Remember the geese
Full Member
Scored some nice goals in the academy.He doesn't score goals like Alonso
Scored some nice goals in the academy.He doesn't score goals like Alonso
Depends what you mean. I'd you mean for us then I'd say absolutely not as he's not good enough to play for us currently. If you mean just in general then I absolutely agree, he seems tailor made to play the role Zinchenko plays.
Feels like squad planning wise loaning to Burnley is the best move. Malacia gets another season to prove himself, whilst Fernandez (who is 3.5 years younger) gets a chance to strengthen his case on a side that plays relatively good football in the PL.
If it wasn’t Arsenal up after Forest I’d start hun vs Forest.
However I think we’ll need a rethink now. Probably Martinez LB.
He's not ready at all, if we rely on him then we're in trouble.
We wont rely on him but he's there for cover.He's not ready at all, if we rely on him then we're in trouble.
At his age, he needs to be out on loan. Start Dalot LB and have Martinez as cover, it's not going to do Fernandez any good being sat on our bench until January.We wont rely on him but he's there for cover.
Starting Martinez at LB is not a good idea.At his age, he needs to be out on loan. Start Dalot LB and have Martinez as cover, it's not going to do Fernandez any good being sat on our bench until January.
Starting Martinez at LB is not a good idea.
Also about loan, he's 20, why not give him a shot if all of our LBs are injured.
In any case its probably going to be Dalot at LB anyway until either Shaw or Malacia (where is he) come back.
Exactly that.Starting Martinez at LB will have the same effect as Rashford at CF. He probably can do it, but it will disrupt the balance of the team. Not to mention that he isn't anywhere close to top fitness level so I'd expect him to get beaten quite easily by fast wingers.
We are in trouble relying on Shaw so there's that.He's not ready at all, if we rely on him then we're in trouble.
Yeah, it's quite odd. Apparently Diallo, Mainoo, Hannibal, Fernandez all need additional loans before they can contribute. Despite the fact they all play in positions we are crying out for support in!I swear some will have players out on loan eternally if it was up to them. He is twenty and may have some flaws but we are the same club that played the Da Silva twins at around the same age in deep CL runs and PL title wins.
Not sure where you got Mainoo needed a loan from, what I’ve gotten from Ten Hag interviews is it’s very likely he’d be a regular in the squad if not for the injury. Diallo did nothing in the preseason friendlies, Fernandez is behind 3 other players and Hannibal isn’t ready for top flight football, so loans are the best options for them.Yeah, it's quite odd. Apparently Diallo, Mainoo, Hannibal, Fernandez all need additional loans before they can contribute. Despite the fact they all play in positions we are crying out for support in!
I think hes ready to contribute when we have the ball and are going forward but he will cost us defensively. Best idea to delay the loan/sale and use him from the bench, mostly when we're in a comfortable position and limit the amount of time hes playing where 1 mistake leading to a goal will cost us points.
Starting Martinez at LB will have the same effect as Rashford at CF. He probably can do it, but it will disrupt the balance of the team. Not to mention that he isn't anywhere close to top fitness level so I'd expect him to get beaten quite easily by fast wingers.
Think Martinez will get beat by fast wingers, so would Fernandez, he doesn't have the pace or positioning skills to play LB, I'd say he'll move centrally as his career goes on. We'll play Dalot there anyway.Exactly that.
How come he lacks that given he's a LB?Think Martinez will get beat by fast wingers, so would Fernandez, he doesn't have the pace or positioning skills to play LB, I'd say he'll move centrally as his career goes on. We'll play Dalot there anyway.
Starting Martinez at LB would provide more balance to the team than Fernandez at LB, especially when we push up the pitch.
Think Martinez will get beat by fast wingers, so would Fernandez, he doesn't have the pace or positioning skills to play LB, I'd say he'll move centrally as his career goes on. We'll play Dalot there anyway.
Starting Martinez at LB would provide more balance to the team than Fernandez at LB, especially when we push up the pitch.
Think Martinez will get beat by fast wingers, so would Fernandez, he doesn't have the pace or positioning skills to play LB, I'd say he'll move centrally as his career goes on. We'll play Dalot there anyway.
Starting Martinez at LB would provide more balance to the team than Fernandez at LB, especially when we push up the pitch.
How's that so? I think the "inverted fullback joining midfield" goes out of the window for the next few days anyway. So we will be playing traditional 4231 with fullbacks staying wide. Makes no sense to me to move Martinez around. I'd rather play Lindelof LB than Martinez.Think Martinez will get beat by fast wingers, so would Fernandez, he doesn't have the pace or positioning skills to play LB, I'd say he'll move centrally as his career goes on. We'll play Dalot there anyway.
Starting Martinez at LB would provide more balance to the team than Fernandez at LB, especially when we push up the pitch.
Not every player has the positional sense, even Shaw has lacked it in the past.How come he lacks that given he's a LB?
Where have I argued his attacking abilities aren't his strongest attributes? I haven't. I said his defensive position and pace isn't what's needed of a modern day full back, so like Martinez, he'd also get outpaced by wingers, like I saw when I watched him plenty of times for Preston last season.That's a horrible assessment, his attacking abilities are where he excels and he is very good technically, overlapping and making crosses, CB would be his worst position.
Compared to the modern day full back, I think he still lacks the right pace, especially as he cannot make up for it in positional sense.He's quicker than Martinez. Agree his positioning and acceleration still need work though.
Well that's if we went with the 433, 4231 one of the DM would have to cover Fernandez as he went forward, which would have worked better if we had Fred.How's that so? I think the "inverted fullback joining midfield" goes out of the window for the next few days anyway. So we will be playing traditional 4231 with fullbacks staying wide. Makes no sense to me to move Martinez around. I'd rather play Lindelof LB than Martinez.
Not every player has the positional sense, even Shaw has lacked it in the past.
Where have I argued his attacking abilities aren't his strongest attributes? I haven't. I said his defensive position and pace isn't what's needed of a modern day full back, so like Martinez, he'd also get outpaced by wingers, like I saw when I watched him plenty of times for Preston last season.
Compared to the modern day full back, I think he still lacks the right pace, especially as he cannot make up for it in positional sense.
Well that's if we went with the 433, 4231 one of the DM would have to cover Fernandez as he went forward, which would have worked better if we had Fred.
I do think we'll go with Dalot for now, he's been used there a few times.
I've got it from countless comments on here. Diallo doing nothing in meaningless preseason friendlies being a reason to chuck him back out on loan is exactly the issue. It's mental. Our current right wing options are Antony (who I like but is obviously struggling and should in no way be an undisputed starter), Pellistri, and Sancho who's a left winger. The position is there for the taking. Diallo is regarded as a big prospect, was bought for big money, is 21, and is coming off the back of an excellent and productive loan. This is a really obvious opportune moment to integrate him into the first team.Not sure where you got Mainoo needed a loan from, what I’ve gotten from Ten Hag interviews is it’s very likely he’d be a regular in the squad if not for the injury. Diallo did nothing in the preseason friendlies, Fernandez is behind 3 other players and Hannibal isn’t ready for top flight football, so loans are the best options for them.