Which has been the best superhero film?

032Devil

Full Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2004
Messages
22,147
Of the last couple of years. We've had:

SUPERMAN (Brandon Routh) - really surprised by this. Good story, involved, great set pieces 9
BATMAN (Christian Bale) - darkest of Batman movies. Good story but needs to be darker still 8
SPIDERMAN - I really like this. I think Raimi has done a really good job with this. Only downside is that the baddies are crap 8
X-MEN - Decent set of films but generally left with a feeling of dissatisfaction. With such a canvas (world population of mutants), expected it to be more epic 5
FANTASTIC FOUR - OK, on par with X-Men 5
HULK - really shit. The CGI Hulk didn't work 0
DAREDEVIL - Didn't work for me 1
IRON MAN - Decent story, Downey impressive 7
ELEKTRA - shit actress. If Daredevil is anything to go by then 1
BLADE - haven't seen it so can't rate it.
 
SUPERMAN (Brandon Routh) - 6
BATMAN (Christian Bale) - 8
SPIDERMAN - 0, 0, 0
X-MEN -6,6,2
FANTASTIC FOUR - :lol: :lol:
HULK -3
DAREDEVIL - 4
IRON MAN -
ELEKTRA - 3
BLADE - 4
 
Superman Returns (is the name of the Routh film has been the best of the recent ones, and to little suprise imo great director, Bryan Singer who did X-Men but took Superman instead of X3 I actually thought X:2 was really good though way better than the others, I wish they would have had Gambit as part of the squad though
 
032Devil said:
Of the last couple of years. We've had:

SUPERMAN (Brandon Routh) - really surprised by this. Good story, involved, great set pieces 9
BATMAN (Christian Bale) - darkest of Batman movies. Good story but needs to be darker still 8
SPIDERMAN - I really like this. I think Raimi has done a really good job with this. Only downside is that the baddies are crap 8
X-MEN - Decent set of films but generally left with a feeling of dissatisfaction. With such a canvas (world population of mutants), expected it to be more epic 5
FANTASTIC FOUR - OK, on par with X-Men 5
HULK - really shit. The CGI Hulk didn't work 0
DAREDEVIL - Didn't work for me 1
IRON MAN - Decent story, Downey impressive 7
ELEKTRA - shit actress. If Daredevil is anything to go by then 1
BLADE - haven't seen it so can't rate it.
Click to expand...

Undoubtedly one of the best in Hollywood when he cares to be and isnt super messed up on drugs
 
olesmyhero said:
The 3rd one was awful.

I'd say the best one has been Batman Begins. The only thing that annoys me about that movie is that annoying fecking voice Bale does when he's Batman.
Click to expand...

I thought I was the only one who noticed that!! Still probably the best of the lot though.

The first spiderman was good the other two were mediocre at best which is a pity.

x-men - first two terrible, the last one was good though.
superman - didn't really like it, Superman has been done to death there is no originallity in any of the productions.
fantastic four - fantastic bore, unwatchable.
hulk - pretty poor and forgettable as I can't remember anything about it.
iron man - really good, bubbled along nicely before a good set piece finish and left me wanting more.

haven't seen the others.
 
032Devil said:
Of the last couple of years. We've had:

SUPERMAN (Brandon Routh) - really surprised by this. Good story, involved, great set pieces 9
BATMAN (Christian Bale) - darkest of Batman movies. Good story but needs to be darker still 8
SPIDERMAN - I really like this. I think Raimi has done a really good job with this. Only downside is that the baddies are crap 8
X-MEN - Decent set of films but generally left with a feeling of dissatisfaction. With such a canvas (world population of mutants), expected it to be more epic 5
FANTASTIC FOUR - OK, on par with X-Men 5
HULK - really shit. The CGI Hulk didn't work 0
DAREDEVIL - Didn't work for me 1
IRON MAN - Decent story, Downey impressive 7
ELEKTRA - shit actress. If Daredevil is anything to go by then 1
BLADE - haven't seen it so can't rate it.
Click to expand...

Spiderman 2 and Blade were class. The rest were fecking shit. As for Superman and 9???? Christ.
 
Blade and Batman were good as they were more dark and gloomy. I dont like the ones where the superheroes have nipples on their suits :rolleyes:
 
X-men - had a promising cast but the storylines were complete shit
spiderman - sucks plain and simple it was soo fecking corny
fantastic 4 - pretty terrible
hulk - joke of a movie eric bana should have known better
batman begins - easily the best superhero movie ive ever seen the sequel looks great as well
iron man - looks great ill be seeing it soon
daredevil/elektra - pure garbage
superman - didnt see it looked ok
blade - first one was decent the second not as good as the first the third not as good as the second
punisher - anyone see this? was it any good?
 
duffer said:
Hellboy was very good.

Mystery Men amused me.

Captain America was awful.
Click to expand...

Forgot about that, great movie.

Batman Begins is easily the best though.

Blade and Siderman were good too.
 
Alex said:
I thought it was shit not as bad as 3, but not as mediocre as 1
Click to expand...

It was good, and delved into the geeky spiderkid's head. Which is what Spiderman's about.

1 has been done a zillion times. . .and 3 was awful.
 
032Devil said:
Really wondered why they bothered making the film. Thought the part was made for Perlman but sadly a very disappointing film.
Click to expand...

And yet you rate Superman as a nine.........personal taste and all that I guess.
 
SUPERMAN (Brandon Routh) - One of the worst films I've ever seen
BATMAN (Christian Bale) - Enjoyed it
SPIDERMAN - Why would this even seem like a good idea to make a film out of? Second one might have been alright, if they hadn't have made it about 10 hours long
X-MEN - Watchable, I thought. Magneto keeps appearing in other films, pretending to be a good guy, but he always goes back to being Magneto about half way through
FANTASTIC FOUR - No
HULK - Actually turned it off even though other people were watching...nobody cared
DAREDEVIL - Pointless
IRON MAN - Not seen...lots of stuff exploding in trailer...probably enjoyable on some level
ELEKTRA - What's this?
BLADE - Couldn't stop laughing at the part where he clenches his fist.
HELLBOY - Like Men In Black, but dull

Superhero movies tend to be a bit crap, unless the villain is cool, or unless the hero is secretly evil
 
IBleedRed said:
I cant think of a bad movie edward norton has been in
Click to expand...

The score - Brando DeNiro, and Norton. verdict - complete shite, for some unknown reason. He's also in that Kingdom of Heaven shite with Orlando ("a red moon rises") Bloom.

There's two. He was also in a play when he was ten which was utter shite, probably.
 
Wes said:
The score - Brando DeNiro, and Norton. verdict - complete shite, for some unknown reason. He's also in that Kingdom of Heaven shite with Orlando ("a red moon rises") Bloom.

There's two. He was also in a play when he was ten which was utter shite, probably.
Click to expand...

I think Edward Norton was brilliant in The Score. He actually acted like a genuine retard.
 
Wes said:
The score - Brando DeNiro, and Norton. verdict - complete shite, for some unknown reason. He's also in that Kingdom of Heaven shite with Orlando ("a red moon rises") Bloom.

There's two. He was also in a play when he was ten which was utter shite, probably.
Click to expand...

The Score kind of reminds me of the Galaticos except instead of a lack of a strong manager you had a lack of a strong script. I quite liked Kingdom of Heaven but I can understand why a lot of people thought it wasn't so good.

Best superhero film has to be Batman Begins, I didn't even like the Batman films before this one. X-Men and Spiderman (except the last one were watchable). Couldn't stand Superman Returns absolutely boring old tosh.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.