Moby
Dick
The aim of this poll is to decide the winner in this fantasy game contested between two sides assembled through the method of drafting. For the purpose of this game, all players would be considered as being at their respective peaks. I invite all posters to go through the formations, tactics and arguments that will follow in the thread and kindly leave their vote. Thanks.
antohan's tactics
Tactics and game-plan rationale
I rate Gio’s spine quite highly, many of them are former 70s draft players of mine. Mine would give it a game, but rather than argue myself silly on players and what they could or couldn’t do, I’ve opted for focusing on where his comparative weakness lies: the flanks.
By reinforcing my spine with Popescu, I give my defence peace of mind and my fullbacks the freedom to shine. Both my midfielders are also given more freedom in possession, fully aware that the dangerman (Rivaldo) is well taken care of by Popescu staying behind.
Upfront it’s all rather simple, if difficult to defend against. When needing to drop someone upfront to give Koeman a partner, the Dream team occasionally played Laudrup in a false 9 role, with Stoichkov being the actual striker but starting from out wide. That’s exactly what Bergkamp and Cavani are doing here and they are both well suited to it. Notice Cavani’s flank is Brehme’s to run. Edi has complete freedom there, while Robben does indeed play a more traditional winger role with his overlapping fullback, either going for the byline or cutting inside.
The big decision really was whether to start Robben or Müller. The setup is one which works well on the counter, but I don’t plan to do that all game. My players are well suited to exert a good measure of control over proceedings, but I do expect Gio to come out all guns blazing so I’d prefer that pace on the break and dribbling early on, particularly against a fullback who wasn’t exactly blessed with pace.
As the game settles into a more balanced affair, Müller would be an obvious sub to reinforce control of the game and find more intricate paths to goal.
Key considerations I would like to highlight:
Overall, once you look beyond an impressive and defensively solid spine, every relevant factor to be considered indicates my team is superior to Gio’s and will prevail.
- Brehme vs. Panucci. Only one winner.
- Sagnol and Robben vs. Carboni. Two winners here.
- Rivaldo, López, Hagi and Vieri are all left-footed (some of them very left-footed). It’s a good thing their preferred path to goal is guarded by Lilian Thuram.
- Every single one of my defenders and midfielders is superb on the ball. There’s a distinct gap between Gio’s defenders and midfielders and mine in terms of the precision and range of their passing. Koeman-Popescu-Cocu/Schweini is as strong a spine as you could hope for to dictate play centrally from deep.
- Proven partnerships across the pitch: Thuram and Sagnol (France ’06), Popescu and Cocu (both regularly in a Barca midfield three), Schweinsteiger and Robben/Müller (treble-winning Bayern), Koeman/Cocu and Bergkamp (Netherlands). The only relationship of any relevance for Gio is Simeone-López.
- You will hear a lot about Vieri and his record from headers, which is indeed excellent. Good thing I have a keeper who excelled aerially and would regularly make it all academic by just intercepting the crosses.
2-1
I expect our midfield to exert control of the match. Davids and Simeone are fiercely competitive all-rounders who will provide the platform for the attacking trio of Claudio Lopez, Michel and, the best player on the park by some distance, Rivaldo, to show off their quality. That's a tasty and talented five that marries physicality (Davids and Simeone's bite, Piojo's pace), technical ability (all five) and mental qualities (Rivaldo's vision, Simeone's resilience, Michel's creativity) to form a balanced midfield. Cocu, Schweinsteiger and Bergkamp are all good players that I rate but are coming up against a more impressive trio. There is no doubt about that.
Dealing with the opposition's threat:
Anto has a very decent attack, however Bergomi, Campbell, Carboni and Kohler are a robust and uncompromising quartet who will run a tight ship. Frankly I'm not seeing any of Anto's forward players getting the best out of that back-line. If Robben cuts in from the right, he'll be entering Davids or Kohler territory.
One particular route to goal will be Christian Vieri getting on the end of Michel's crosses. Koeman (and Popescu if he plays) haven't got the strength, spring or pace to deal with the powerful Vieri, who, as the all-time highest scorer of headed goals in Serie A, could have a fruitful day.
As the best player on the park Rivaldo has the right players around him to fire on all cylinders. Two grafting ball-winners to do the dirty work, the sheer pace of Claudio Lopez to stretch the play (see the same role played by Overmars, Carlos), the right-sided invention and wide play of Michel (see the same role played by Figo), and a proper target-man-cum-centre-forward in Christian Vieri (see Kluivert or Ronaldo). The irrepressible genius Gheorge Hagi waits patiently on the bench to grab or create a match-winner - should his services be required.
Last edited: