Dj_Sydney_A
Guest
Forgetting what you'd LIKE to see happen, do you THINK Veron will be at Old Trafford by the start of next season?
Originally posted by Amir:
<strong>I thought we looked better tonight late on when Veron was running the show.</strong><hr></blockquote>
agreed, he's at his best when everything goes thro' him, its a pity he didn't move into the centre alot earlier.
Originally posted by Amir:
<strong>You never know what will happen (Just ask Stam!)</strong><hr></blockquote>
Please don't bring up Stam. That sale is the worst decision SAF has ever made, unfortunately.
And we still haven't got the bloody money for it!
Nothing a manager does can guarantee greatness for a football club. But backing off from doing what he knows is necessary can make certain failure.<hr></blockquote>
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>I personally dont think he did anything wrong tonight.
I dont blame him for anything that has not gone United's way this season (ok, he lost possession against boro but that could happen to anyone.)
I just happen to think his style isnt suited to your system and it upsets the balance..not his fault.
I've always rated him as world class and i still do...but some posters on here have suggested that after tonight's game, which some saw for some reason as his 'last chance', he will be on his way (dunno why tonight's game triggered it).
So i'm just wondering what people think...whether he'll start next season with United or be sold, most likely (IF he goes) to Lazio.
I'm just interested in people's opinions about him.</strong><hr></blockquote>
I'm just going to watch the replay of the game tonight, but the live show said to me that he played very well.
You will all get my full assessment after the replay and without the emotion of the live viewing.
Originally posted by beatlemanu:
<strong>Damn it, and he nearly scored...AGAIN...if it had just gone in...mmm... He'll be back and when he does get comfortable with the league, it'll be a whole new ball game...
</strong><hr></blockquote>
PRICK!
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>
1) If someone offered you your £28m back NOW, would you take it or keep Veron and refuse the 'refund'? KEEP HIM FOR ANOTHER SEASON AT LEAST.
2) IF he does leave, how much do you realistically feel you'd get for him? LESS THAN WE PAID, UNLESS IT'S AFTER THE WORLD CUP
3) If him staying meant you played a 4-4-1-1 formation on a regular basis, would you be happy with this and seeing Solskjaer start virtually every game on the bench? NO
4) If Veron stayed and SAF played him centre mid in a 4-4-2, which of your 'pick themselves' midfielders (as they are IMO) would you drop, Giggs, Scholes, Keane or Beckham? NONE. VERON SHOULD BE ROTATED LIKE EVERYONE ELSE.
5) An extension of Q4, do you think any of those 4 mentioned above deserve to lose their place in order for Veron to play centre mid? NO. AND NOR DOES NICKY BUTT.
</strong><hr></blockquote>
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>1) If someone offered you your £28m back NOW, would you take it or keep Veron and refuse the 'refund'?
2) IF he does leave, how much do you realistically feel you'd get for him?
3) If him staying meant you played a 4-4-1-1 formation on a regular basis, would you be happy with this and seeing Solskjaer start virtually every game on the bench?
4) If Veron stayed and SAF played him centre mid in a 4-4-2, which of your 'pick themselves' midfielders (as they are IMO) would you drop, Giggs, Scholes, Keane or Beckham?
5) An extension of Q4, do you think any of those 4 mentioned above deserve to lose their place in order for Veron to play centre mid?
Opinions gratefully received.</strong><hr></blockquote>
1) I'd take it.
2) Some spaniards would probably give us our money back (if he doesn't stink up the world cup too badly)
3) No
4) Would have to be Scholes?
5) No
This is not knee jerk reaction. This is after a whole season.
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>DJ, he's not leaving, so all of the questions cannot be answered!</strong><hr></blockquote>
It's hypothetical, Weastey..use your imagination, lad!
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>Ok, a few more questions for you:
1) If someone offered you your £28m back NOW, would you take it or keep Veron and refuse the 'refund'?
No.
2) IF he does leave, how much do you realistically feel you'd get for him?
What we paid.
3) If him staying meant you played a 4-4-1-1 formation on a regular basis, would you be happy with this and seeing Solskjaer start virtually every game on the bench?
The 4-4-1-1 formation came to Fergie's mind before he signed Veron. Bringing Seba allowed him to try it though as what he saw as optimal, but I still expect Fergie to twist and turn this formation.
4) If Veron stayed and SAF played him centre mid in a 4-4-2, which of your 'pick themselves' midfielders (as they are IMO) would you drop, Giggs, Scholes, Keane or Beckham?
Depends on form, etc, although Scholes would probably be the first one sacrificed. Anyway, we had all those players this season and they all played plenty.
5) An extension of Q4, do you think any of those 4 mentioned above deserve to lose their place in order for Veron to play centre mid?
The best players in the best form should play. As Keane is always on form he's unlikely to lose his place, but the rest, like I said earlier, is opened to change. Injuries, form, etc, make for different midfields.
Opinions gratefully received.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>4) If Veron stayed and SAF played him centre mid in a 4-4-2, which of your 'pick themselves' midfielders (as they are IMO) would you drop, Giggs, Scholes, Keane or Beckham?
</strong><hr></blockquote>
Keane? Did you watch the game tonight? Are you nuts?
Originally posted by passiveman:
<strong>
Keane? Did you watch the game tonight? Are you nuts?</strong><hr></blockquote>
Well yes, of course i saw the game and i know what you mean, he's class...but they all are really and i had to give you all the options!
(for the record, i AM nuts)
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>
It's hypothetical, Weastey..use your imagination, lad!
</strong><hr></blockquote>
I don't need to, he's not leaving! <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>
I don't need to, he's not leaving! <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />
</strong><hr></blockquote>
I can just picture you now, looking up, high into the sky, with a tear in your eye as you wave to his Rome-bound private jet...a gust of wind blows by and you can just be heard muttering to yourself..."but he's not leaving..."
I paint a lovely picture, dont i?
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>Please don't bring up Stam. That sale is the worst decision SAF has ever made, unfortunately.</strong><hr></blockquote>
ur 100% right! i thought nothing could surpass August the 10th 1996 as a dark day on the transfer market, but Stam's selling was almost unforgivable!
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>Ok, a few more questions for you:
1) If someone offered you your £28m back NOW, would you take it or keep Veron and refuse the 'refund'?
2) IF he does leave, how much do you realistically feel you'd get for him?
3) If him staying meant you played a 4-4-1-1 formation on a regular basis, would you be happy with this and seeing Solskjaer start virtually every game on the bench?
4) If Veron stayed and SAF played him centre mid in a 4-4-2, which of your 'pick themselves' midfielders (as they are IMO) would you drop, Giggs, Scholes, Keane or Beckham?
5) An extension of Q4, do you think any of those 4 mentioned above deserve to lose their place in order for Veron to play centre mid?
Opinions gratefully received.</strong><hr></blockquote>
1. I'd take the money, but will not be disapointed if no one bidded for him. He still is a quality player and yet to fully adapt to english football and the 4-5-1 formation.
2. No less than £25M
3. No, Ole should partner Ruud on a regular basis.
4. If he had to play, then I think Scholes will be the unlucky one. I'd rather have Scholesy over Seba though.
5. No
Originally posted by Dj_Sydney_A:
<strong>
I can just picture you now, looking up, high into the sky, with a tear in your eye as you wave to his Rome-bound private jet...a gust of wind blows by and you can just be heard muttering to yourself..."but he's not leaving..."
I paint a lovely picture, dont i?
</strong><hr></blockquote>
<img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />
Many people like to make out that I am a Verón fan no matter what! It's totally untrue, I just see potential when I see it!
There is no doubting that he is one of the best midfield players in the world, and you could see many times tonight the look of disgust on his face when things went wrong. Not to mention the effort he put in!
He's class and he's coming good!
Sorry if you and 90% of United supporters disagree with me!
Originally posted by GiggsysGirl:
<strong>
ur 100% right! i thought nothing could surpass August the 10th 1996 as a dark day on the transfer market, but Stam's selling was almost unforgivable!</strong><hr></blockquote>
There is no point crying over spilt milk lass. What was done was done.
And we haven't done that badly without him really! <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />
I just think that we would have done one hell of a lot better with him!
Originally posted by GiggsysGirl:
<strong>
ur 100% right! i thought nothing could surpass August the 10th 1996 as a dark day on the transfer market, but Stam's selling was almost unforgivable!</strong><hr></blockquote>
Learn to forgive and forget... Sir Alex's decision has hardly proved itself one way... Or the other. We certainly can't say it's the reason we'll finish trophiless.
Ahem what happened on August the 10th 1996? The only sold player I can remember of that summer is Sharpe.
Originally posted by Amir:
<strong>With all due respect, talking about determination is a cheap excuse. Maybe our players aren't good enough, maybe we're tactically crap. I don't believe in any of the two, but I do no believe we lost a semi final because of the lack of determination.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Well I do, I'm not about to say the players didn't want it - but they didn't demand it. The only player out there who refused to lose tonight was Keane. If we had ten more Keanes we wouldn't have lost.
Originally posted by passiveman:
<strong>
Well I do, I'm not about to say the players didn't want it - but they didn't demand it. The only player out there who refused to lose tonight was Keane. If we had ten more Keanes we wouldn't have lost.</strong><hr></blockquote>
We didn't lose, we drew, and unfortunately the 2-2 draw was at our place. Our players under performed, not underfought.
Originally posted by Amir:
<strong>
We didn't lose, we drew, and unfortunately the 2-2 draw was at our place. Our players under performed, not underfought.</strong><hr></blockquote>
I am aware of how the away goals system works you know - point is we lost the tie. You're entitled to your opinion - and I understand your defensive attitude to the players, but I don't share it. How many times did you see Bayer players attack us in numbers when we had possesion?
The same could not be said of our players - in the first half in particular I didn't sense our team in the ascendent, they looked sloppy at times and nervous on the ball.
As I've said, it's not like they didn't try - they simply didn't play like a team who are desperate to reach the final. In the last fifteen minutes we terrorised the Bayer goal, looking like a team who knew that time was running out. Where was that sense of urgency at the beginning of the game?
I don't expect to change your mind - and yes, we were unlucky, but that just wasn't a top class team performance and I've absolutely no idea why
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>
<img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />
Many people like to make out that I am a Verón fan no matter what! It's totally untrue, I just see potential when I see it!
There is no doubting that he is one of the best midfield players in the world, and you could see many times tonight the look of disgust on his face when things went wrong. Not to mention the effort he put in!
He's class and he's coming good!
Sorry if you and 90% of United supporters disagree with me! </strong><hr></blockquote>
Hey Weastey, i DO agree with you...but i wouldnt be surprised if he was sold.
Remember, at the start of this thread, the question was do you THINK he'll go, not would you LIKE him to go.
I THINK he'll go..i'd LIKE him to stay cause his signing (not 'him') has disrupted your previously successful system.
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>
<img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />
Many people like to make out that I am a Verón fan no matter what! It's totally untrue, I just see potential when I see it!
There is no doubting that he is one of the best midfield players in the world, and you could see many times tonight the look of disgust on his face when things went wrong. Not to mention the effort he put in!
He's class and he's coming good!
Sorry if you and 90% of United supporters disagree with me! </strong><hr></blockquote>
No one can disagree with you if you said Veron has "potential" to play well. Who don't know how good was him when he played for Lazio and Argentina? But the problem is that you never admit some players just can't make it in certain club/country. So you haven't watched the game yet but can't wait to come to defend Veron? Okay, I tell you how he perform: "He did nothing wrong" -- he seldom give the ball away and he worked hard -- but the most important thing is that he once again never did, or never looked like he can do, a thing which can change the course of the game and win us the match. An average performance, but for me it is unacceptable for only getting an average and ordinary player for 28m.
Originally posted by darko:
<strong>
Here is a thought. If we had Zidane instead of Veron, don't you think we'd of won our league by now and booked a place in the CL Finals? I think so. I would have cost us alot more though.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Or we would have the same bloody topic named Zidane instead of Veron.
Originally posted by darko:
<strong>Yes. He should be sold at 30 + million after the WC. He;'s agreat talent , but i don't think he suits the way we play. I'm sorry. He hangs on to the ball to long. Furthermore, we need Paul Scholes in CM because he scores a shit load of goals. he's proved that with us. He has been good for about a goal every three matches. Playing him at RM is a waste. If anything, play Veron at RM. I think Beckham would do twice the job as Veron for us at CM.. So, sell him and use the money to improve other areas. When only have 5 good ball carriers (I'm assuming Chadwick will never have a 1st team place) in RVN, Giggs, OGS, Silvestre and Forlan. The rest of the squad relies on fluent passing.
Here is a thought. If we had Zidane instead of Veron, don't you think we'd of won our league by now and booked a place in the CL Finals? I think so. I would have cost us alot more though.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Agreed. Veron should be sold. Only problem is that after the season he's had here, no one would pay the kind of money we paid. Hopefully he'll have a good world cup, his value will increase, and we can make at least some of the money back.
£28M???? ha! Lazio must have been laughing all the way to the bank.
He's a nice guy, a gentleman, and undoubtedly skillful. But he's not a united player. He was bought by Ferguson to unlock defences in europe (that's what Fergie said). He hasn't done that at all. And, when the chips are down, we desperately need a goal in the last 10 minutes, where is veron? HIDING AT CENTREBACK! Letting Blanc play midfield. As far as i'm concerned that says it all: he bottled it.
Why the hell Sir Alex kept him on and took off Butt, i have no idea. Face it, those who defend him. Veron has contributed to our trophyless season more than any other player. I'm not just talking about his shoddy play against middlesboro, bad and costly though that was, but about his inability to keep the ball moving quickly (key to our style) and the need to reconstruct the formation just to get him in the side.
Time for him to move on. Best of all would be if we could swap him for Ljunberg: get a player who scores and DOES unlock defences, and in the process let Seba undermine someone else's team.