Ah of course, you don't like the correct decision?
You would of loved it if the other way round mate...think about it.
VAR Decisions - PL 19/20 Season
- Thread starter edcunited1878
- Start date
You would of loved it if the other way round mate...think about it.
One of the big issues for me, besides the delays making it unfeasible at the moment, is that it was originally meant to be used for clear and obvious errors, not something you need to see four or five times in slow-motion without being entirely convinced.
VAR is really screwing City over
I actually don't have a problem with the new rule. That ball went directly to a attacking player because it hit a hand. It happened last week. It's going to happen again next week. VAR strikes again. And got it right.
It was a correct decision, but I think it was not clear and obvious enough to make that call. To be honest I would be furious if that happened to my team.
Also, it becomes more and more difficult to really celebrate goals because people are afraid of it turned back by VAR. This will even increase when people get more used to it. Having said that, I am still pro VAR, but I think it should be used on much less occasions and just interfere to avoid big injustice.
Also, it becomes more and more difficult to really celebrate goals because people are afraid of it turned back by VAR. This will even increase when people get more used to it. Having said that, I am still pro VAR, but I think it should be used on much less occasions and just interfere to avoid big injustice.
So Var ist getting flamed for being correct?
What is this bullshit?
What is this bullshit?
This new handball rule is absolutely stupid in my opinion
Those that are against VAR are willfully conflating the two.
It's getting the decisions correct so they can't complain. If you're blaming VAR it's because you didn't do enough during the game to win in the first place.
I'm more amazed VAR wasn't used for that rugby tackle in the first half tbh.
How much more clear and obvious does it have to be? It touches Laporte's hand.
In the olden days:
Ball goes into the net. The attacking team celebrates 0 seconds later.
In modern football:
Ball goes in the net. The attacking team are full of hope and expectation for 15 seconds. The defending team are full of hope and expectation for 15 seconds. Then one of the two teams celebrates.
Nothing is really taken away. There's just the addition of extra drama, extra hope, and a bigger buildup before the final release of elation.
In terms of joy and entertainment and talking points, today's VAR decision has produced a net positive result for the game.
The spectacle has been improved when you take into account more than just the side that's penalised. You also need to consider the side that benefits as well as the neutals who have something new to look out for.
Just imagine how much of the cheating have they done in the past, what blatant injustices their opponents have suffered before VAR.
Hail VAR! (today)
^
VAR worked perfectly in that Jesus goal.
Spot on. Where are the players supposed to have them?
Imagine the uproar from spurs fans if that goal stood. VAR credibility would be finished.
The best thing about VAR is when players look like prime pricks for their dumb arse celebrations.
Happened last year too.
Happened last year too.
It’s ridiculous, because out of the two, the first half one was more “clear and obvious”.
Well its the inverse of the rule right now. Instead of any part they can score with, the rule would be every part they can score with.
Not cheating. Just a tweak.
Like everything decisions will cancel it out for all teams by end of the season. Every team is going to get goals pulled back.
Michael Oliver didn't refer much to VAR, but every goal is mandated to be reviewed.
I agree that it shouldn't be about positioning - it should be about whether an arm is used to help your team gain an advantage. In this instance it definitely did.
Oliver signalled to the players in the game that nothing has come through on his ear piece from VAR about the incident.
For those against VAR,
stop living in the fecking stone age ffs
stop living in the fecking stone age ffs
If that handball was clear and obvious how was grabbing someones neck not clear and obvious? https://www.clippituser.tv/c/lwpepp
That’s just it, I enjoyed the 0 second wait to burst into celebration. Not having to wait 15+ seconds to celebrate. Just different opinions and different outlook on the game I guess
It is fecking wank.
Anything that makes the match day experience worse is a joke. It’ll be proven in the long run.
Anything that makes the match day experience worse is a joke. It’ll be proven in the long run.
Thank you, my fault. I had watched the replay just once and did not realize that the ball went from Laporte´s arm directly to Jesus. With the new handball rules it was a very obvious situation then.
Yeah but Obertan made the match day experience worse and you liked him, so?
It died 10 years ago.
Every goal is referred. If the ball hits an attacker's arm it is handball.
No room for subjectivity.
The penalty shout is the referees subjective opinion, so would only be overturned it it was obvious error. Get it?
Because of the way the rules work.
The handball rule is very clear. Once it touches the hand, it's a handball. So not giving the handball was immediately a clear and obvious error. It was an objective call rather than a subjective one.
Whereas pulling and dragging at corner kicks is an area where we know referees exercise subjectivity and discretion, which then makes it harder for VAR to state that the referee had definitely made a mistake.
I agree with you, which is why I don't support VAR. Penalty decisions regarding handball & fouls rely on the interpretation of someone, which in most cases people will always disagree with, as many of the cases are so minor, & should be left to the referee unless clearly wrong.
What people are complaining about today is VAR being used in Man Cities late goal, & disallowed because a city play handballed it on the way through to Jesus. This rule was brought in at the beginning of the season, & stated that any handball involved in the build up to the goal, whether accidental or not, would be disallowed. All players & managers, unless completely thick, know this, & what will happen. The Wolves players & manager complaining last week, plus the Man City ones should be dealt with severely by the authorities for their childish tantrums, & perhaps future idiots will keep their mouths shuts.
Your right the spurs supporters had absolutely no emotion.............
The apps have got to hold off on sending updates with goals on too!
I saw the 3-2 come through, and thought , you dastards, but take that Liverpool.
And then 2 mins later the correction! Rubbish.
Fcukin love VAR and goal line tech when it is City and Liverpool suffering from it. 
It was funny in the CL game last season. Was totally ridiculous today
VAR should feck off. It’s going to kill the game.
Spot on.
Someone from the FA needs to come out and explain why VAR chooses to disallow a goal at one end and chooses to ignore a penalty at the other.
And I mean it NEEDS someone to explain this. Otherwise what we have now is a guy sitting in a room deciding who he wants to win the game
And I mean it NEEDS someone to explain this. Otherwise what we have now is a guy sitting in a room deciding who he wants to win the game