- Joined
- Aug 23, 2014
- Messages
- 305
Like to see Van Gaal's 4-2-3-1 like he did at Bayern and AZ. It was a success formula for him so why not at United.
Like to see Van Gaal's 4-2-3-1 like he did at Bayern and AZ. It was a success formula for him so why not at United.
Same formation with Mata for RVP and Falcao for Wilson if he is fit.--------------------------De Gea------------------------
Rafael---------Smalling---------McNair-----------Shaw
--------------------------Blind---------------------------
---------------Herrera---------Di Maria-----------------
-------------------------Rooney--------------------------
-----------------RVP-------------Wilson------------------
Fellaini has been playing well but Herrera can offer so much more I feel. When Fellaini plays, our whole playing style changes. He doesn't make late runs into the box. He goes up even before the ball is played out from the back. This way our build-up play gets affected. Somehow would like to fit in both of them, but there is just no space for it. Our injury crisis in a way has allowed all our players to get equal game time.Why do you guys want to drop Fellaini ? He is literally perfect for this game to bully Arsenal
We will spank them as we always do. I just know that RVP has a goal in him when we play Arsenal.
That midfield will get torn to shreds and Januzaj starting again
I am beginning to think that the option of Herrera does not work without Rafael being fit. Don't think Valencia offers the same option for Ander to pass to. Valencia would just cross the ball, where Ander and Rafa exchange passes round the edge of the box so Ander can thread the ball through to the strikers.I was discussing this with my Dad on the way back from the match today. I think RvP should start - him scoring against Arsenal almost seems inevitable these days. Mata probably deserves a start and I want Herrera back so badly! Hopefully the international break gives Rafa time to get fit. We miss him bombing forward so much.
Fellaini is a good option against physically strong teams as he helps in the air, but against Arsenal I think we'd be fine without his added height. The quality on the ball, energy and creativity that Herrera brings is way above anything Fellaini can offer so he really should play.Why do you guys want to drop Fellaini ? He is literally perfect for this game to bully Arsenal
Problem is he won't drop RVP. So he will persist with Rooney deeper. Unfortunately, he won't want to upset RVP by dropping him against Arsenal. Remember we have a two week international break coming for other players to get injured. It won't be other teams players, it will be our bloody players.Fellaini is a good option against physically strong teams as he helps in the air, but against Arsenal I think we'd be fine without his added height. The quality on the ball, energy and creativity that Herrera brings is way above anything Fellaini can offer so he really should play.
Basically, players that have to (IMO) play if fit are Rooney, Di maria (middle please), Carrick, Blind, Herrera, Shaw and De Gea. After them I'd definitely keep Valencia in the team but play him on the right, and also bring Mata into it as today he looked excellent when he came on and made the difference in scoring and almost grabbing a second. If Rafael is fit then he walks in behind Valencia, and then whoever is fit for right center back I guess. Smalling will probably get himself injured though he'll be back from suspension, while Jones and Evans might both be back fit. McNair has probably looked more solid then any of them but I doubt he'd play away to Arsenal.
So that would be:
De Gea
??? ??? Blind Shaw
Carrick
Valencia Herrera Di Maria Mata
Rooney
Yeah but 2 games over the break for Netherlands, if RvP fails to perform in those as well there might be hope. Van Gaal could go for the freshness of Mata and Herrera instead of Van Persie who has been off anyways. It's not much to cling on to but it's something. We're looking to get that balance and I think that'd be a brilliant team, and we won't have a balanced team until we stop playing Rooney and Van Persie together. They just don't work.Problem is he won't drop RVP. So he will persist with Rooney deeper. Unfortunately, he won't want to upset RVP by dropping him against Arsenal. Remember we have a two week international break coming for other players to get injured. It won't be other teams players, it will be our bloody players.
I thought LvG had more courage in dropping players tbh. He is as scared of upsettting RVP as Moyes was. I actually think it might do RVP more good having a break than trying to get him to play through his woes. Also after being told that we had lost our identity he seems determined to blood Januzaj and Wilson to prove people wrong, even if it isn't necessarily good for the team. Januzaj has not justified being picked. Wilson I like, but to me if you are going to play him, play him properly or don't. Bringing him on for short periods, when we aren't actually creating chances for him serves no purpose.Yeah but 2 games over the break for Netherlands, if RvP fails to perform in those as well there might be hope. Van Gaal could go for the freshness of Mata and Herrera instead of Van Persie who has been off anyways. It's not much to cling on to but it's something. We're looking to get that balance and I think that'd be a brilliant team, and we won't have a balanced team until we stop playing Rooney and Van Persie together. They just don't work.
As international breaks go, this one is welcome. Hopefully we go into the Arsenal game with more players available than we have now.
I'm having de ja vu from saying this before the last international break, largely concerning the usual suspects.
Can't be more boring than last year, you lot came with no ambition expecting to lose and then perked up a bit when you realised we looked as scared of you as you were of us.Got a feeling this will be a boring one. I think we should be able to beat this lot though.
To be honest depending on who those 5 are it could be a blessing in disguiseGiven our luck, 4 will return and 5 will pick up new injuries
LVG said it was cramp.Been told by a friend that McNair is injured, any truth to this? Surely we cant have another defender drop dead, its getting ridiculous!
Been told by a friend that McNair is injured, any truth to this? Surely we cant have another defender drop dead, its getting ridiculous!
Can't be more boring than last year, you lot came with no ambition expecting to lose and then perked up a bit when you realised we looked as scared of you as you were of us.
-------------------DDG--------------------
Rafael------Jones------Smalling-----Shaw
------------Carrick-------Di Maria----------
Rooney----------- Mata------------Janujaz
---------------------RvP----------------------
Best of a bad job atm, if it aint working bring Herrera on for Janujaz, and switch him with Di Maria.
No Blind? He has been one of our most consistent players this season.
Poor wingers simple as. Di Maria was never a great winger even Madrid fans could tell you that, very inconsistent and Januaj has just been wank.
Mike Dean