Rate the Premier League managers 2024/2025 edition

[SilentWitness]

A - Pep.

B - Arteta, Emery.

C - Slot, Ange, Ten Hag.

D - Silva, Howe, Iraola, Glasner, Frank, Lopetegui.

McKenna, Hurzeler, Maresca, Martin.

E - Dyche, Nuno, O'Neil, Cooper.

Something like that. I don't know enough yet about those managers in the dead zone between D and E to judge properly yet but the former three are closer to D than E and Martin is closer to E than D.

I think that the managers in C are all on the periphery of either B or D too.

A - Pep.

B - Arteta, Emery, Slot.

C - Ange, Silva, Iraola, Howe, Nuno, Maresca, Hurzeler and Frank.

D - McKenna, Glasner, Lopetegui, Ten Hag.

E - Dyche, O'Neil, Cooper, Martin.

Maybe something like this now? It's hard to do a rating really as I want to try and be fair to recent management experiences and also their history as a manager so some people like McKenna may be slightly worse and others like Maresca/Ange/Ten Hag may be seen favourably.

The C/D zones are quite close with a gap between the B to C and the D to E.

 

[Bartondale]

For me it's Iraola and Hurzeler joint top. What they have achieved this season without any truly outstanding players is amazing at such small clubs.

Both Bournemouth and Brighton play terrific football and are capable of giving any top Premiership side a difficult game. Makes me wonder if Pep, Slot and Arteta could do the same with such limited resources. Hope both managers get a chance with a traditional top six club before their careers end.

 

[Red Star One]

For me it's Iraola and Hurzeler joint top. What they have achieved this season without any truly outstanding players is amazing at such small clubs.

Both Bournemouth and Brighton play terrific football and are capable of giving any top Premiership side a difficult game. Makes me wonder if Pep, Slot and Arteta could do the same with such limited resources. Hope both managers get a chance with a traditional top six club before their careers end.

Hurzeler is doing some incredible work and it never stops shocking me he is younger than some of our players, like Casemiro what a managerial talent.