Sane in talks with Bayern?/ Signed for Bayern

Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m curious to see his performances in a non-Guardiola team.
 
I'd be amazed if they sold him as he's such a talent.

I could see him wanting to go to Bayern 100% but what on earth would City be thinking selling someone of his ability.
 
Bwuk said:
He'd be a superb signing for Bayern.
Click to expand...

I'm actually envious of the fact that Bayern put such a clear focus on always having wingers in the side, for years they had Robben and Ribery and when they had Coman and Costa they were clearly planning ahead even then
 
Devil81 said:
I'd be amazed if they sold him as he's such a talent.

I could see him wanting to go to Bayern 100% but what on earth would City be thinking selling someone of his ability.
Click to expand...

Pep is brutal (and that's why he's the best). Had no problems selling the likes of Yaya Toure, Eto'o and Sanchez at Barca when they were all at their best as well. If you dont fit into his philosophy then you're done
 
charlenefan said:
I'm actually envious of the fact that Bayern put such a clear focus on always having wingers in the side, for years they had Robben and Ribery and when they had Coman and Costa they were clearly planning ahead even then
Click to expand...

Agreed. I'd love us to play with actual wingers.
 
charlenefan said:
Pep is brutal (and that's why he's the best). Had no problems selling the likes of Yaya Toure, Eto'o and Sanchez at Barca when they were all at their best as well. If you dont fit into his philosophy then you're done
Click to expand...
Which Sanchez?
 
Devil81 said:
I'd be amazed if they sold him as he's such a talent.

I could see him wanting to go to Bayern 100% but what on earth would City be thinking selling someone of his ability.
Click to expand...

Think they want him to stay but can't guarantee him a starting place as Sterling and Bernardo suit Guardiola's tactics better. He has also an attitude problem and we know that Guardiola is ready to kick out any player who questions him, even if he is among the best out there. There is a reason why Eto'o hates him. Guardiola had no time for his antics.
 
Devil81 said:
I'd be amazed if they sold him as he's such a talent.

I could see him wanting to go to Bayern 100% but what on earth would City be thinking selling someone of his ability.
Click to expand...
I read somewhere that City want to sell Sane and Jesus to sign Joao Felix.

Maybe they need more a player like Felix considering they already have Sterling, Bernardo Silva, Mahrez as wingers.
 
No matter how good he is as a talant some managers require their players to have a certain mindset to his in with the squad. Clearly Sane has some issues with his mindset his national team didnt select him and his club want rid of him.
 
Is it just me who feels Sane is a bit wasted at City and not the best fit for Guardiola's style of play? He seems more of a counter attacking player and at his best when he has more space to run into rather than playing against packed defences where City have 65+% every game.
 
The problem with Leroy is his consistency. It's difficult to say whether this will come with age because he's had so many off days this season. Whether you can put that down to a lack of starts, I don't know.

I would be disappointed to see him go. He's got it in him to be one of the very best. Aside from De Bruyne, he's the best striker of the ball in our squad.
 
Uli Hoenes just confirmed Bayerns interest in Sane.
They always speak about other clubs players publicly. Same happened with Hudson-Odoi. They’re such can’ts.
 
Mogget said:
Is it just me who feels Sane is a bit wasted at City and not the best fit for Guardiola's style of play? He seems more of a counter attacking player and at his best when he has more space to run into rather than playing against packed defences where City have 65+% every game.
Click to expand...

What top team doesn't face packed defences?
 
Sane is way more talented that B Silva and Sterling.

Attidude can be fixed
 
Mogget said:
Valid point, but I feel it's different for a Guardiola team due to the way they play.
Click to expand...

It's true that basically no team is as dominant as Guardiola's but in return his positional football also supports attackers like very few other coaches. It's no accident that his teams score tons of goals, despite opponents trying to be as defensive and passive as possible against his sides.
At another club Sane will get more space, but he will also get less structure and less support.
 
Mogget said:
Is it just me who feels Sane is a bit wasted at City and not the best fit for Guardiola's style of play? He seems more of a counter attacking player and at his best when he has more space to run into rather than playing against packed defences where City have 65+% every game.
Click to expand...

If that's the case he should join Liverpool and not Bayern.
 
charlenefan said:
Pep is brutal (and that's why he's the best). Had no problems selling the likes of Yaya Toure, Eto'o and Sanchez at Barca when they were all at their best as well. If you dont fit into his philosophy then you're done
Click to expand...

He's being sold because he isn't signing a contract extension. City have been trying to get him to sign one for 18 months.
 
Kaglish10 said:
I'm not saying Sterling and Sane don't stretch the wings.

All I'm saying is Sane can only play as a traditional winger/SS, these are his best role whereas Sterling can play as an inverted forward on the left, as a traditional winger on the right side or SS.

If you look at Pep's Barca side, the likes of Villa, Pedro were inverted wing forwards who cut in several times, while Alves and Alba stretched the wings. Maybe that's what he's trying to do at Mancity. I know that Pep tried Sane on the right in his first season but he wasn't good until he was moved to the left.
Click to expand...
Not true. At Barca Pep had Eric Abidal and Dani Alves as his fullbacks. Dani was the more offensive fullback that would play high up the pitch while Abidal had a much more reserved role, often even acting as a 3rd CB.

Pedro and Villa were instructed to stay wide and stretch the pitch creating more space for Messi, Xavi and Iniesta to operate.
 
Sane is being sold because even though he has a great left foot - he plays better on the left than on the right.

He doesn't play as an inverted forward whilst sterling is doing exactly that on the left hand side.

Same either stays being a back up option or goes to a club that doesn't need that type of forward - ie bayern.
 
WokoTheGreat said:
Not true. At Barca Pep had Eric Abidal and Dani Alves as his fullbacks. Dani was the more offensive fullback that would play high up the pitch while Abidal had a much more reserved role, often even acting as a 3rd CB.

Pedro and Villa were instructed to stay wide and stretch the pitch creating more space for Messi, Xavi and Iniesta to operate.
Click to expand...

Alba and Alves constantly stretched the wings. Pedro and Villa were always moving inwards. Villa's goal against Madrid in the CL happened when he was central before Messi passed to him. It was more of a diamond with Messi at the tip while Pedro and Villa were more or less the forwards. The likes of Alba and Alves were always combing forward to stretch the wings.
 
I've noticed when watching him for city that he gives the ball away more than any other attacking player. Pep maybe doesn't like that.

Other than that, he's brilliant imo. City are in the position where they can lose someone as good as him and not worry.
 
It would be amazing to have Sane in our team, just imagine Sane and Sancho as our wingers, and Felix behind the striker. But we are linked with Moussa Dembele and Daniel James to improve our attack.
 
Aloysius's Back 3 said:
Sane is being sold because even though he has a great left foot - he plays better on the left than on the right.

He doesn't play as an inverted forward whilst sterling is doing exactly that on the left hand side.

Same either stays being a back up option or goes to a club that doesn't need that type of forward - ie bayern.
Click to expand...

I think he's being sold only because he won't sign a new deal. If he wanted to stay why would they sell him, it's not like they need the money.
 
Fer said:
It would be amazing to have Sane in our team, just imagine Sane and Sancho as our wingers, and Felix behind the striker. But we are linked with Moussa Dembele and Daniel James to improve our attack.
Click to expand...

Of course we are, this summer was always destined to be a disaster.
 
Bastian said:
I think he's being sold only because he won't sign a new deal. If he wanted to stay why would they sell him, it's not like they need the money.
Click to expand...

Yeah definitely - but I think sane is not staying because he isn't getting played in his best position & is competing with someone who doesn't look like he can be dropped either. If sane was a RW as fluid as he is on the left I think he'd make Mahrez & the others RW's feel like he does playing second fiddle to sterling.
 
Aloysius's Back 3 said:
Yeah definitely - but I think sane is not staying because he isn't getting played in his best position & is competing with someone who doesn't look like he can be dropped either. If sane was a RW as fluid as he is on the left I think he'd make Mahrez & the others RW's feel like he does playing second fiddle to sterling.
Click to expand...

Yeah, he doesn't really suit their tactical setup. And maybe questions about his attitude and application.

To me he looks like the perfect old school winger. And it just pisses me off that Bayern will get a free run at this. They've normally always spent way below MV on players. Remember it being the case all the way back to when they picked up Ballack and Ze Roberto for absolute pittance...
 
Fer said:
It would be amazing to have Sane in our team, just imagine Sane and Sancho as our wingers, and Felix behind the striker. But we are linked with Moussa Dembele and Daniel James to improve our attack.
Click to expand...

Because we are a bang average team right now with CL next season. Why would any top player want to leave a better club and join our shit show?
 
El Jefe said:
I've always been a bit confused by Pep's treatment of Sane this season. IMO he is a super player and better than Sterling the only difference is the latter fits Guardiola's type of wide player more.

Last season and the first half of this season just gone, Sane was absolutely unplayable at times. His assist ratio since he's been in the PL says it all and he gets a good amount of goals for a winger.

Who can City bring in that is better than Sane?
Click to expand...
Agree with this. It's quite puzzling what's happened to him at City. This is the sort of decision we need them to make more of. It's an obvious mistake IMO.
 
RooneyLegend said:
Agree with this. It's quite puzzling what's happened to him at City. This is the sort of decision we need them to make more of. It's an obvious mistake IMO.
Click to expand...

He's had a contract offer on the table for a year and a half and it's still unsigned. In the meantime, he's no longer a guaranteed starter due to Bernardo and Sterling's form. While he hasn't been a regular starter, City have amassed 98 points and won a domestic treble.

I don't necessarily agree with the decision to sell but if he won't sign a contract, City really have no choice but to sell and replace while they can, especially with a potential transfer ban coming next season.

Need to verify whether he plans to sign it or not. If it's a no or an undecided, he has to go for the maximum fee and City have to chase Felix
 
Andrew Wolf said:
He's had a contract offer on the table for a year and a half and it's still unsigned. In the meantime, he's no longer a guaranteed starter due to Bernardo and Sterling's form. While he hasn't been a regular starter, City have amassed 98 points and won a domestic treble.

I don't necessarily agree with the decision to sell but if he won't sign a contract, City really have no choice but to sell and replace while they can, especially with a potential transfer ban coming next season.

Need to verify whether he plans to sign it or not. If it's a no or an undecided, he has to go for the maximum fee and City have to chase Felix
Click to expand...

Yeah. They're not pandering to their players. This is how United used to operate.
 
He gives City a great plan B when tiki taka isn't working. Tactically it'll be a huge step backwards if they let him go and fail to replace his directness with the ball.
 
Andrew Wolf said:
The problem with Leroy is his consistency. It's difficult to say whether this will come with age because he's had so many off days this season. Whether you can put that down to a lack of starts, I don't know.

I would be disappointed to see him go. He's got it in him to be one of the very best. Aside from De Bruyne, he's the best striker of the ball in our squad.
Click to expand...
He was excellent last season and he's still very young.
 
Fer said:
I read somewhere that City want to sell Sane and Jesus to sign Joao Felix.

Maybe they need more a player like Felix considering they already have Sterling, Bernardo Silva, Mahrez as wingers.
Click to expand...

I could see the previously rumoured Jesus for Rodri swap happening with Atletico, Gundogan staying and then City buy Felix to be both the backup 9 and the backup LW.

Sterling-Aguero-Bernardo as a front 3 with Mahrez and Felix backing them up (Foden some minutes there too), then DeBruyne, David Silva starting with Gundogan and Foden backing up the CMs (Bernardo also getting time there), with Rodri and Fernandinho as the 6s.

That's 11 guys to play 6 spots.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.