Jordan_mufc
Full Member
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2016
- Messages
- 507
Good to take our time with him. If we can get him fit for the end of the season he could win us 6 points or so, which could be crucial
Absolute bollock of a post. He's been good for us this season when he's played(which has unfortunately not been as much as we wanted) and we've played exponentially better as a team. If anything the less he plays, the more negativity people like you bring and sell this narrative that he's an absolutely mediocre player.I swear he's a prime example of a player that gets better the less he plays. He's always injured and, when he's not, he's largely ineffective. He's an utterly pointless player at this stage.
Complete twat of a post as he's really not been. He's a useless waste of a shirt and you Martial FC folk are extremely tiresome.Absolute bollock of a post. He's been good for us this season when he's played(which has unfortunately not been as much as we wanted) and we've played exponentially better as a team. If anything the less he plays, the more negativity people like you bring and sell this narrative that he's an absolutely mediocre player.
I swear he's a prime example of a player that gets better the less he plays. He's always injured and, when he's not, he's largely ineffective. He's an utterly pointless player at this stage.
I guess you can both draw your own conclusions from these:Absolute bollock of a post. He's been good for us this season when he's played(which has unfortunately not been as much as we wanted) and we've played exponentially better as a team. If anything the less he plays, the more negativity people like you bring and sell this narrative that he's an absolutely mediocre player.
These stats look pretty average and pretty much mirror what he shows on the pitch. His dribbling is no longer much good, he is below average where goals and xG are concerned, doesn't shoot much and is below average as far as key passes go. He doesn't lose possession much and his passing stats are good, mostly because he's not the most adventurous of passers. I'm sure ETH would like him as an option - the more bodies, the better - but I am also sure he won't get a sniff next season.I guess you can both draw your own conclusions from these:
Anthony Martial Scouting Report for Last 365 Days Men's Big 5 Leagues, UCL, UEL | FBref.com
Anthony Martial | Manchester United | xG | Shot Map | Goal stats | Understat.com
His finishing has definitely deteriorated this season but overall his contributions are quite high and I'm sure Ten Hag would love to have him fit.
He is in the 79th percentile for assists, 86th for progressive passes, 87th for passes in the final third, 89th for throughballs. What do you mean he's not the most adventurous of passers?These stats look pretty average and pretty much mirror what he shows on the pitch. His dribbling is no longer much good, he is below average where goals and xG are concerned, doesn't shoot much and is below average as far as key passes go. He doesn't lose possession much and his passing stats are good, mostly because he's not the most adventurous of passers. I'm sure ETH would like him as an option - the more bodies, the better - but I am also sure he won't get a sniff next season.
Below average for key passes, which are a better gauge of adventurous passing than throughballs, no? Also, the way we play means that by nature he plays a lot of passes in the final third. DOesn't mean they're adventurous. As for dribbling, 46 percentile for successful take on %, 30th for tackled during take on, 36 for miscontrolled. All your 'dribble' stats show is that he can run unopposed with the ball.He is in the 79th percentile for assists, 86th for progressive passes, 87th for passes in the final third, 89th for throughballs. What do you mean he's not the most adventurous of passers?
And on his dribbling? 97th percentile on carries into final third, 87th on carries into the penalty area. What?
Are you sure you understand what you are looking at?
Honestly, not sure how you can look at these stats:Below average for key passes, which are a better gauge of adventurous passing than throughballs, no? Also, the way we play means that by nature he plays a lot of passes in the final third. DOesn't mean they're adventurous. As for dribbling, 46 percentile for successful take on %, 30th for tackled during take on, 36 for miscontrolled. All your 'dribble' stats show is that he can run unopposed with the ball.
The problem is it's a tiny sample size heavily influenced by some good sub appearances.Honestly, not sure how you can look at these stats:
And say that he is not good at dribbling.
As for passing, would it make you feel more convinced if you look at his stats for the PL only (link and previous screenshots were for top 5 leagues):
Even in key passes he is above average for PL among forwards.
I think that kind of stats profile is pretty amazing, to be honest...
Martial, 2020/21, Premier League:The problem is it's a tiny sample size heavily influenced by some good sub appearances.
If fit, I think Martial would be a massive difference for us. I still don't think he'd be good enough, though he has individual games that obviously are good enough.
Oh Tony!Martial, 2020/21, Premier League:
He has always been great for us. Injuries (and Mourinho) have been the problem.
Yeah. Those numbers are meh. Quantity of passes doesn't matter a whole lot, it's what he does with them. Yes we know he links up and holds up well. But he needs more than that. These stats don't tell me injuries are the only problem. His shot creating actions are pretty shit, his his passes in final third, xG, xAG, key passes, passes into the box, are all unspectacular.Martial, 2020/21, Premier League:
He has always been great for us. Injuries (and Mourinho) have been the problem.
You are literally ignoring his goal creating stats here. Not sure why.Yeah. Those numbers are meh. Quantity of passes doesn't matter a whole lot, it's what he does with them. Yes we know he links up and holds up well. But he needs more than that. These stats don't tell me injuries are the only problem. His shot creating actions are pretty shit, his his passes in final third, xG, xAG, key passes, passes into the box, are all unspectacular.
Of course, he would improve us massively this season if he were fit. I've always liked him, but there's more than just injuries being the issue for him. His numbers point to a good and nothing more forward. Right now we have basically relegation level output out of that position, so of course that would help...
Shot creating action more consistent, goal creating has a lot more variance based on just some clinical finishing or bad goalkeeping.You are literally ignoring his goal creating stats here. Not sure why.
Anyways, I think we are in agreement: we need him fit!
He is dispossessed more often than not when he tries to take people on. Most of his take on are unsuccessful. His ball carrying has him above most but that doesn't make him a good dribbler. To me, being a good dribbler means being able to take on a player successfully, a metric where he demonstrably falls short. Do you think those ball carrying stats mean that he's a good dribbler, despite the below average takeon success rate?Honestly, not sure how you can look at these stats:
And say that he is not good at dribbling.
As for passing, would it make you feel more convinced if you look at his stats for the PL only (link and previous screenshots were for top 5 leagues):
Even in key passes he is above average for PL among forwards.
I think that kind of stats profile is pretty amazing, to be honest...
Martial, 2020/21, Premier League:
He has always been great for us. Injuries (and Mourinho) have been the problem.
May I introduce you to the Phil Jones 2022/23 Performance thread.Does this performance thread have the highest pages per perfomance ratio? What's the cafe record?
We are stuck with him there’s no club going to take a chance on him never mind try to match what we are paying him
I always supported AM. I’m done with him now. I hope to be proved wrong but Rashford kicked on he didn’t. I think we’d all agree his potential at 18 has not been met.