Transfer Tweets - Manchester United - 2022/23 | Follow the OP rules and check the quality of your sources before posting. STAY ON TOPIC!

[Swedish_Plumber]

We could see a 60+ million bid for Rashford accepted and not see that money again.

 

[mazhar13]

 

[Barnslig]

Such an uninspiring signing. 0% excitement over this. Hopefully the deal falls through. I'd rather McFred honestly.

Surely there's some young, midfield talent out there we could target instead?

 

[Alemar]

Could Juve be interested in McTominay perhaps?

 

[croadyman]

Such an uninspiring signing. 0% excitement over this. Hopefully the deal falls through. I'd rather McFred honestly.

Surely there's some young, midfield talent out there we could target instead?

Go on put forward some names them

 

[AFC NimbleThumb]

Go on put forward some names them

Exactly how I’m beginning to feel. So many posters will immediately write off a signing [Im not overjoyed about this one tnh] but the second you say ‘who would you sign’, it’s suddenly’not my job’ etc.

So if it isn’t your job to suggest why is it your job to deride.

Rabiot, Tielemans, Neves, SMS, in each of their threads you’ve naysayers for no apparent reason. Let’s judge the squad on September 1st & if the manager wants a player, he’ll live &/or die by their success.

 

[AaronRedDevil]

Wouldn’t mind selling Rashford as long as there’s a buyback clause. He’s still young enough and could be useful when United finally get there shit together.

 

[Red00012]

The fact that he's travelled to Turin but apparently not to Barcelona is probably not a great sign.

He’s been to Barca they’ve agreed a fee….

 

[croadyman]

Exactly how I’m beginning to feel. So many posters will immediately write off a signing [Im not overjoyed about this one tnh] but the second you say ‘who would you sign’, it’s suddenly’not my job’ etc.

So if it isn’t your job to suggest why is it your job to deride.

Rabiot, Tielemans, Neves, SMS, in each of their threads you’ve naysayers for no apparent reason. Let’s judge the squad on September 1st & if the manager wants a player, he’ll live &/or die by their success.

Yeah sometimes ones you aren't keen on end up really surprising, likewise there are players we have been buzzing about signing but flopped.

 

[Wing Attack Plan R]

Remember Memphis? He was every bit as bad but far and away the best player in Holland

I said it a few above this post, but I'd take Memphis over Gakpo (or Rashford).

 

[Cantonagotmehere]

PSG are in for Rashford...

hahahahhaaha

 

[amolbhatia50k]

I'm on about the real dross....like Maguire!

Rashford is really dross these days. I fancy Maguire having a better season than him.

 

[amolbhatia50k]

Such an uninspiring signing. 0% excitement over this. Hopefully the deal falls through. I'd rather McFred honestly.

Surely there's some young, midfield talent out there we could target instead?

I understand people being a bit skeptical about this deal but not such strangely extreme reactions. He's obviously far more talented than Mctominay, a guy who can't trap or pass the ball half the time and tackles opponents when trying a piece of skill. Rabiot hasn't fulfilled his potential but by all accounts he's always been considered to have ability. Our chap can't get a game in midfield for Scotland.

So, why would you want to stick with our current midfield? If ETH wants him, he has a plan for how he'd fit in. And he does play for France who aren't a bad team

 

[OmarUnited4ever]

He'd be a free next year though.

No, he has a contract till June 2023 with an option of another year (club option), so 2 years overall, no rush to renew.

 

[Daengophile]

We are clearly taking the wrong approach with FdJ. Murtough needs to fly out to Holland, don some clogs and have a few pints of advocaat with his mum

 

[Judas]

We could see a 60+ million bid for Rashford accepted and not see that money again.

Exactly, it's bizarre how people don't learn this. We may invest some of it, perhaps, but all of it? I very much doubt it.

 

[Yagami]

Exactly how I’m beginning to feel. So many posters will immediately write off a signing [Im not overjoyed about this one tnh] but the second you say ‘who would you sign’, it’s suddenly’not my job’ etc.

So if it isn’t your job to suggest why is it your job to deride.

Rabiot, Tielemans, Neves, SMS, in each of their threads you’ve naysayers for no apparent reason. Let’s judge the squad on September 1st & if the manager wants a player, he’ll live &/or die by their success.

There are many press resistant midfielders available.

Arthur, Lobotka, Amrabat, Sergi Darder, Matheus Henrique, Merino.

In all the Juve games I've watched these past two seasons, he's not had one good performance. Lightweight, disinterested, lazy passes that should be easy to make. There's a reason that, despite Juve having a very poor midfield last year, he was moved to the left. It's because he was the worst of the lot.

 

[Yagami]

I understand people being a bit skeptical about this deal but not such strangely extreme reactions. He's obviously far more talented than Mctominay, a guy who can't trap or pass the ball half the time and tackles opponents when trying a piece of skill. Rabiot hasn't fulfilled his potential but by all accounts he's always been considered to have ability. Our chap can't get a game in midfield for Scotland.

So, why would you want to stick with our current midfield? If ETH wants him, he has a plan for how he'd fit in. And he does play for France who aren't a bad team

McTominay has had more good games for us than Rabiot in general these past two years, and I am no McTominay fan.

People really have no clue as to how Rabiot has been performing at Juve considering the acceptance of this potential transfer.

He may have a honeymoon period here, but it's more short sighted bs like the Eriksen transfer. Get in some press resistant midfielders who will have a positive impact for the long term.

 

[Judas]

I trust McTominay who actually cares about the club, as limited as he is, to put a better shift in. I just think this bloke is going to underwhelm long term, massively.

Just look at what Juve fans think of him, not sure why people would choose to ignore all the warning signs.

 

[Highfather_24]

Just look at what Juve fans think of him, not sure why people would choose to ignore all the warning signs.

For the same reason people ignored Maguire's slowness, or AWB/James lack of technical ability. We all would like to believe that all signings will work out. But for Utd, most dont.

Also the "if Rabiot's so bad, suggest alternatives" take is so so stupid. There were more than a dozen talented midfielders which have switched clubs this summer, while Utd sat there. Bissouma, Kamara, Vitinha, Ruiz the list goes on. If the best we could think of was Rabiot, that's just depressing.

 

[UnitedWA]

Get rid of Rashford asap! Especially if they offer 30 mil.+

 

[Highfather_24]

So if it isn’t your job to suggest why is it your job to deride.

This is dumb. So if I dont suggest alternatives to Arnautovic, I cant say that he will be a shit transfer, although its obvious that he will be?

Its common sense to suggest that its better to sign a young, upcoming and hungry player, rather than an off form player who might be on the decline with a lot of baggage and drama surrounding him.

You dont need to produce a transfer scout list in order to say a signing might not work. That's bizarre. Although there were many other ball winning midfielders we could have actually gone for this summer on the cheap like Kamara, Bissouma, Bruno Guimarães, Sangare etc.

 

[Satissh12]

 

[AFC NimbleThumb]

This is dumb. So if I dont suggest alternatives to Arnautovic, I cant say that he will be a shit transfer, although its obvious that he will be?

Its common sense to suggest that its better to sign a young, upcoming and hungry player, rather than an off form player who might be on the decline with a lot of baggage and drama surrounding him.

You dont need to produce a transfer scout list in order to say a signing might not work. That's bizarre. Although there were many other ball winning midfielders we could have actually gone for this summer on the cheap like Kamara, Bissouma, Bruno Guimarães, Sangare etc.

Dumb is moaning about something then when being harmlessly asked to make suggestions talk about ‘more than a dozen players’ but list the same few players in multiple posts.

As for your second paragraph, typical Caf strawman as I certainly haven’t said we shouldn’t sign ‘young, upcoming’ players so not sure who that rant is aimed at. Moving further onto things nobody said, when did I say you ‘need’ to produce a scout list? I said if you can do one then you can do the other.

People are simply being asked to throw a few names into the hat as alternatives, no one’s asked for a dozen names or full scout reports. Dumb is the overreaction you’re having to being asked to further the conversation.

 

[CM]

Not really sure what to make of this one. De Gea certainly shouldn't go unchallenged but any keeper we do find at this stage of the window (and as a back-up) isn't likely to be particularly great.

I'd be tempted to say go on the look for first-choice goalkeepers for next summer instead. That way we can replace him properly, although it would also be nice if we could gradually phase him out during the season.

 

[Highfather_24]

I said if you can do one then you can do the other.

People are simply being asked to throw a few names into the hat as alternatives, no one’s asked for a dozen names or full scout reports.

Why, why exactly do you have to "throw names into the hat", in order to say Rabiot might be a shit signing based on the clear red flags?

 

[Member 105568]

Wouldn’t mind selling Rashford as long as there’s a buyback clause. He’s still young enough and could be useful when United finally get there shit together.

Serious? He's 25 years old FFS!

 

[Hackman2210]

Couple of things.

Rashfords agent is called Dwayne - wont end well for either party.
Targets - total clusterfeck, its like pulling names out of a hat at random, embarassing.
Sales - what sales? Lets loan everyone and pay their wages in the hope they can raise their profile and we can get a fee for them after the damage playing for us has done to them.
Overall view - dumpster fire. To many regime changes, 9 years to get us into this mess, 2-3 years to get out.

 

[CallyRed]

Good we are focusing on the most urgent areas of our team.

 

[pascell]

Heaton was fuxking rubbish with his feet vs Rayo so this isn't surprising.

 

[Fortitude]

Couple of things.

Rashfords agent is called Dwayne - wont end well for either party.
Targets - total clusterfeck, its like pulling names out of a hat at random, embarassing.
Sales - what sales? Lets loan everyone and pay their wages in the hope they can raise their profile and we can get a fee for them after the damage playing for us has done to them.
Overall view - dumpster fire. To many regime changes, 9 years to get us into this mess, 2-3 years to get out.

@Dr. Dwayne

 

[Jacob]

I trust McTominay who actually cares about the club, as limited as he is, to put a better shift in. I just think this bloke is going to underwhelm long term, massively.

Just look at what Juve fans think of him, not sure why people would choose to ignore all the warning signs.

Effort counts for shit if you have zero talent.

 

[Member 105568]

Also the "if Rabiot's so bad, suggest alternatives" take is so so stupid. There were more than a dozen talented midfielders which have switched clubs this summer, while Utd sat there. Bissouma, Kamara, Vitinha, Ruiz the list goes on. If the best we could think of was Rabiot, that's just depressing.

I think Rabiot might be okay, but, yes, it's just nonsense to be pretend there hasn't been players on the market, and at reasonable fees. Viera, Enzo Fernandez, Nunes, Bennecer, Caqueret could all be added to that list as well. All would have been under 40 million early in the summer.

 

[Highfather_24]

I think Rabio might be okay, but, yes, it's just nonsense to be pretend there hasn't been players on the market, and at reasonable fees. Viera, Enzo Fernandez, Nunes, Bennecer, Caqueret could all be added to that list as well. All would have been under 40 million early in the summer.

Yep. I dont think Rabiot will be a bad signing, he is a decent player if he's heads in the game, but we could have and should have done better.

 

[Acole9]

I know the back up goalkeeper chat tends to get a lot of moans and groans but we do need one. I know it's not the most exciting of signings but we are short in that area now Henderson and Grant have gone.

 

[Mickeza]

Ooh I have an idea! We could sell Henderson and use those funds to buy a new young GK to challenge de gea!? Oh no. He’s on loan. The fact his media interviews have forced the club to decide he isn’t the future rather than his attitude which surely those interviews just reflect is bonkers to me. We do not sell anyone. Ever.

 

[georgipep]

Ooh I have an idea! We could sell Henderson and use those funds to buy a new young GK to challenge de gea!? Oh no. He’s on loan. The fact his media interviews have forced the club to decide he isn’t the future rather than his attitude which surely those interviews just reflect is bonkers to me. We do not sell anyone. Ever.

He is on 120k/week,who would buy him?

 

[Mickeza]

He is on 120k/week,who would buy him?

Newcastle wanted him. Both in January and earlier this summer. Or - and here’s a novel idea - we pay him some money to then make money.

 

[ayushreddevil9]

Such an uninspiring signing. 0% excitement over this. Hopefully the deal falls through. I'd rather McFred honestly.

Surely there's some young, midfield talent out there we could target instead?

Yeah sure you would.

 

[TMDaines]

Too fecking late. We have shit the bed with the man management of our keepers. With an in-form De Gea, a reliable Romero and a hot prospect in Henderson, we were incredibly well stocked.