Ecstatic
Cutie patootie!
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2015
- Messages
- 13,787
- Supports
- PsG
Lovely stuff. A bit surprised to see Daly in there. Maybe switch Best to the right wing and play Liam Whelan on the left, or am I underrating Daly?
RIP indeed . Those Tugay and Gazza GIF-fests you did when we teamed up will live long in the memory.
you have the picks of @2mufc0 ,?
An all-Ireland team is actually pretty strong, with the centre forward position being the only serious weak link. As a starting point in terms of obvious balance (and prioritising some personal favourites namely Duff) I'd go with something like this:
Jennings is by far the standout keeper, and with due respect to the likes of Lawrenson, Moran and especially Tony Dunne I'd keep the back four as it is too. Danny Blanchflower really should be in there, so I'd probably shunt Brady out to a David Silva-esque wide playmaker role, move Best to the left wing and drop Duff.
Up front, Stapleton seems a bit underwhelming but the only orthodox alternatives I can think of off hand are David Healy and Robbie Keane, both great for their national teams but underwhelming in an all-time context, particularly Healy. So for an experimental line up I'm tempted to stick the skilful but highly robust Whiteside up front for something like this:
There's a nice balance between north and south in that second line up, with 7 RoI players and 4 from Northern Ireland, which broadly reflects the relative populations of the two areas.
There's excellent quality in reserve in the midfield area, with the likes of Ray Houghton, Ronnie Whelan and Sammy McIlroy deserving a mention. There's plenty in reserve in the creative wide areas too: Steve Heighway (37th in the latest Scouse list of '100 Players Who Shook The Kop'), the wonderfully talented Billy Whelnan who died in the Munich Disaster, and going much further back the highly-regarded Celtic star Patsy Gallacher.
I've been typing this whilst cooking dinner so I'm probably missing someone blatantly obvious, but the only one that springs to mind is John Aldridge, who does deserve a mention but he can feck off as he's a knob.
Looks good mate. One question tho - why are you merging Northern Ireland with Ireland?An all-Ireland team is actually pretty strong, with the centre forward position being the only serious weak link. As a starting point in terms of obvious balance (and prioritising some personal favourites namely Duff) I'd go with something like this:
Jennings is by far the standout keeper, and with due respect to the likes of Lawrenson, Moran and especially Tony Dunne I'd keep the back four as it is too. Danny Blanchflower really should be in there, so I'd probably shunt Brady out to a David Silva-esque wide playmaker role, move Best to the left wing and drop Duff.
Up front, Stapleton seems a bit underwhelming but the only orthodox alternatives I can think of off hand are David Healy and Robbie Keane, both great for their national teams but underwhelming in an all-time context, particularly Healy. So for an experimental line up I'm tempted to stick the skilful but highly robust Whiteside up front for something like this:
There's a nice balance between north and south in that second line up, with 7 RoI players and 4 from Northern Ireland, which broadly reflects the relative populations of the two areas.
There's excellent quality in reserve in the midfield area, with the likes of Ray Houghton, Ronnie Whelan and Sammy McIlroy deserving a mention. There's plenty in reserve in the creative wide areas too: Steve Heighway (37th in the latest Scouse list of '100 Players Who Shook The Kop'), the wonderfully talented Billy Whelnan who died in the Munich Disaster, and going much further back the highly-regarded Celtic star Patsy Gallacher.
I've been typing this whilst cooking dinner so I'm probably missing someone blatantly obvious, but the only one that springs to mind is John Aldridge, who does deserve a mention but he can feck off as he's a knob.
Fan of Sheedy. It would be good to have a draft where players like that get some decent exposure.A decent player but probably a personal choice... better to have Best right and Sheedy left (liked Sheedy.... liked all the EFC mid 80s team) give two different styles.
I'd do a Welsh United XI but it would be cack though we'd have a good forward line .... and Clayton Blackmore as a 1-man defence.
Great pick for Round 14.
Wanted him but fecking Schuster blocked him for me
My squad is an insane mess at the moment.. if I can get through the first game without a DQ I will consider it a success .
Yip. "Players who played in Div.1 (or UK?) in the 80s" (or even 1980-pre Prem League).Fan of Sheedy. It would be good to have a draft where players like that get some decent exposure.
Truth be told, was a bit of a dark age of football, that.Yip. "Players who played in Div.1 (or UK?) in the 80s" (or even 1980-pre Prem League).
The world didn't end with Brazil/Ajax/Bayern in the 70s and start again with SKY/Prem League?
Yeah. Even going by the way physio has done his time periods, I think you can set a distinct era in English football from the end of the World Cup winning generation to the Premiership era. So basically the 1970s and 1980s, and being specific something like 1972 to 1992. For me that's a distinct era for British and Irish football as well, with Scottish, Welsh and Irish (north and south) players having fairly key roles in the best teams. You can even see a clear line in the sand for Scottish football which did so well in the 1960s and renewed itself with the new firm to be competitive again in Europe in the 1980s.Yip. "Players who played in Div.1 (or UK?) in the 80s" (or even 1980-pre Prem League).
The world didn't end with Brazil/Ajax/Bayern in the 70s and start again with SKY/Prem League?
Used to be a member of that place in the late 1990s or so. Log-in still works as well. That does show how shite drafts can be on other forums, rating everyone's teams - as mere lists of players - just seems so anti-climactic.Another forum just literally did that draft.
http://www.footballforums.net/threads/60s-90s-english-top-division-draft.266883/
Truth be told, was a bit of a dark age of football, that.
Yeah. Even going by the way physio has done his time periods, I think you can set a distinct era in English football from the end of the World Cup winning generation to the Premiership era. So basically the 1970s and 1980s, and being specific something like 1972 to 1992. For me that's a distinct era for British and Irish football as well, with Scottish, Welsh and Irish (north and south) players having fairly key roles in the best teams. You can even see a clear line in the sand for Scottish football which did so well in the 1960s and renewed itself with the new firm to be competitive again in Europe in the 1980s.
Ahem.Used to be a member of that place in the late 1990s or so. Log-in still works as well. That does show how shite drafts can be on other forums, rating everyone's teams - as mere lists of players - just seems so anti-climactic.
I meant British football particularly and a subtle dig at the era dominated by Liverpool.Maradona, good German teams, grown up Zico, France 82, grown up Falcao, Holland 88, Robson... ...... grim times indeed.