So our attack and midfield has the following 23 or under:
- Rashford - 21
- Martial - 23
- James - 21
- Greenwood - 17
- Chong - 19
- Gomes - 18
- Pereira - 23
- Mctominay - 22
Then Lingard, Pogba and Fred are 26, with Mata being 31. Find me a younger midfield and attacking group. We've played 3 games, with James, Martial and Rashford as our starting front 3 and the midfield has McTominay replacing Matic so far. That's literally the definition of giving the youth a chance.
You make some great points if this was a discussion of quantity, not quality.
United do not operate in a vacuum where the world isn’t littered with numerous youth talents; I’m no football scout but I would be amazed if there are not multiple players 23 or under [the maximum age you listed] that could improve our attack & midfield.
At no point do I say giving youth a chance is a bad thing. I like getting rid & giving players opportunities.
I just don’t buy that we are so focused on youth that our vast scouting system could only identify James & Longstaff as potential signings this summer.
My Mata point is being somewhat facetious but if we are so invested youth all of a sudden then redistribution of his wages etc. surely make sense. You don’t win anything with kids but Mata isn’t such a leader that you overpay him to stay imo.
I doubt I’d be able to find you a younger attack/midfield group with the same lofty ambitions as ours but I can damn sure find you multiple better ones of all ages.
The Glazers really have played a blinder when age suddenly comes before quality.
OgS deserves much better. He was saying we need a finisher heading into the Summer.
Playing youth doesn't mean you play only young players. Also it doesn't mean only academy players counts. James is also young player so is McT, Rashford, Martial.
Making any conclusion after 3 games is silly.
Not sure what you’re attempting to disagree with here.
I didn’t say we should play only youngsters.
I also don’t suggest youth only counts from the academy.
We have pushed a narrative that we are focusing on youth which the majority of the fanbase encourage & have rid ourselves of certain attackers whose roles didn’t justify their wages but then we’ve signed 1 youthful attacker & no one in midfield despite already being light in both departments.
I refuse to believe there were no ‘youngsters’ we could have purchased this summer that would improve the current squads quality & would improve with good coaching over time.
If having an opinion after 3 games is drawing a conclusion I guess we’re both guilty.