I watched
Murder on the Orient Express yesterday, the classic version from 1974. I had been really looking forward to this given its reputation, cast, and director, but I came out of it kinda disappointed. I'd love to be told what I missed, but here's what I thought.
It's an awesome ensemble cast, but given the dynamics of the story, they don't get to do a whole lot of acting. Apart from Poirot, all characters have just little snippets of action, and that makes it hard to put in a noticeable performance. Of course, even 5 seconds of acting can be great, and they do each get at least one scene (the interrogation) to shine. But take Bergman: her 5 min continuous interrogation scene is supposed to be awesome and what got her the Oscar, but I don't get it. She was given some awful lines to work with. I mean: 'I was born backwards. That is why I work in Africa as missionary, teaching little brown babies more backwards than myself.' Or all the excessive religious stuff she says. That's just unsalvageable no matter the performer. And this way, everyone seems to have been given a sort of miniature caricature and ditto lines to deal with.
Even Finney can't escape that. With Poirot, he's obviously the one person that really gets to shine; but then Poirot is this weird and awkward person, and as much as Finney might have set the standard here for how Poirot will always be seen, it is a bit of a clown. You can do that well, of course, and indeed Finney does; so maybe it's me and my expectations, but the whole character seems just 'too much', and as such difficult to fully enjoy or appreciate.
Don't get me wrong, I liked the film and I'm happy I watched it. I just didn't feel it lived up to its reputation. And that's not because it's a film from 1974; I've seen plenty of films from the 70s, also before. It's really something about this film specifically. Maybe I expected too much and forgot the story, as any adaptation of Murder on the Orient Express comes with very specific restraints, of course.
I should probably read the book again (that's been 25 years probably
), and I am now also really wondering how the 2017 film was different, as I think I did like it better. But I don't think I'm going to make this into such a big project.