Who was the greatest United Centre Half?

Pallister. Quick for such a tall man and of course a threat from corners.

His face always wore a deceptively tired look though...even from the first minute, but a damn fine athelete in reality.

:cool:
 
stam

Originally posted by MancFanFromManc:
<strong>With all this talk of new defenders and with Blanc signing a new contract...

Who do you reckon was out greatest ever center back?

Here's my shortlist (from the ones I've actually seen):
Buchan
McGrath
Pallister
Stam</strong><hr></blockquote>
 
Difficult one this, there are obvious reasons for selecting Bruce and Pally. As a duo they really complimented each others ability. It would be fantastic to have such a duo again but i have my doubts we'll get the players we need tis summer.
On an individual level you would have to pick Paul McGrath. The guy oozed class. My favourite moment from McGrath albeit for Ireland was in 94 against Italy at the World Cup. Ireland were under the cosh abit. Italy took an inswinging corner which landed in the six yard box. McGrath infront of Baggio's nose decided to flick the ball with the back of his heel away to safety. McGrath turned around and smiled at him. You knew from that moment that Italy were'nt going to get past McGrath that night. What a shame he had so many personal problems and injuries.
 
Originally posted by golden_blunder:
<strong>

had the class to play anywhere thats for sure.
I personally thought he was a great Cb but credit also has to be given to Moran alongside him who was also a hell of a defender.
its scandalous we didnt win more in the 80's when you look at the players we had on paper.</strong><hr></blockquote>

Blame me for that. I only missed 5 matches under Atkinson, then when Fergy arrived it all seemed so dull so I started playing Saturday league, instead of watching - I had a decent semi-pro carear but talk about all time DOH !

<img src="graemlins/houllier.gif" border="0" alt="[Houllier]" />
 
Originally posted by Lover of Football:
<strong>Chilton,Foulkes,Sadler the list is endless and not one of em used his hands. :) </strong><hr></blockquote>

Bill Foulkes for me,what a goal he scored in the 1968 EC semi,i'll never forget it.
 
Originally posted by ukbob:
<strong>Your question was " Who was the greatest United Centre Half" ? In that case without a shadow of doubt Duncan Edwards. However the question then changed to Centre Back. Two different animals by old and new definitios..!!</strong><hr></blockquote>

Duncan Edwards was a half back. Centre half pre Munich was Mark Jones or Jackie Blanchflower. Duncan could play anywhere. I remember reading that England moved him to centre forward one game (against West Germany, I think) when they were losing 2-0 and ended up winning 3-2.

In my United all-time dream team I would play him in central defence because there are so many midfield and attacking options. From what I have read he would walk into any team. Its hard to beleive he was only 21 when he died.
 
This is pure madness!Paul McGrath was the finest defender of his generation in the world,to compare him with Stam or Hansen is laughable.The only two who were anywhere near him were Baresi and Sammer(in his generation)The man was a fuking genius,he was a credit to the beautiful game.Twas a tradgedy that himself and Fergie were incompatible,a tradgedy,boo hoo ,boohoo :(
 
Without a doubt Johnny Carey, played for Ireland, Northern Ireland and the rest of the world, and played every position for United except outside left
 
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>Duncan Edwards, my grandad told me so!</strong><hr></blockquote>

Although Duncan could,and did, play in just about every position when asked to do so, centre half was not his best position. For the purposes of this debate and setting aside his off field and injury problems, Paul McGrath has been our most talented centre back. Gary Pallister and Jaap Stam were excellent but each had weaknesses which made them fallible at times. Then of course we had Steve Bruce and before him the dependable rock solid Billy Foulkes both of whom I would put on a par.
 
Just like Arnie, My favorite centre back is big Jim Holton partnered by Martin Buchan, one of the best central defensive partnership. During our younger days then, every of the my United supporter friends would named themselves as Jim Holton, especially attacking corner-kicks during our kick-arounds. Too bad he broke his leg and was never his oldself after recovering.