Music RedCafe's Favourite Albums Of All Time Contest (Round 3)

Dirty Schwein

Has a 'Best of Britney Spears' album
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
35,858
Location
Miracle World
Supports
Luton Town
Round 2 is complete and the 5 albums progressing are:

The Dark Side of the Moon
Rumours
Unknown Pleasure
Never Mind The Bullocks
Wish You Were Here

The below 2 albums are going to the Resurrection Round:

Led Zeppelin IV
London Calling

Note: Wish You Were Here and Led Zeppelin IV were tied here and both got 5* on AllMusic but the former had more ratings on the website. Second round in a row where a tie breaker was decided like this.

Full results below:

The Dark Side of the Moon (Pink Floyd)
68​
Rumours (Fleetwood Mac)
62​
Unknown Pleasure (Joy Division)
62​
Never Mind The Bollocks (Sex Pistols)
50​
Wish You Were Here (Pink Floyd)
46​
Led Zeppelin IV (Led Zeppelin)
46​
London Calling (The Clash)
36​
Blood on the Tracks (Bob Dylan)
26​
Transformer (Lou Reed)
26​
Songs in the Key of Life (Stevie Wonder)
24​
Another Green World (Brian Eno)
20​
Leave Home (The Ramones)
18​
Off The Wall (Michael Jackson)
18​
The Rise & Fall of Ziggy Stardust (David Bowie)
18​
After the Goldrush (Neil Young)
16​
Real Life (Magazine)
16​
Bryter Layter (Nick Drake)
14​
Hotel California (The Eagles)
14​
Paranoid (Black Sabbath)
14​
A Night at the Opera (Queen)
12​
Deep Purple (Macine Head)
12​
Blue (Joni Mitchell)
10​
Born To Run (Bruce Springsteen)
10​
Close to the Edge (Yes)
10​
Hejira (Joni Mitchell)
10​
Hunky Dory (David Bowie)
10​
Machine Gun Etiquette (The Damned)
10​
Master of Reality (Black Sabbath)
10​
Parallel Lines (Blondie)
10​
Paris 1919 (John Cale)
10​
Physical Graffiti (Led Zeppelin)
10​
Pink Moon (Nick Drake)
10​
Regatta de Blanc (The Police)
10​
The Specials (The Specials)
10​
Third (Big Star)
10​
Trans Europa Express (Kraftwerk)
10​
Visions of the Country (Robbie Basho)
10​
Vol 4 (Black Sabbath)
10​
Animas (Pink Floyd)
8​
Black Sabbath (Black Sabbath)
8​
Breakfast in America (Supertramp)
8​
Cheap Trick (Cheap Trick)
8​
Die Mensch-Maschine (Kraftwerk)
8​
Exile on Main St. (Rolling Stones)
8​
Innervisions (Stevie Wonder)
8​
Low (David Bowie)
8​
Marquee Moon (Lou Reed)
8​
News of the World (Queen)
8​
Presence (Led Zeppelin)
8​
Songs of Love & Hate (Leonard Cohen)
8​
Station to Station (David Bowie)
8​
Talking Book (Steview Wonder)
8​
Thick as a Brick (Jethro Tull)
8​
Tonight's the Night (Neil Young)
8​
Another Kind Of Blues (UK Subs)
6​
Aqualung (Jethro Tull)
6​
Doremi Fasol Latido (Hawkwind)
6​
Heroes (David Bowie)
6​
Loaded (Velvet Underground)
6​
Perfect Angel (Minnie Ripperton)
6​
Q: Are We Not Men? We Are Devo! (Devo)
6​
Raw Power (The Stooges)
6​
Red (King Crimson)
6​
Still Bill (Bill Withers)
6​
The Coln Concert (Keith Jarrett)
6​
The Idiot (Iggy Pop)
6​
The Last Waltz (The Band)
6​
The Wall (Pink Floyd)
6​
Discovery (ELO)
4​
Ege Bamyasi (Can)
4​
Future Days (Can)
4​
GI (The Germs)
4​
Harvest (Neil Young)
4​
Here Come the Warm Jets (Brian Eno)
4​
Highway To Hell (AC/DC)
4​
Horses (Patti Smith)
4​
Legalize It (Peter Tosh)
4​
Meddle (Pink Floyd)
4​
Piledriver (Status Quo)
4​
Rust Never Sleep (Neil Young)
4​
Tarkus (Emerson, Lake & Palmer)
4​
The Clash (The Clash)
4​
The Modern Lovers (The Modern Lovers)
4​
What's Going On (Marvin Gaye)
4​
Who's Next (The Who)
4​
Alive (Kiss)
2​
Back Home Again (John Denver)
2​
Dire Straits (Dire Straits)
2​
Fragile (Yes)
2​
Fun House (The Stooges)
2​
Just As I Am (Bill Withers)
2​
Let's Stay Together (Al Green)
2​
Live at the Witch Trials (The Fall)
2​
Live in Europe (Rory Gallagher)
2​
Outlandos d'Amour (The Police)
2​
Ramones (The Ramones)
2​
Selling England by the Pound (Genesis)
2​
Si On Avait Besoin… (Harmonium)
2​
The Man Machine (Kraftwerk)
2​
This Year's Model (Elvis Costello)
2​
Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (Elton John)
2​
Bat Out of Hell (Meat Loaf)
1​

Through so far:

Round 1:
Abbey Road (The Beatles)
Pet Sounds (The Beach Boys)
The Velvet Underground & Nico (The Velvet Underground & Nico)
The Doors (The Doors)
Revolver (The Beatles)

Round 2:
The Dark Side of the Moon (Pink Floyd)
Rumours (Fleetwood Mac)
Unknown Pleasure (Joy Division)
Never Mind The Bullocks (Sex Pistols)
Wish You Were Here (Pink Floyd)

Resurrection Round:
Let It Bleed (The Rolling Stones)
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (The Beatles)
Led Zeppelin IV (Led Zeppelin)
London Calling (The Clash)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Onto the next round!

Each Monday, I will set up a new round for the contest.
Each round will represent a different decade of albums (I can't check the dates for each album so please make sure yourself).

The decades are below (BOLDED IS THE CURRENT ROUND FOR THIS THREAD):

Round 1 - Up to 1969
Round 2 - 1970-1979
Round 3 - 1980-1989
Round 4 - 1990-1999
Round 5 - 2000-2010
Round 6 - 2010-Present Day
Round 7 - Resurrection Round
Round 8 - The Finals

For each round, please list your top 5 music albums from the decade in list view (album name first, followed by artist).
Please do this by Friday 11:59pm BST (no votes beyond this will be counted).
5th = 2 pts, 4th = 4 pts, 3rd = 6 pts, 2nd = 8 pts, 1st = 10 pts.
The top 5 albums from each round will go through to the finals.
The 6th and 7th album from each round will enter the resurrection round, where 5 albums will go through to the final.
In the event of a tie, I will refer to their AllMusic scores (and then the amount of scores if still a tie).
If you have voted, then changed your vote, please don't edit your vote... instead, reply to it and let me know by tagging me, otherwise I may miss your vote by accident.
I will try to start each new round on the Monday after a vote round has finished.
At the opening post of each round, I will put in the results from the previous round and start the voting of the current round.
Once rounds 1-7 are complete, we head into the final round with 35 albums on the shortlist.
Then once that voting is done, I will post the top 35 in order from last to first and crown the overall winner.

Remember, I have 2 kids and a full time job so there may be times where I miss deadlines or post later than anticipated. Apologies in advance.

I hope this is fun and you guys enjoy it.
 
1. Thriller (Michael Jackson)
2. Straight Outta Compton (NWA)
3. Let's Dance (David Bowie)
4. Control (Janet Jackson)
5. Never Too Much (Luther Vandross)
 
Last edited:
1. Talk Talk - Colour of spring
2. Peter Gabriel - 3 (also know as 'Melt' or '3: Melt')
3. King Crimson - Discipline
4. Kate Bush - Hounds of love
5. Paul Simon - Graceland

This was the hardest decade so far! I'm not sure this is really my top 5 either, but I don't want to think about it for too long.
 
  1. Closer - Joy Division
  2. Violent Femmes
  3. Doolittle - The Pixies
  4. Ride The Lightning - Metallica
  5. Daydream Nation - The Sonic Youth
I am disappointed in how easy this decade was; thought it’d be much more strenuous to decide. The 70’s were tougher, and I’m guessing the 90’s will be equally stressful.
 
1) Let It Be - The Replacements
2) Dolittle - The Pixies
3) Disintegration - The Cure
4) Murmur - REM
5) Remain In Light -Talking Heads
 
1. Appetite for Destruction - Guns n' Roses
2. Synchronicity - The Police
3. Straight Outta Compton - NWA
4. The Queen is Dead - The Smiths
5. Closer - Joy Division
 
Black Flag-Damaged
Joy Division- Closer
Bad Religion- Suffer
TSOL- Beneath the Shadows
The Smiths- Meat is Murder
 
1. Appetite for Destruction - Guns n' Roses
2. Synchronicity - The Police
3. Straight Outta Compton - NWA
4. The Queen is Dead - The Smiths
5. Closer - Joy Division
This was 80s?? Completely misjudged that. Need to adjust my list!
 
This was 80s?? Completely misjudged that. Need to adjust my list!
Yeah, but how good is it really? It's got a few good/great tracks, but the worst tracks of the album are really bad (and really didnt fare well lyrically). As much as it's an important album in the history of rap music, it hasn't got a patch on De La Soul's debut (1989) for example - or what Dr. Dre and Ice Cube would each subsequently put out in the 90s.
 
Hex Enduction Hour - The Fall
Script of the Bridge - The Chameleons
This Nation's Saving Grace - The Fall
Closer - Joy Division
What Does Anything Mean? Basically - The Chameleons

Honorable mentions to

Pornograghy - The Cure
Brand New Age - UK Subs
Hatful of Hollow - The Smiths
Gentlemen Take Polaroids - Japan
In the Flatfield _ Bauhaus
 

The Cure: Disintegration (1989)

The Smiths: The Queen Is Dead (1986)

Joy Division: Closer (1980)

Iron Maiden: The Number of the Beast (1982)

The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses (1989)
 
  1. Thriller - Michael Jackson
  2. The Game - Queen
  3. Diamond Life - Sade
  4. Straight Outta Compton - N.W.A
  5. More Specials - The Specials
 
Damaged - Black Flag
Licensed To Ill - Beastie Boys
Appetite for Destruction - Guns n' Roses
Doolittle - The Pixies
Los Angeles - X
 
1. The Smiths - Queen is Dead
2. The Cure - Disintegration
3. XTC - Skylarking
4. Paul Simon - Graceland
5. Leonard Cohen - Various Positions
 
Last edited:
Surfa Rosa - Pixies
Nebraska - Bruce Springsteen
You're Living All Over Me - Dinosaur Jr
Daydream Nation - Sonic Youth
Technique - New Order
 
1. Thriller - MJ
2. Appetite for Destruction - GnR
3. Bad - MJ
4. The Queen is Dead - The Smiths
5. The Joshua Tree - U2
 
Another round where the tiebreaker puts through a second album from one artist. Terrible.
 
Another round where the tiebreaker puts through a second album from one artist. Terrible.
This time it’s a good album, though. So it’s fine with me.
 
1. Thriller (Michael Jackson)
2. Daydream Nation (Sonic Youth)
3. Remain in Light (Talking Heads)
4. Hatful of Hollow (The Smiths) - it's the best one, sorry but no-one cares that it's technically a compilation
5. Psychocandy (The Jesus and Mary Chain)

Honourable mentions:
The Queen Is Dead
Doolittle
The Stone Roses
The Smiths
My Life in the Bush of Ghosts
Scary Monsters 'and Super Creeps'
Isn't Anything
 
Qualified finalists so far - beatles and pink floyd - you vanilla fecks (solid enough albums though)
 
1. Disintegration - The Cure
2. Spirit of Eden - Talk Talk
3. Hounds of Love - Kate Bush
4. Somewhere in Time - Iron Maiden
5. Floating into the Night - Julee Cruise

Gonna be much harder from now on.
 
Last edited:
Qualified finalists so far - beatles and pink floyd - you vanilla fecks (solid enough albums though)
You just chose a compilation. You have no power here.
 
Led Zeppelin IV should have made it through since you already had a Pink Floyd album make it through and number of ratings on some rando site doesn't really mean much but no big deal.
 
I thought about Hatful of Hollow but since it's a comp I immediately discounted it like a normal person.
 
Still thinking about mine. Turns out whilst I love 80s music I don't really listen to that many full albums from that era.

My no.1 is Remain In Light but need to refresh on others.
 
I thought about Hatful of Hollow but since it's a comp I immediately discounted it like a normal person.
Thank god you came to your senses. Creepy to think that people choosing compilations might actually walk among us.
 
1980s dying days of rock but:

Back in Black- AC/DC
Iron Maiden-Iron Maiden
The River- Bruce Springsteen
The Unforgettable Fire -U2
Women and Children First-Van Halen
 
I thought about Hatful of Hollow but since it's a comp I immediately discounted it like a normal person.
It's not a vanilla compilation though now is it. Plenty of unreleased tracks/recordings.
 
  1. Some Great Reward- Depeche Mode
  2. It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back - Public Enemy
  3. Paul's Boutique - Beastie Boys
  4. Enter - Cybotron
  5. Planet Rock - Afrika Bambaata and Soulsonic Force


I may re-arrange the order or add or subtract an album if I remember something I forgot which is likely.

Honorable Mentions
Thriller - Michael Jackson
Raising Hell - Run DMC
Paid in Full - Eric B and Rakim
Power Corruption Lies - New Order
Moving Pictures - Rush
The Message - Grandmaster Flash and Furious Five
Music for the Masses - Depeche Mode
Stone Roses - Stone Roses
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but how good is it really? It's got a few good/great tracks, but the worst tracks of the album are really bad (and really didnt fare well lyrically). As much as it's an important album in the history of rap music, it hasn't got a patch on De La Soul's debut (1989) for example - or what Dr. Dre and Ice Cube would each subsequently put out in the 90s.

If we're counting early hiphop-electro (and I am), Straight Outta Compton is not even a top 10 hip hop album of the 1980s let along top 5 overall, it's probably one of the most overrated hip hop albums of all time.
 
  1. Purple Rain - Prince & The Revolution
  2. The Joshua Tree - U2
  3. 1999 - Prince & The Revolution
  4. Back in Black - AC/DC
  5. Hysteria - Def Leppard


Probably forgetting loads.

Re the 70s, to paraphrase True Romance “all we have is fecking Floyd”

@Dirty Schwein Switched 1&2, 1999 in at 3, back in black to 4.
 
Last edited:
1. The Cure - Disintegration.
2. The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses
3. Prince and the Revolution - Purple Rain
4. Pixies - Doolittle
5. Guns N' Roses - Appetite for Destruction
 
Last edited:
1. Disintegration - The Cure.
2. The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses
3. Prince and the Revolution - Purple Rain
4. Pixies - Doolittle
5. Guns N' Roses - Appetite for Destruction
Shut up and go sign up to WW :)
 
1. Thriller - Michael Jackson
2. Purple Rain - Prince & The Revolution
3. Full Moon Fever - Tom Petty
4. 1984 - Van Halen
5. Appetite for Destruction - Guns 'n Roses
 
If we're counting early hiphop-electro (and I am), Straight Outta Compton is not even a top 10 hip hop album of the 1980s let along top 5 overall, it's probably one of the most overrated hip hop albums of all time.
Yeah, I think it's pretty much the historical factor combined with Straight Outta Compton and F*ck Tha Police being great that makes people think the whole album is amazing.

Well, and each to their own taste and all that of course.
 
1. Doolittle (Pixies)
2. Tracy Chapman (Tracy Chapman)
3. Straigh Outta Compton (NWA)
4. 3 Feet High and Rising (De La Soul)
5. The Queen is Dead (The Smiths)


Honourable mentions:

Raising Hell (Run-DMC)
Hounds of Love (Kate Bush)
The Smiths and Meat is Murder (The Smiths)
Surfer Rosa (Pixies)
Licenced to Ill (Beastie Boys)
Joshua Tree (U2)
Disintegration (The Cure)