I take less talented Brazilian teams that played with heart over that 2006 fiasco.
The 2006 Brazil team was wild.
It was -on paper- probably the strongest national team ever assembled.
The starting line up was:
---------------------- Dida -----------------------
Cafu --- Lucio --- Juan -- Roberto Carlos
-------- Emerson --- Ze Roberto -------
------ Kaka ------------------- Ronaldinho
---------- Adriano -- Ronaldo ---------
3 Ballon d'Or winners in there, plus one of the most intimidating strikers ever, two contenders for the best full backs of all time, and amazing defensive players and work horses to add.
If each of these players what at his best, this team would be unstoppable.
But in reality they underperformed badly.
To be fair to them, they did have some good games like the second half again Japan and the knockout tie again Ghana, and it took Zidane's brilliant performance to knock them out. However the expectations going in the tournament were massive, they were seen as clear cut favourites, and they disappointed everybody.
I remember this was the first time people saw Ronaldinho as human again, as before that, despite some inconsistent form that season, he used to deliver in big games in Barcelona and had just come of winning the Champions League against Arsenal.
This WC also cemented the downfalls of Adriano and Ronaldo, who were no longer seen as elite players afterwards.
However I think that despite this team being seen as a fiasco, I honestly think that this was still a better Brazil than any team that came afterwards. Despite the poor form of key players, they were still very defensively solid and if it wasn't for that Zidane pass to Henry, they might have knocked out France on penalties. Going out losing 0-1 to that France team is no shame, it was much less of an embarrassment than the ways in which the future teams going out of WC. From my memory Lucio was a total beast on that tournament. So as badly as they underperformed, I would still take that Brazil team over any other that came afterwards. For example there's no way this team loses 7-1 to Germany or wastes a lead to Croatia. Just too much defensive talent and experience in there.