9 is fantastic but I prefer 7 and 8 which are just more my thing aesthetically. Beaten every single game in the series except 11 which i've never played. Top 6 are:
FF 8- Personal favourite, though I know it divides opinion. Music is just some of the best of any game ever and the story is underrated.
FF 7- My first proper FF game (mystic quest doesn't count
). Wouldn't argue against it being the best in the series.
FF 9- Really enjoyable. Probably the purest FF game in terms of capturing what the series is about. Not a big fan of the cartoony vibe but it's still just a really great game.
FF 10- Proof that linearity isn't a bad thing in these games when done correctly (FF13 take note)
FF 6- Classic (if a tiny bit overrated). Best villain by some margin.
FF4- The first classic of the series.
The good but not great pile:
FF1- A bit bland but ok
FF2- Actually enjoyed this despite it being hated by a lot of people.
FF3- enjoyable but no real story
FF5- underrated and fun, though the random battle encounter rate was way too high in the version I played most recently.
FF12- Gameplay was fun and the world map is probably the best in the series but is annoyingly getting the status as a bit of a lost classic which i don't think it deserves. Most of the party sucks, there's barely any emotional or dramatic moments in the story, it's all a bit meh. It's extremely well written in terms of dialogue but there's not a lot there that really grabs me.
FF15- does a lot of things wrong but gets points for a great villain, decent battle system and good music.
The one I really hate:
The only one that i really disliked in the series was 13. The combat system and music are actually pretty good, it's just story and characters that I find so unbearably obnoxious. Getting the platinum was just pure torture at some points.