do that for a season or 3.
 
Because it doesn't matter who we sign some people just like a good moan!
Herrera - Why didn't we sign Fabregas
Blind - Too Dutch
Rojo - shit league
Darmian - who?
Schweinsteiger - too old
Di Maria - too expensive
Otamendi - too short

It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.
 
Schweinsteiger got back from a long World Cup and barely had time off before starting the new season. Also, the role he has been playing for Bayern requires a lot more running than Carrick's role which probably led to more injuries.

And so did another 25 German players. They didn't suffer the same feat. Add the physicality if the English game to his problems and we've got another Hargreaves!

In all seriousness though Schweini is fantastic but I doubt he'll have the impact people expect and are overly excited about.
 
Central midfielders peak at around the age of 29 and remain good for quite a while. Just look at Scholes, Pirlo, Xabi Alonso, Xavi and Carrick just to get some perspective. Scholes and Pirlo at 34 were still 2 of the best midfielders in the world.

I just don't get how someone can be against getting Schweinsteiger for 13m and 135k a week.

People are just worried that it might imply not getting schneiderlin who would represent the better investment with an eye on the future.

Also I don't think anyone is against it but rather temporing the enthousiasm a little bit.
 
Herrera - Why didn't we sign Fabregas
Blind - Too Dutch
Rojo - shit league
Darmian - who?
Schweinsteiger - too old
Di Maria - too expensive
Otamendi - too short

It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.
I know, we just have to laugh at them. I for one am very excited at our new found activity!
 
Herrera - Why didn't we sign Fabregas
Blind - Too Dutch
Rojo - shit league
Darmian - who?
Schweinsteiger - too old
Di Maria - too expensive
Otamendi - too short

It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.

I lliked the signings of Herrera, Blind and Rojo. I also liked bringing in di Maria, just wasn't a fan of the high fee we paid for him.
 
And so did another 25 German players. They didn't suffer the same feat. Add the physicality if the English game to his problems and we've got another Hargreaves!

In all seriousness though Schweini is fantastic but I doubt he'll have the impact people expect and are overly excited about.

I second this and I hope I'll be wrong about it
 
Herrera - Why didn't we sign Fabregas
Blind - Too Dutch
Rojo - shit league
Darmian - who?
Schweinsteiger - too old
Di Maria - too expensive
Otamendi - too short

It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.

Messi - he's not as good as Ronaldo.
Ronaldo - he's not as good as Messi.
 
And so did another 25 German players. They didn't suffer the same feat. Add the physicality if the English game to his problems and we've got another Hargreaves!

In all seriousness though Schweini is fantastic but I doubt he'll have the impact people expect and are overly excited about.
I won't be surprised if he picks up a few minor injuries but at least we've got a pretty much equally good alternative to our most important player bar De Gea, Carrick. Having a long vacation should help a lot.
 
Stop comparing Falcao to Schweinsteiger. Falcao had a major injury.

Only a year ago, Schweinsteiger on his own in midfield carried Germany through to the final. With Khedira and Kramer getting injured.
 
Herrera - Why didn't we sign Fabregas
Blind - Too Dutch
Rojo - shit league
Darmian - who?
Schweinsteiger - too old
Di Maria - too expensive
Otamendi - too short

It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.

Messi - too old
 
I'am not saying they can't be good player but still they are old and in the last years of their career. If you transfer them you aren't looking focussed on the long term and I don't like signings that aren't focussed on the long term.

I think if you invest so much money you need to be able to look at 5 or 6 years atleast for it to make sense. RVP was similar but in the end was worth it because of that amazin first season. I hope Bastian will be here longer, I hope he'll be better for us and I hope we'll also win something with him but signing a schneiderlin that could be at the club for 7 or 8 years makes more sense to me.

Success breeds success. A player like Schweinsteiger can lift us to another level and lead us to titles.


The players he leads to success can then go on and do the same for the next generation.


Winning is an art in itself, the psychology behind it, getting yourself and team over the line is huge. Fergie recognised it and it's why he kept his winners around and it's why he put emphasis on cups as insignificant as the League Cup.

We need to get back to winning ways and having winners like him around will only help that. Even if it's for just 2 or 3 years.
 
Herrera - Why didn't we sign Fabregas
Blind - Too Dutch
Rojo - shit league
Darmian - who?
Schweinsteiger - too old
Di Maria - too expensive
Otamendi - too short

It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.

No issue with Herrera, Blind , Rojo or Darmian (in fact very optimistic about that one)

Di Maria was expensive but over the moon we got him because he was one of the best players in the world that season and we needed such a world class signing. Just unfortunate that he hasn't shown any of it so far this season which just leaves you with the big price tag.

Otamendi is my preferred CB signing so wouldn't have any complaints on that one either in fact I'd be over the moon if we'd announce his signings as we can use a good cb.

Schweinsteiger I love the fact he will be a united player but I really have my reservations about him being 31 years old and the injurries which always end up being worse at our club for any player.
 
I can see it already,things not going well for him,some of those who are over the moon at the moment,will go full "No wonder they sold him to us" "20 mil.(you know coz its bigger number,more impact) for this,well done Woody you clown",in case we dont get Morgan "Instead of 25-30 mil.,we wasted 20 mil.(again no mention euros) for someone ready for retirement" etc.
 
And so did another 25 German players. They didn't suffer the same feat. Add the physicality if the English game to his problems and we've got another Hargreaves!

In all seriousness though Schweini is fantastic but I doubt he'll have the impact people expect and are overly excited about.

If you look at the injury rates in the Bundesliga and at the running datas that increased by a mile in the big pressing league Bundesliga the last seasons it might not be a change when it means physicality...

When I look at the running data the UEFA provides after the CL matches it seems that the Bundesliga is atleast on a similar level now. Atleast that is what Alonso told after some weeks playing here. That is a development of the recent three-four years. And in the World Cup the German players were the fittest...
 
Stop comparing Falcao to Schweinsteiger. Falcao had a major injury.

Only a year ago, Schweinsteiger on his own in midfield carried Germany through to the final. With Khedira and Kramer getting injured.

I never compared the two.
 
Success breeds success. A player like Schweinsteiger can lift us to another level and lead us to titles.


The players he leads to success can then go on and do the same for the next generation.


Winning is an art in itself, the psychology behind it, getting yourself and team over the line is huge. Fergie recognised it and it's why he kept his winners around and it's why he put emphasis on cups as insignificant as the League Cup.

We need to get back to winning ways and having winners like him around will only help that. Even if it's for just 2 or 3 years.

That's pretty much how i see it.
 
It keeps going on and on. :mad: They would find something to moan about Messi as well. I'm sure of it.

Messi - why get him when we could have got Ronaldo who actually loves us
Sign Ronnie and
Ronaldo - hes too selfish and only thinks about himself.
 
I can see it already,things not going well for him,some of those who are over the moon at the moment,will go full "No wonder they sold him to us" "20 mil.(you know coz its bigger number,more impact) for this,well done Woody you clown",in case we dont get Morgan "Instead of 25-30 mil.,we wasted 20 mil.(again no mention euros) for someone ready for retirement" etc.

No chance.

There's a difference between him and someone like Hargreaves/Falcao. Even if he is (god forbid) not at his best/kind of injured, he's a world cup winner and a true leader who has been at the highest peak of world and European football. All of that takes a special mentality. Our squad is severely lacking true winners. For that he'll have a very positive impact without even being at his best.

However, I don't thin he's past it at all.
 
Guys I'm coming and bringing my warrior personality and world cup winning attitude to the dressing room. I'll whip these boys into shape. Me and Carrick will kick ass and take names all day long baby!
 
We all knew he wanted to come to LVG since he started emulating LVG and RVP's hairdo

bastian-schweinsteiger.jpg

ivanovic-schweinsteiger.jpg
 
No chance.

There's a difference between him and someone like Hargreaves/Falcao. Even if he is (god forbid) not at his best/kind of injured, he's a world cup winner and a true leader who has been at the highest peak of world and European football. All of that takes a special mentality. Our squad is severely lacking true winners. For that he'll have a very positive impact without even being at his best.

However, I don't thin he's past it at all.
No.
 
That is old for me

Genuinely not a fan of signing players over 30

Meh, 29-32 is the prime of most players. Pirlo was by many considered to old for Juve but was a fantastic signing who led us to 4 league titles and a CL final. Class is class.
 
I am so pumped for this, even at 30 years old and a recently poor injury record. This is one of the classiest holding midfielders around, and when you know the Bayern fans would be pretty pissed to see him leave is when we are heading in the right direction.

Short term solution perhaps, but bringing in his experience into Champions league after a year out would be just what we need.
 
Gotta love the FM generation. Once a player hits 30 he suddenly loses all footballing ability and becomes completely useless.
 
Scholes' best performances for us came after he was 30, imo -- at least, the Scholes who became the playmaker that we all remember fondly today.
 
Meh, 29-32 is the prime of most players. Pirlo was by many considered to old for Juve but was a fantastic signing who led us to 4 league titles and a CL final. Class is class.
A big part of Bosstian's game is linked to his physical attributes, he's nothing like Pirlo.
 
He had one of the most awesome WAGS and is now with Ana. Some guys have it all :(
 
Gotta love the FM generation. Once a player hits 30 he suddenly loses all footballing ability and becomes completely useless.

He is certainly no longer at his physical peak and in 9 out of 10 cases in general decline as a footballer. Not sure why this would come as a surprise to anyone.
 
In summary then, our central + attacking midfield options have gone from being Anderson, Giggs, Carrick, Scholes, Cleverley, Fletcher, Powell and Kagawa in 12/13 to (potentially) being:

Mata, Carrick, Blind, Herrera, Fellaini, Schweinsteiger and Schneiderlin plus Di Maria and Januzaj who could potentially play in some sort or free attacking role behind a striker.

Not bad at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.