I have to add some things that have been mentioned here.
- The First Battle of Geonosis - that Jedi are idiots isn't a secret. But this was beyong lunacity. Okay, we knew that they didn't had much time to prepare but going all in without much chance of winning wasn't smart. In that battle were 9 members of the Jedi High Council (Mace Windu, Shaak Ti, Adi Gallia, Ki-Adi Mundi, Plo Koon, Even Piell, Coleman Trebor, Eeth Koth, Saeese Tiin) and then they were joined by Master Yoda. Add to that, in the battle there was Kit Fistu who together with Obi-Wan Kenobi were basically, next in lone members for the Jedi High Council. If the Jedi would have lost, the war practically would have been over. The Jedi High Council had 12 members and if 10 of them would have died, then they would have been as good as destroyed. Let's move on.
- The Number of Clones - 'Master Kenobi, here there are 200000 clone soldiers (around the same number as army of Greece), and in reparation there are another 1 million (USA). If you want more, you have to wait'. Yep, the Jedi/senate wanted more and somewhere between the two episodes they ordered another 5 million soldiers (all together are as much as militaries of USA, China, India and Russia). For a galaxy that has quadrillion inhabitans. Corruscan itself had one trillion of people. If they would have recruited only 1 for each a thousand of people, they would have formed an army of 1 billion soldiers.
- Jedi Masters are total idiots - Does anyone think different? They usually spend their time to meditate but do little of value. Of course, there are exceptions like Obi-Wan Kenobi who was awesome, but most of them are totally useless. During the Clone Wars, basically all the difficult stuff was done by Kenobi and Skywalker. Yoda and Windu who apprently were more powerful and more wise, spend their time doing basically nothing. cnuts!
And this seems to have been a phenomena during their entire history. Everytime they had to fight against someone, they were completely incompetent and almost all the time they were saved by someone who had gone rogue (Revan, Meetra Surik, Uliq Qel Droma, Lord Huth), by someone who had joined the dark side before (Revan, Anakin Skywalker) or by someone with little training (Nomi Sunrider, Luke). They had survived all the time, only because of the brilliance of someone who usually either was outcasted, left the order or had just joined them.
- The absurdity of Ruusan reformation - Has anyone ever thought why such a powerful Galaxy doesn't have an army? The reason for that is beyond absurd, a thousand years before the movies, they just decided to not use anymore armies, because when you have armies then you'll fight. So, let's totally demilitarize. Cool! And what if someone starts making soldiers/droid soldiers?? Idiots.
At the same time, they decided that te Jedi won't be anymore as Supreme Chancellors which is again absurd. Why would have the Jedi left such power? Especially considering that they think that are supersmart.
- The prophecy of the Chosen One - A lot of people have misinterpreted it here. The prophecy is a Jedi prophecy. According to them, the force is in balance where there is only the light side. When things will go to shit, someone will bring the force in balance. For a thousand year, they didn't believe it because they thought that the Sith were destroyed. The first hints that this isn't the case, were around a hundred years before the movies. And that was confirmed after Kenobi and Jiin saw Darth Maul.
- Let's treat Anakin Skywalker like shit - I am looking at you Mace Windu. And you Yoda. And almost all the other Masters. He can't have a wife because this is forbidden. Except that an another Master (Ki Adi Mundi) had one (and in history there were many others). They don't give him the title of Master because he still wasn't stable enough. The title was a complete formality. In the clone wars, one of the most important Masters Depa Billaba (who was the youngest Jedi to sit on the Council and was the ex-padawan of Mace Windu) turned to the dark side and had to be put down. Oh, I didn't even mention the mistreatment of Anakin's padawan on The Clone Wars TV Show. And then Yoda's advice to Anakin, was to let Padme die. Excellent!
The worse part was that they were convinced that he was the Chosen One. And treated him that badly.
- The transformation of Anakin - It was done very badly. Interestingly, it was done excellently on the novel which was published a month before the book. Entire parts when he got transforrmed were skipped. Like his dialogue with Palpatine, when Palps admits that he is the Sith Lord. I would highly recommend to anyone to read that novel. Here he just simply decided to become evil in the space of a few minutes. In fact, we don't even know on the movies his relation with Palps. That was much more closer than we saw on the movie. Basically, Palps was the third most important person on Anakin's life.
- Suicide against the Sith Lord - [Windu's logic] We know that he is more powerful than us, and chances that we'll win are slim, and Anakin has most chances to win against him, but screw that, I am going to fight him. Why the feck he didn't wait for Yoda and Kenobi? Him with Yoda most likely would have defeated Palps. Add Kenobi on equation (who was the only one who could have controlled Skywalker) and they would have definitely win. But no, again he was shown to be a massive bellend.
- I have the higher ground - Despite it's critics, it was done good. Skywalker was slightly more powerful then Kenobi and Kenobi knew that. Anyway, considering that he had trained Skywalker, he knew exactly how he fights so he could defend well against Skywalker. Defeating him was more difficult though. But Kenobi was the cunniest Jedo of his time, so he played on Anakin's arrogance. While Kenobi was at a better position, Skywalker could have easily landed somewhere else and continue the fight. But Kenobi saying to him 'don't do it Anakin, I have the higher ground' was basically a challenge to Anakin. And Anakin went for it, while Kenobi was anticipating that move. It was a good job by Lucas, but because he was so shit on all other things, people don't give him credit for that and think that Kenobi only won because he had the higher ground. Oh by the way why was skipped the best line of dialogue on the novel?
'This is the end for you my Master'
'I have heard this many times Anakin. I never thought that I would hear it from you' was replaced on the movie by 'I have failed you Anakin'. Feck knows!
- Anakin and Padme - The biggest question is was Padme really beautiful, was she beautiful because she was in love or wasn't she beautiful but she looked beautiful to Anakin because he was in love. Losing the will to live should be added in medicine as one of the reason why people die.
