Alex Song

Rumours he had fallen out big time with the coaching staff hence why we were keen to get rid. Good passer and tackler but plays like someone who doesn't want or need responsibilities. Goes wondering out of position and made it too easy for the opposition bypass. His best performances came with Arteta mopping up behind him. Always felt we needed someone more disciplined in his role so Had no problem with him leaving, relying on Diaby to regain fitness and replace him was the problem though....



Helped is probably pushing it....

Agree with all of that.

I wanted United to make a move for him last summer - think he'd be perfect alongside the more defensively conscientious Carrick. Song really struck up a good rapport in that final season at Arsenal with van Persie - he was regularly loading the bullets for him. It's amazing how quickly players' stock can fall following one below par season - I'd say United could do a lot worse if Song is looking to get out of Barca.
 
Appears that Song will be heading to Napoli on loan, according to Sky Sports. Rumour it is for 2M with an option to buy 8-10M
 
His performance against Ajax was dreadful. He's been a poor signing IMO.
 
They never do as well after Wenger stops sprinkling the ooffle dust.
 
Most pointless signing of last summer.

And they still haven't bought a proper centerback. Much like us with midfield.
 
Appears that Song will be heading to Napoli on loan, according to Sky Sports. Rumour it is for 2M with an option to buy 8-10M
Wouldn't that mean Barca really lacks squad depth in midfield? What happens if Busquets gets injured?
 
If Song were going for that price then I think we'd be missing a trick not getting him or at least trying to. Just the sort we could do with and would be a proper box to box player and has a good understanding with RVP.
 
If Song were going for that price then I think we'd be missing a trick not getting him or at least trying to. Just the sort we could do with and would be a proper box to box player and has a good understanding with RVP.
Moyes can't even get Fellaini to play for Man Utd - he's got no chance with Song.
 
Do you consider Song a high maintenance player from the manager's point of view?

He's twice the midfielder Fellaini is.
He was under Wenger I wouldn't trust him to produce any of that form elsewhere.
 
Do you consider Song a high maintenance player from the manager's point of view?

He's twice the midfielder Fellaini is.

He wasn't high maintenance in the sense that he was a troublemaker, and is definitely a superior player to Fellaini in almost every respect. Wenger put a lot of time into him though.

His real weakness is positioning.
 
Wouldn't that mean Barca really lacks squad depth in midfield? What happens if Busquets gets injured?

I think it'll mean Mascherano & Roberto will provide cover and that they will sign a CB in the winter window, finally
 
Most pointless signing of last summer.

And they still haven't bought a proper centerback. Much like us with midfield.

Yeah, it was a bad gamble by Tito that never paid off. After the club failed to sign Silva or Javi Martinez, they went to plan C and left with Song. Tip for the future, never go to Plan C, just scrap it and stick to A/B
 
Yeah, it was a bad gamble by Tito that never paid off. After the club failed to sign Silva or Javi Martinez, they went to plan C and left with Song. Tip for the future, never go to Plan C, just scrap it and stick to A/B

To be fair he was coming off an excellent season with the gooners. Easily their best player that year. You got him for a pretty low fee as well. Wouldn't mind having a look at him considering our midfield is absolute toss. Can't imagine he would be any worse than Anderson or Fellaini.
 
To be fair he was coming off an excellent season with the gooners. Easily their best player that year. You got him for a pretty low fee as well. Wouldn't mind having a look at him considering our midfield is absolute toss. Can't imagine he would be any worse than Anderson or Fellaini.
I think Van Persie probably had a strong claim for our best player that season. Song wasn't as good for us as he's made out on here. Koscielny and Arteta were probably both better that season as well. 15m was an ok deal for us and a bad one for Barca.