Block it
42
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 12
- Clean sheets
- 3
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 3
- Red cards
- 1
- Status
Why not? If anyone should get dropped at the moment it should be Evans. Only person who should take Blackett's place is Rojo, so Shaw can get a game.
I think after last week's success, LVG will not change things yet. the diamond worked really well for us, so I think giving it another go is the best option.
Then he said this week that we have to look at the quality of the players we now have, meaning that he now feels we have a good enough squad to stand toe to toe with pretty much anyone. I don't see the merit of dropping an extra attacker for a defender, myself.
http://www.espnfc.com/club/manchest...e-for-his-place-in-the-manchester-united-team
Good to hear he despises Liverpool also!
Good to hear he despises Liverpool also!
Has he? How many/What mistakes have Smalling and Jones made?
He will eventually be better than any of Evans, Smalling or Jones I'm increasingly confident of that. In his first team games to date he has proven at the very least to be their equal and yes he has made the odd mistake but he will do at his age. His composure on the ball is remarkable considering not only his inexperience but also the fact that the entire team is in transition and he's been playing alongside players who are hardly commanding presences themselves. I'd keep him in for now no matter who's fit but LVG did say that Tyler had been "lucky" to get so many games due to injuries so that suggests he'll bench him soon. If he does it won't be for long as it's just a matter of time before Jones and Smalling are injured again and Evans is brainfarting goals away.
Gotcha, I was just wondering how comfortable he was on the right as it might be easier for him to get games once everyone is fit if he can play as either given it seems we will be going back to a back 4.
Jones made a stupid challenge against Burnley which gifted them a free-kick near the edge of the box, from which they hit the bar. Jones and Smalling were both asleep in the early stages of Swansea's 2nd goal. That's off the top of my head. While Blackett has made errors which have been pointed out in this thread, on an (clear) errors per match basis, his figures aren't so different from the other defenders. Not sure I'd go so far as to say he's made fewer per 90 mins. Indeed I would rate him behind both Jones and Smalling so far.
Last edited:
In 4 years you will repeat this post with the name Blackett in place of Evans and some youngster in place of Blackett.
If you're trying to hynoptise me it won't work
I dont get the hype hes hype hes getting so far this season. Im obviously all for giving the young players a chance but people saying hes been our best defender are going overboard. He's made at least one blatant error in every game which havent been punished and apart from actually getting on the ball and passing it he's looked to stay out of the game as much as possible and play as a spare man which doesnt really work when youre playing as a centre half. Im not saying he doesnt deserve to get more chances but I cant see him playing a huge amount with a 4 man defence if we can ever get our other centre halves fit although thats not particularly likely.
Stats this season from Squawka
Name Appearances Pass accuracy Defensive Actions Duels won Defensive Errors Cards
Smalling 2 90% 6 83% 0 0
Evans 2 86% 9 47% 1 0
Jones 3 91% 12 69% 0 0
Rojo 1 92% 5 45% 0 0
Blackett 4 87% 7 50% 1 2
Stats this season from Squawka
Name Appearances Pass accuracy Defensive Actions Duels won Defensive Errors Cards
Smalling 2 90% 6 83% 0 0
Evans 2 86% 9 47% 1 0
Jones 3 91% 12 69% 0 0
Rojo 1 92% 5 45% 0 0
Blackett 4 87% 7 50% 1 2
Smalling's back from the injury but that doesn't necessary means Blackett shall be dropped.
He's actually slowly getting close to throwing Smalling out of LVG's equation.
He's actually slowly getting close to throwing Smalling out of LVG's equation.
He's been very composed and assured which for a 20 year-old with no previous first team experience, is impressive. No, he hasn't.
So, apart from looking to get on the ball and pass it assuringly he's looked to stay out of the game...great logic
you people!He's played well and as long as he continues to do so he deserves to play.
Please tell me what's wrong with those stats...
It's strange, but I didn't think that he looked that good in the youth teams and was almost sure that he would be sold/released.
First team football really has been the making of him though.
Hopefully he can really push on and become a United regular for years to come.
First team football really has been the making of him though.
Hopefully he can really push on and become a United regular for years to come.
Me too, i always thought that he was to heavy for a left back, it took him to much time to turn himself and track back, i thought that he could be a CB but wasn't convinced by that prospect.
He's been very composed and assured which for a 20 year-old with no previous first team experience, is impressive. No, he hasn't.
So, apart from looking to get on the ball and pass it assuringly he's looked to stay out of the game...great logic
He's played well and as long as he continues to do so he deserves to play.
Please tell me what's wrong with those stats...
Yes he actually has if you watched games from a defensive point of view he has been caught out of position or had a miscommunication with somebody in every game so far which as a centre half you cant afford to do.
I said hes looked good on the ball but when the other team has the ball he has looked to stay out of the game and play as a spare man as much as possible hes not marking men tightly, looking to challenge for many headers or looking to make tackles or blocks. The logic is hardly that difficult to comprehend and as for your little "you people" comment I've probably seen considerably more of the lad playing than almost anyone on this forum and am a huge advocate of giving youth a chance so thats a bit of an unnecessary and pointless comment.
I never said there was anything wrong with the stats but they do illustrate the points I've made above considering hes played 4 games and has only had 1 more defensive involvement than Smalling who played a game and a half and has less than both Jones and Evans who have both played less games and his passing accuracy which has been his stand out attribute so far is actually worse than everyone apart from Evans who is having one of the worst spells of form of his career.
Be harsh not to start him today after his impressive displays of late, but now that Shaw's back, I can see him going in at left back, with Rojo partnering Evans.
Yeah, it would be really harsh on him. As much as I want to see Shaw play, I'd be a bit disappointed if it was instead of Blackett.
Last edited:
There are going to be times when Blackett will be left out, that's normal for a young player. We can't expect him to start 30 games this season.
He has done well for us but a tough away game might be better left to the more senior players. Evans rebounded pretty well against QPR. I think he will hold his place alongside Rojo.
He has been decent but nothing more. But considering his age and experience playing with the big boys, that is quite impressive. Shaw started off by being "decent" at first and we all know how much he developed last year so Blackett certainly has good potential. He is good on the ball and looks very composed which are two great aspects to have at such an age.
I think he is being a tad over rated in here.
For example, (maybe I'm just seeing things) I'm sure Evans was being criticised for his performance in the Burnley game whilst there wasn't much talk on Blackett. Fact is, Blackett made quite a few questionable decisions on the ball as well. Defensively Jones was the best, but Burnley hardly threatened anyway.
It's nice to see an academy player in the first team, I just think perhaps we are getting a bit carried away. Same thing happened with James after the Galaxy game and it was evident in the Valencia game he wasn't quite good enough going forwards and didn't really fit in.
For example, (maybe I'm just seeing things) I'm sure Evans was being criticised for his performance in the Burnley game whilst there wasn't much talk on Blackett. Fact is, Blackett made quite a few questionable decisions on the ball as well. Defensively Jones was the best, but Burnley hardly threatened anyway.
It's nice to see an academy player in the first team, I just think perhaps we are getting a bit carried away. Same thing happened with James after the Galaxy game and it was evident in the Valencia game he wasn't quite good enough going forwards and didn't really fit in.
Huge difference between playing fairly well in a pre-season friendly, and playing every minute of the first for epl games of a season, and playing quite well in most of them.
I know. I'm just saying people had James down as a back up wing back, and then the Valencia game came and it was clear he wasn't ready/good enough.
Not saying Blackett isn't good enough, just that we shouldn't get carried away, especially when he has made some bad decisions. He's young, I get it, it doesn't mean we should just forget about it though.
I would encourage everyone to remember that even Vidic struggled in his first 6 months playing in the EPL.
I definitely think Jones has been our best defender, and I expect Rojo to nail down the other place quick enough.
But it should be remembered that Blackett is extremely inexperienced at CB. And he's now had only 1 game with us in a back 4.
Pre-season is completely meaningless, no need to think much about his time there, beside noting he didn't fall to pieces.
He's very, very raw. He played 5 official games in the previous two seasons at CB, on loan and for the reserves.
Hopefully he can be brought through in a few years with luck.
I definitely think Jones has been our best defender, and I expect Rojo to nail down the other place quick enough.
But it should be remembered that Blackett is extremely inexperienced at CB. And he's now had only 1 game with us in a back 4.
Pre-season is completely meaningless, no need to think much about his time there, beside noting he didn't fall to pieces.
He's very, very raw. He played 5 official games in the previous two seasons at CB, on loan and for the reserves.
Hopefully he can be brought through in a few years with luck.
I don't think anyone is to be honest.
The mistakes that he has made have come through naivety, it has been his only achilles heel, but its also the thing that is probably easiest to coach out of him.
Starts again. Deserved IMO.
I'm so glad that LVG put his faith on this guy again. Even though there is Shaw. Glad that we keep our tradition to have player from our academic graduates in our starting eleven.
I know that Smalling won't start since he just came back from injury.
I know that Smalling won't start since he just came back from injury.
I admire LVG's faith and trust but Blackett needs to take these chances to his heart. So far he deserve them.
Fantastic stuff by Blackett, full credit to him.
Seems like a good kid, glad he's keeping his place in the side.. should be left out once he has a genuinely bad game.
Reminds me of a young Ledley king great prospect!
Great shout. He really does seem like Ledley King. Composure, strength and maturity.
Seems like a nice bloke and fairly grounded. But I'm not so sure about his actual ability. He looks ok so far but some on here are overrating him big time.
Blackett can also score a cracker goal. Well in academy, he took long shot free kick. I don't know if he can still do it.
How?
Great to see him starting again , despite what some would have liked.
He looks like him but that's about it I'm guessing.
- Status