If Martial and Shaw are not fully fit, then this line up makes sense. It's the only reason I will justify playing Lukaku.
Darmian is certainly more disciplined than Rojo as an option though he offers less going forward. Dalot can do that while Rashford attacks from the left wing. The two center backs are no brainers if fully fit considering how their pairing was doing before Lindelof got injured. A case can be made for Bailly but his pairing with Smalling and Lindelof has not exactly clicked. So, Smalling and Lindelof for me in this game. The big mystery for me is Mata. My favourite player at the moment. Why did he drop Mata? That beats me. Pace is the only reason I can think of. This Liverpool team is very hardworking and pacy. Maybe that's why Mata is not starting but that also means we will miss his incredible creativity. As for Pogba, well he didn't do enough at Valencia to win back his spot.
On the other hand, if Martial and Shaw are fully fit and Jose has gone for this line up, then I will have to say he has gone nuts.
Anyway, if we lose, it really wouldn't matter which line up he picked, he will get nailed. Let's see if this team can at least play with dignity.