I'll give it a shot in this thread.
The situation is grim, no denying that at all. Having said that, I still feel that Ten Hag shouldn't and wouldn't be sacked. There are a few mitigating points I'll try to reason here:
- Injury Crisis: Possibly the worst kind we've seen in a long, long time. 3 out of 4 of our starting defence are out and Varane has just come back. The fact that there are defensive gaps should not be surprising. With Reguilon possibly coming back post the Brentford game, at least we'll have proper players in their positions
- Been there, done that: 2019/20 started with 9 points from 7 games and we ended up finishing 3rd. While I will never celebrate finishing 3rd as an achievement, the sad fact is that a title challenge is still a bridge too far. The standards for title race have been obliterated by City and losing a couple of games in the beginning of the season means that you're out of the race already. But having been in a top 4 race for almost every season in the past 7-8 years, we know that you're never fully out of it and a run of wins can propel you up the table and into the midst quite swiftly
- Fixtures: Barring City and Newcastle (Carabao), we have a reasonably manageable set of fixtures till the end of November. Given the atmosphere of doom and gloom, maybe it would've been better to play tougher fixtures at this point so we can be no-hope underdogs. However, now is the time to grind out results. Brentford, Sheffield United and Copenhagen represent fixtures where we can do it and gain some momentum.
- Ten Hag: For all the criticism he faces, I believe he handles the situation with dignity. While still only proven in Eredevisie, he is a class manager recognized across Europe. He has made mistakes, particularly in recruitment, and his in game management of sticking with Bruno and Rashford, especially when they are playing terribly, is quite rage inducing. However, we need to stick with the manager even if it means suffering in the short term. Player power at our club is beyond control. Sacking him gives in to that. Prima donnas like Sancho who've earned massive wages while delivering feck all are chilling at home rather than putting in a shift for the team. Our failings over the past few weeks are led by Ten Hag but have been characterized by individual blunders (Bayern, Galatasaray) and narrow margins (Arsenal, Spurs).
The doom and gloom at the club becomes so consuming that you feel that in a quieter environment, the team can actually pull themselves through the mess. As fans, particularly at this stage, I believe that we should back the manager to pull the team out of this mess. He did that last season, and he can do it this season as well. Falling into the same cursed cycle will lead us nowhere. Might as well try something new this time around.