Chelsea 2022/2023 | THIS IS LAST YEARS THREAD YOU NUMPTIES

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maluco said:
A lot of decent defenders can get on ok in a back three. He was decent, don’t get me wrong, I just don’t think he was ever a great player, and was probably lucky to be at Chelsea.

Liverpool won the CL with Djimi Traore. It’s all about hiding those weaknesses and getting him to play a specific role. He needed that, whereas you could have put Terry in any defensive role in any team and he would have been great
Click to expand...

Terry when he played high line under AWB he looked very uncomfortable. That's probably the only time he played in high line. Next season Jose was back to Chelsea and played with deep line and Terry was great again.

Terry was ofcourse awesome CB but I don't agree with "play him anywhere" part.

Yeah, maybe Cahil wasn't a great player but it was a great deal for Chelsea. Signed for just 7 million, played big role in lot of trophies. That was very good return on what they paid.
 
roonster09 said:
Terry when he played high line under AWB he looked very uncomfortable. That's probably the only time he played in high line. Next season Jose was back to Chelsea and played with deep line and Terry was great again.

Terry was ofcourse awesome CB but I don't agree with "play him anywhere" part.

Yeah, maybe Cahil wasn't a great player but it was a great deal for Chelsea. Signed for just 7 million, played big role in lot of trophies. That was very good return on what they paid.
Click to expand...

He was already into his thirties and being asked to do that role for the first time under a young and naive coach, but yeah, I get your point, maybe not a super high line for big JT.

Agree on the price too, for 7 million he was a decent option. I was just questioning people perhaps overrating him because of the team he played in. I just don’t feel he was ever a top CB, but he did play a role and won trophies.
 
roonster09 said:
Yeah, maybe Cahil wasn't a great player but it was a great deal for Chelsea. Signed for just 7 million, played big role in lot of trophies. That was very good return on what they paid.
Click to expand...

Yep, Cahill for £7M was one of the most value-for-money deals Chelsea have made in the last decade or so. Only behind Azpilicueta I'd say.

While he clearly wasn't world class, Cahill did what was asked of him and he did it well. He made an instant impact playing a big role in the UCL win in his first few months at the club, not to mention being a +30 game starting player in two league title wins inside the first five years as well. Replace Cahill with some objectively 'better' CB and I don't think Chelsea would've won any more trophies during his time at the club. For managers like Mourinho and Conte he was a very good fit for how they wanted their teams to play and defend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roonster09
WeePat said:
Lukaku was an absolutely awful deal and I have no idea how Werner’s agent finessed 270k a week out of Chelsea. Sterling is a massive deal but also what can you do, if you wanna sign him and he’s already on 300k, then best case scenario he’s coming in on that wage, but most likely he will want an increase. This one does have the potential to turn into a big problem in a couple of seasons though, if/when Sterling declines and he still has 2-3 years left on that contract.

James is still on his first contract he signed when he broke through in 2020. He and Mount are absolutely due a new and improved contract. Same with Mendy. Big difference between signing a relatively unknown keeper from Rennes and high profile players from CL clubs.
Click to expand...
I can forgive the Werner deal because on paper he should have worked (and did to a certain degree especially in TT's first 6 months) but Lukaku was unforgivable, it was so obvious he was a disastrous misfit in this system and i don't think even a 30 goal haul would have offset what we lost in general play with him in the side.
 
SirReginald said:
Cahill was decent. A consistent 7.5 player. My only issue with him was his last ditch tackles was one of his strongest traits but he shouldn’t have had to make as many as he did, which was also his greatest flaw.
Click to expand...

That was 100% my big issue with him too. People used to rave about his amazing last ditch tackling, but he was at fault for getting into those positions where they were necessary in the first place. Great servant to the club, and an amazing piece of business considering the cost, but I was never a huge fan.
 
Kentonio said:
That was 100% my big issue with him too. People used to rave about his amazing last ditch tackling, but he was at fault for getting into those positions where they were necessary in the first place. Great servant to the club, and an amazing piece of business considering the cost, but I was never a huge fan.
Click to expand...
He was signed as a squad player but circumstances (Luiz and Jose not meshing, us taking a while to get with the ball playing CB times and lack of quality CB's on the market) led to him getting a starting place.

He wouldn't have got near Jose 1.0's, Carlo's double or Tuchel's UCL winning sides as a starter.
 
Dancfc said:
He was signed as a squad player but circumstances (Luiz and Jose not meshing, us taking a while to get with the ball playing CB times and lack of quality CB's on the market) led to him getting a starting place.

He wouldn't have got near Jose 1.0's, Carlo's double or Tuchel's UCL winning sides as a starter.
Click to expand...
Let’s be fair to Gary. How many CBs in English football history could make Jose 1.0 team? There’s a reason our records that year are never getting beaten.
 
SirReginald said:
Let’s be fair to Gary. How many CBs in English football history could make Jose 1.0 team? There’s a reason our records that year are never getting beaten.
Click to expand...
15 league goals conceded all season was simply outrageous.
 
It’s lovely to see us kicking into gear with wingers and CB’s but it’s a bit worrying that we haven’t heard much of anything about some cover for our fullbacks.

I couldn’t stomach another extended stint of Azpi or Alonso getting destroyed defensively (in Alonso’s case) or not be able to do anything going forward (in Azpi’s case).
 
charlenefan said:


Thought he was highly rated?
Click to expand...


He’s going to end up at a CL club within 3 seasons if Chelsea let him go. I said the same with Guehi. I hope this isn’t true. Losing this guy for sake of Ake or Kimpempe would be the height of stupidity.
 
That small window while Lampard was boss was really the only hope for the young players, shame it was well timed for Reece James
 
:lol: Couldn't make it up. We will buy back one of Guehi or Tomori in 2 years and buy back Levi a few years later.
 
charlenefan said:


Thought he was highly rated?
Click to expand...

He is. But with possibly 3 CB to arrive, he wasn't going to be the 4th option was he? He'd still be behind Silva, Trev and even Reece James; and after a successful loan spell, why would he want to come back and have 2 or 3 mins here and there against lower oppo, or weaker, in carabao cup. It may even be that the player himself will want to move on

Long term Colwill would be ideal, id have still loaned him out again regardless, but he still only has one year of senior football under his belt. He is not of the level of the reported incomings. So I can see both points of view
 
GlasgowCeltic said:
That small window while Lampard was boss was really the only hope for the young players, shame it was well timed for Reece James
Click to expand...

I mean Gallagher is set to have a big role in the team next season. Chalobah was added to the team last season. We don’t know yet what ends up happening with Broja but Tuchel likes him and said he wants to assess him himself.

Still though, this Colwill thing really stings, especially after we saw how quickly Guehi showed he was ready.
 
Wow, surprised at the Colwill thing if true. I'm there's was even a remote chance Chelsea would sell to us without a buy back I'd be all over that since we are out of the running for Martinez.

Chelsea wouldn't be that silly to sell to us mind you, it will be a mid table placed team with some sort of buyback.
 
charlenefan said:
Thought he was highly rated?
Click to expand...

Makes no sense to me. Fecking hell, the club never seem to learn from past mistakes.

Silva, Koulibaly, Chalobah, one of Aké/Kimpembe and Colwill IMO would be more than enough at CB for Tuchel's three at the back system. That way the youngster would still get plenty enough minutes to stay happy and keep developing but it seems Tuchel wants to sign both Aké AND Kimpembe who will no doubt cost a total of 100+ million and one of them will just end up being a backup anyway.

If Colwill is sold, just watch him become a 60M+ rated player within a couple of years and Chelsea again being after new CBs when Silva eventually retires and maybe one of Ake/Kimpembe proves to be not good enough. Could easily see Colwill tearing up the league at Leicester for example.

If it happens, Tuchel has blood on his hands.
 
AB24-ABB5-B363-47-DA-ACF2-D7-A96-DB91812.jpg
 
WeePat said:
If true, it’s a disaster. I still think it won’t happen but there is no shortage of takers.
Click to expand...
I'm a little bit more hopeful after this tweet.



I wasn't too bothered with Tomori and Guehi as I don't really see what so many do (they're good and I'm happy they're doing well but I don't see elite level in either) Colwill however will be indefensible and for the first time I'll be questioning TT's long term suitability.

Next season my expectations was consolidate top 4, have a good UCL campaign and hopefully win one of the cups. If Colwill leaves and Kimpembe comes in then I revise my expectations to a sustained challenge for the big two (ie title race and UCL semi minimum requirement).
 
Dancfc said:
Next season my expectations was consolidate top 4, have a good UCL campaign and hopefully win one of the cups. If Colwill leaves and Kimpembe comes in then I revise my expectations to a sustained challenge for the big two (ie title race and UCL semi minimum requirement).
Click to expand...

You think Kimpembe is that much of a difference maker?
 
Losing Rudiger, Christensen and Sliva being a year older and getting in Kimpembe, Ake and Koulibally is about par I think.
 
Berbaclass said:
Losing Rudiger, Christensen and Sliva being a year older and getting in Kimpembe, Ake and Koulibally is about par I think.
Click to expand...
Id say that on paper the 3 CB are now stronger/upgraded overall... IF Kimpembe happens, of course
 
Dancfc said:
I'm a little bit more hopeful after this tweet.



I wasn't too bothered with Tomori and Guehi as I don't really see what so many do (they're good and I'm happy they're doing well but I don't see elite level in either) Colwill however will be indefensible and for the first time I'll be questioning TT's long term suitability.

Next season my expectations was consolidate top 4, have a good UCL campaign and hopefully win one of the cups. If Colwill leaves and Kimpembe comes in then I revise my expectations to a sustained challenge for the big two (ie title race and UCL semi minimum requirement).
Click to expand...

I liked Tomori, could see there was a top Cb in there. Guehi i rate too, but i think he is around his level with Palace. He is the one of those 2 who i think is a tad overhyped [as many do with a lot of our academy boys, tbf]

Colwill though, definitely another loan only! Waste of time keeping him around the squad this coming season after a season of regular games. But as i said in another thread, clubs just arent going to turn down 20m for Colwill and the like, after a single senior campaign of football. I think Romano may have jumped the gun a little, and i hope he got confused between loan and sale
 
ZolaWasMagic said:
Id say that on paper the 3 CB are now stronger/upgraded overall... IF Kimpembe happens, of course
Click to expand...
Possibly, not by a great deal though.

You're also relying on the two players new to the PL hitting the ground running and integrating into the side.
 
duffer said:
We're almost deffo losing Azpi as well. Maybe not his best season ever last year but he's a huge loss.
Click to expand...
Not his best season is a pretty big understatement, sadly. He’s past it. He was always unbelievable defensively so it made up for his lackluster attacking quality. But for the past year he also can’t stay in front of people defensively. He is easy pickings for quick, skillful players out wide.

He’ll be greatly missed off the pitch for sure and he’s a genuine legend but it’s not a loss on the pitch.
 
duffer said:
You think Kimpembe is that much of a difference maker?
Click to expand...
Tuchel clearly does so if he's going to let go an elite prospect to bring him then it has to be backed up with hard results.
 
Orc said:
He’ll be greatly missed off the pitch for sure and he’s a genuine legend but it’s not a loss on the pitch.
Click to expand...

I really think his leadership will be missed on the pitch as well. One of the things I like about Koulibaly is that he seems to be cut from a similar cloth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.