What is the best XI of ex-United players still playing

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
20,025
Supports
Mejbri
--------------------Foster

Rafael----Shawcross---Evans----Evra

-----------Cleverley----Brady

Nani-------------Kagawa--------Di Maria

-----------------Hernandez

That midfield is pretty horrific, but the rest of the team is decent. Think they'd easily be a top half Prem team.
 
Bastian said:
--------------------Foster

Rafael----Shawcross---Evans----Evra

-----------Cleverley----Brady

Nani-------------Kagawa--------Di Maria

-----------------Hernandez

That midfield is pretty horrific, but the rest of the team is decent. Think they'd easily be a top half Prem team.
Click to expand...

Pogba might get a game.
 
How has Ronaldo not made your team?

Howard
Rafa Pique Shawcross Evra
Cleverley Pogba
Di Maria Kagawa Ronaldo
Hernandez
 
Bastian said:
--------------------Foster

Rafael----Shawcross---Evans----Evra

-----------Cleverley----Brady

Nani-------------Kagawa--------Di Maria

-----------------Hernandez

That midfield is pretty horrific, but the rest of the team is decent. Think they'd easily be a top half Prem team.
Click to expand...

Darren Fletcher would be in & Darron Gibson may have a shout too. Makes the team look stronger in my opinion.
 
Bastian said:
--------------------Foster

Rafael----Shawcross---Evans----Evra

-----------Cleverley----Brady

Nani-------------Kagawa--------Di Maria

-----------------Hernandez

That midfield is pretty horrific, but the rest of the team is decent. Think they'd easily be a top half Prem team.
Click to expand...

Ronaldo not getting a game :lol:
 
----------Howard

Rafael---Pique---Evans----Evra

-----Pogba-----Di Maria-----

Nani-------Kagawa-----Ronaldo

-------------Tevez-----

Fergie would win the league with that team.
 
Haha. This is what happens when you ignore the obvious. Pogba, Pique, Ronnie and Fletch. Jesus wept.
 
paulscholes18 said:
How has Ronaldo not made your team?

Howard
Rafa Pique Shawcross Evra
Cleverley Pogba
Di Maria Kagawa Ronaldo
Hernandez
Click to expand...
Drop cleverley for fletcher
Drop kagawa, put nani on the wing and move DiMaria to AM

Then you've nailed it, though personally is have Evans alongside pique
 
Howard
Rafael - Pique - Shawcross - Evra
Kagawa - Pogba - Di Maria
Tevez - Diouf - CR7​
 
Last edited:
AngeloHenriquez said:
What do you mean? You asked for the best XI and then forgot all the best players...
Click to expand...

Yes. I had an epic glitch in my brain. I struggle to understand it myself.

Anyhow, given the team that can be assembled by others whose brains are working, it looks like it would beat our current XI...
 
not the best but the team that i would like to watch:

------------Zieler-------------
Rafael---Evans-Vidic-----Brady
------Cleverley--Pogba--------
Nani---------Ravel----Welbeck
-----------Tevez-------------
 
------------------tevez barbatov
-------------------------Maria
ronaldo-------Pogba kagawa------nani
------------------Evra vidic pique
------------------------Foster
 
----------------Zieler------------------
Rafael - Pique - Shawcross - Evra
-----------Pogba-Fletcher------------
Di Maria------Kagawa--------Ronaldo
----------------Tevez--------------------
 
-------------Howard
Rafael---Pique---Shawcross---Evra
----------Pogba---Di Maria
Ronaldo-----Kagawa--Welbeck
-------------Hernandez

----------------de Gea
Darmian--Smalling-Blind--Shaw
----Schweinsteiger-Schneiderlin
Mata---------Herrera----Memphis
---------------Martial

Which team has less flaws?
 
Bastian said:
Yes. I had an epic glitch in my brain. I struggle to understand it myself.

Anyhow, given the team that can be assembled by others whose brains are working, it looks like it would beat our current XI...
Click to expand...

What scares me is their attacking midfielders, Ronnnie, Nani, Di Maria & Kagawa.... That with players like pique, Pogba, Tevez etc it's quite scary...
 
Cristiano--Tevez-----------
----------Kagawa--DiMaria
-----Pogba------------------
----------Fletcher-----------
Evra------------------Rafael
------Pique--Shawcross---
----------Howard-----------

Bench:
Diouf, Welbeck, Tosic, Cleverley, Brady, Evans, Zieler/Foster
 
---------------Howard---------------
Rafael--Shawcross--Pique--Evra
-------Fletcher-------Pogba-------
Nani----------Di Maria----------Ronaldo
----------------Tevez----------------
 
---------------Howard------------------
Rafael - Pique - Shawcross - Evra
-----------Pogba-Fletcher------------
Di Maria------Kagawa--------Ronaldo
----------------Tevez--------------------
 
-----------Howard---------------
Rafael - Pique - Evans - Evra
------------Fletcher------------
--------Pogba - Di Maria--------
Nani-----------------------Ronaldo
------------Tevez------------
 
charlenefan said:
---------------Howard---------------
Rafael--Shawcross--Pique--Evra
-------Fletcher-------Pogba-------
Nani----------Di Maria----------Ronaldo
----------------Tevez----------------
Click to expand...

The sad thing is, I'd probably fancy that to beat our current side.
 
------------------Howard

Rafael------Pique--------Evans------Evra

-------------------Fletcher

-----------Pogba--------------AdM

--------------------Kagawa

------------------------------------Ronaldo

----------------------Tevez

Subs: Foster, Shawcross, Nani, Berbatov, Tosic, Welbeck, Hernandez, Cleverley

*could drop Kagawa and have Nani in and switch to 4-3-3.
 
------------Howard
Rafael--Pique--Shawcross--Evra
------Pogba---Fletcher
--Di Maria--Tevez--Nani
----------Ronaldo
 
-------------Howard-----------
Rafael--Pique----Shawcross-Evra
---------Pogba--Kagawa-------
Ronaldo-----Tevez--------ADM
--------------RVP----------------

This is on current ability. Notable mentions to Welbeck, Hernandez and Nani. Maybe Evans too.

P.S. Who is Brady in the OP and who does he currently play for?
 
Andy_Cole said:
P.S. Who is Brady in the OP and who does he currently play for?
Click to expand...

Brady plays for Norwich, though he was at Hull last year. I think he's predominantly a winger but has been playing at left-back this season.
 
Andy_Cole said:
-------------Howard-----------
Rafael--Pique----Shawcross-Evra
---------Pogba--Kagawa-------
Ronaldo-----Tevez--------ADM
--------------RVP----------------

This is on current ability. Notable mentions to Welbeck, Hernandez and Nani. Maybe Evans too.

P.S. Who is Brady in the OP and who does he currently play for?
Click to expand...

Probably choose De Laet over Rafael for full back, otherwise a good side.
 
I wonder if Tom Heaton would get a shout for the GK spot. Or do only players that actually played for the first team count?
 
-----Ronaldo-----Tevez-----DiMaria-----
-------------Kagawa----Pogba-------------
--------------------Gibson------------------
Evra----Shawcross----Pique-----Rafael
---------------------Foster------------------
 
Well I'm not sure about some of the players left out but it looks like a team Fergie could have led to glory.

Mine would have to be:

Howard​
Rafael. Pique. Shawcross. Evra.

Pogba. Fletcher.
​
Ronaldo. Tevez. Di Maria.

RVP.
​
Some of those players are truly wonderful players who I'd love to still be at the club. I mean Tevez would make such a difference to our midfield. And then imagine Ronaldo on one wing and Di Maria on the other.

Real Madrid fans really should have nothing to ever complain about having seen Ronaldo, Benzema, Bale, ADM and Modric all in the same team. Add to that Kroos and James! Makes you sick really... And we had to suffer for years with Darren Gibson, Tom Cleverly, Anderson. Ahh!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.