There’s no proof Mbappé would ruin the team dynamic. All we know is he’d be the best player in the league, it’s stupid to not want the best players in the world?
It’s this kind of shit had people wanting to keep McTominay over Casemiro.
Would you take Mbappe if given the chance?
- Thread starter Sir Erik ten Hag
- Start date
There’s no proof Mbappé would ruin the team dynamic. All we know is he’d be the best player in the league, it’s stupid to not want the best players in the world?
It’s this kind of shit had people wanting to keep McTominay over Casemiro.
Nothing to worry about. Licha will sort him out.
Yeah he would have no issue straightening him
No issue. I‘m confident Hag can handle him.
Yeah, and the same savvy reader would also call you out for a pointless, attention-seeking post. Surprised you didn't write 'do better' just to round off the aura of insufferability.
just noticed that now! I actually have no idea what I meant to type - and yes, I will blame iPhone auto-correct (or 'auto-compete' as you put it!)Why would any club not want to sign the best player in the world? 
'would you accept a Ferrari?' - the Kia driver asks his fellow Kia drivers
At the moment? He's been horrible since the WC ended save for one game against a 6th division team
Having a best player in the world? Hm, let me think for a second...
auto compete. How ironicLet's not get too picky on the specific wording. Regardless of his form over recent weeks, he is arguably the best player of the world since the start of the season.
no, personally i would take januzaj back as he has shown glimpses of being a much more complete player than mbappe
chill out dude, just because you think signing the best player in the world is somehow debateable doesn’t mean others do
No, him and Rash would trip over each other.
What the feck is thisTitle says it all: Imagine new owner comes in and promises to bring Mbappe to Old Trafford as a statement signing, would you take him?
Mbappe would instill fear in the PL defenders. But he may come with certain baggage like huge salary, big ego and extreme scrutiny from the press. Would we be ready to accommodate all of that to have Mbappe on the starting lineup?
Would he be a disruption in the dressing room (Sanchez, Ronaldo…etc) or he would form a lethal partnership with Rashford (The modern York-Cole)? Which way will it swing?
Would you take Manutd wining the PL this season, given the chance ?
Who said I thought that? I just see nothing wrong with posing the question on a chat board. Certainty doesn’t warrant thread deletion.
I think Messi has been better over the period : beginning of the season+WC and they've both been very meh since the WC ended
Yeah will worry about it if ever becomes anything more than a pure pipedream
Thanks I don't need mbappe. I already have Sancho, Amad, Pellistri, Rashford, Elanga, Garnacho, Anthony and looking for where to play Shoretire. He should be at Real Madrid.
No,it sucks alot of fuel and draws alot of attention.
A better question to ask is if the new owners buy Mbappe, how should ETH use him? What formation would we use, what position would he play, and who would play alongside him to make best use of his abilities?
How did this thread get to five pages?
It's not even like it's Haaland, where you could argue that there is the possibility of becoming one-dimensional and scoring less goals as a team despite destroying the race for the Golden Boot. Mbappe is arguably the most complete striker on the planet seeing as his competition in that regard are either past their prime (Lewandowski / Benzema) or an ambitionless also-ran (Kane).
It's not even like it's Haaland, where you could argue that there is the possibility of becoming one-dimensional and scoring less goals as a team despite destroying the race for the Golden Boot. Mbappe is arguably the most complete striker on the planet seeing as his competition in that regard are either past their prime (Lewandowski / Benzema) or an ambitionless also-ran (Kane).
It's more about what a transfer like this would represent rather than the player (who is clearly amazing).
Doesn't he by now have a reputation of being a super prima donna worse than CR7, Messi and Neymar combined?
I'm also not sure our new wage structure can accommodate a player earning 1m p/w.
I'm also not sure our new wage structure can accommodate a player earning 1m p/w.
Is maintenance included? If not, feck no
Take the commercials and attitude out of the equation, in a heartbeat.
Otherwise, it becomes tricky. Best player in the world for sure, but he has taken on the BPITW title without much subtlety or drama.
Otherwise, it becomes tricky. Best player in the world for sure, but he has taken on the BPITW title without much subtlety or drama.
I doubt the upkeep of Mbappe is as much as a Ferrari and he won't break going over a speed bump.
On ability alone of course we would. Given he's on close to £1m a week then I wouldn't personally. That's the type of thing that can ruin a dressing room.
That's a fair point. I think my comment was mostly motivated by my desire to remind the world that Harry Kane has never won a trophy.
Honestly it would be amazing to see him in the prem and playing for United but no.
Not the kind of personality we need right now.
Not the kind of personality we need right now.
apparently, there's that much acrimony in the psg dressing room right now that superstar divas might be had at bargain bucket prices in the summer.
Qatari owners....
Maybe they will spread their superstars out amongst their various feeder clubs!!!
don't forget all those lovely agency fees.
mmmm, gravy. lots and lots of lovely gravy...
One year of his salary (without counting bonuses) can buy you one good player. Thats mental.
One year of his salary can get you 25 Weghorst on a loan.
One year of his salary can get you 25 Weghorst on a loan.
I personally would on his ability but wouldn’t because
Im scared we go all galactico like PSG did with Messi, Neymar, Mbappe,Verrati, Donnuruma etc
The team seems to lack a balance - a balance that Ten Hag seems to be building.
If it’s just him then sure why not except he would probably get even higher wages than he is now and breaks our wage structure even more.
Im scared we go all galactico like PSG did with Messi, Neymar, Mbappe,Verrati, Donnuruma etc
The team seems to lack a balance - a balance that Ten Hag seems to be building.
If it’s just him then sure why not except he would probably get even higher wages than he is now and breaks our wage structure even more.
What if the Qataris fancy Rashford to join him at PSG and not the other way around?
Yea, but no - we got Wout.