- Joined
- Jan 9, 2025
- Messages
- 69
- Supports
- Newton Heath
What's this guys G/A now?
Onana was such a weird signing in every sense. The fact he cost 50m when he moved for free the year before should’ve rung alarm bells.
They had more possession and more shots.
That's a bit harsh.Send this guy down the river.
Feel a bit sorry for him.
He is after all a human with feelings even if he is a rubbish goalkeeper.
Felt he was nervous all game.
Feel a bit sorry for him.
He is after all a human with feelings even if he is a rubbish goalkeeper.
Felt he was nervous all game.
One thing I've noticed on slow motion replays is when he faces tame shots that he knows he should be saving comfortably, he actively tries to push the ball away rather than being satisfied to get his hands on it. Not a problem if you actually push it away. But he's so focused on trying to push the ball he forgets to actually save it.Never seen it with him, even at Ajax never stood out as someone to keep an eye on for instance.
It's a bad state of affairs when a keeper is bad a shot-stopping. It's not mistakes that Onana makes that is the issue, it's his reflective ability when parrying the ball. It's not something that's going to improve as those are subconscious decisions he's making so I don't think it can be drilled out of him by a goalkeeping coach.
The club need to get rid of him ASAP.
One thing I've noticed on slow motion replays is when he faces tame shots that he knows he should be saving comfortably, he actively tries to push the ball away rather than being satisfied to get his hands on it. Not a problem if you actually push it away. But he's so focused on trying to push the ball he forgets to actually save it.
That's what happens on the first goal we conceded today, he could just tip the ball wide but because he had enough time he made huge motion to push the ball away and completely misjudged the ball and it's sneaked through. It's not the first time he's made that type of howler.
Then you have shots that are fizzed at him with more power and he has hard hands and it just bounces off him straight into the danger zone, he has no ability to soften his hands to keep the ball close to him, or the reaction times to steer the ball away from danger zones.
And then you have goals we concede that he has to dive for and his reaction times are just not good enough, these often do not look like howlers but there's always a question if a better keeper could have got a hand to it.
Just an overall poor shot stopper.
you should feel sorry for the fans who gave to watch him day in day outI feel really sorry for him.
Agree, the river doesn't deserve thisThat's a bit harsh.
You all cried asking for a keeper that was “good with his feet”, and what matters in a keeper is actually how he saves! You got what you wanted. Enjoy it ![]()
As shit as Onana is, he wasn't wrong either. We are clearly a better team. They had to rely on 2 goalkeeping errors to scratch together a draw at home.
I’d task our highly paid scouting department to come up with a list.Genuine question
Who would you replace him with in the summer?
Why? Did you feel sorry for Dyche?I feel really sorry for him.
Not easy to bin a keeper that costed 50M€ and is probably earning massive wages
What makes it impossible to even feel the slightest sympathy for himGood thing he didn't say anything before the game to put himself under the spotlight.
No - an initial €51m (£43.8m), plus €4m (£3.4m) in potential add-ons, a year after we could have bought him for nothing.
Standard Caf reaction. Onana is shit and I’m glad he’s being called out for it now. Other players who are not shit have had worse media reaction in our history. This clown seems to get a pass despite so many fecking mistakes.Caf posters all season: "United is too much of a commercial club nowadays. Onana is shit."
Matic the other day: "United is too much of a commercial club nowadays. Onana is shit."
Caf reaction, for some reason:![]()
Except Onana is not good with his feet. It was just a terrible signing overall. Regardless, De Gea needed to be gotten rid of and that was the correct decision.You all cried asking for a keeper that was “good with his feet”, and what matters in a keeper is actually how he saves! You got what you wanted. Enjoy it ![]()
A comfortable 2-0 win away without keeper’s errors would suggest yes. Alas…Do you think you were waaay better than OL?