Rashford v Maguire, Who's the bigger fraud ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is there not enough threads on this kind of shit.
 
Not really no, but I get that people need a scapegoat because it lets them feel like there's an easy solution.

The reality is, swap van Dijk and Maguire tonight and Liverpool still win 0-4
Honestly it's not about scapegoating, Maguire has contributed to a lot of goals against the team, it's not a conspiracy. It's just the reality, of course he isn't the only problem but he's a massive one. Whatever good player he used to be at a certain time for Utd, he's no longer that.
 
Wish we would cut this out seriously. Yes fecking Maguire is looking like an average defender, yes Rashford is having a horrible season, but for feck sake can we quit with the scape goating. I actually want these two to become giants in a cohesive team, honestly feel like they can do it, and contributing to their downfall like this doesn't sit right with me.
 
Maguire seeing as he was apparently supposed to be worth 80m. Rashford I wouldn’t call a fraud as such, as he’s shown his quality in the past. I genuinely think he has a mental issue.
 
Maguire and it’s not even a contest. Rashford has been outstanding for us. Maguire is pure shit and will continue to be just that.
 
I'd say they're on par. One of them is pretty useless but the other had potential and just got ahead of himself and let it all go.
 
Both have been absolutely terrible this season. Only thing I'd say is Maguire cost us 80 million and is captain. He is probably one of the worst transfers of all time when you consider the cost. At least Rashford came from our academy and is still pretty young so has a chance to recover his career.
 
Just feck them both. I guess I would have to pick Rashford he at least has something but the other one is beyond shit.
 
Maguire, he gives it the biggun as well but he's the biggest fraudster around.
 
Rashford has shown he is top class and is young enough to get over the slump he had found himself in.

Maguire has never shown he will be remotely good enough for United and still just continue to get worse
 
I thought we could get through this thread without bringing up Scapegoat. Now just waiting for his pal Agenda to show up.
 
Maguire definitely. He epitomizes everything that's bad about us this season and a massive part of why our confidence is in the mire.
 
Rashford was a promising talent until persistent injuries and loss of confidence ruined him. Maguire was always a nothing player and should never have been signed.
 
Wish we would cut this out seriously. Yes fecking Maguire is looking like an average defender, yes Rashford is having a horrible season, but for feck sake can we quit with the scape goating. I actually want these two to become giants in a cohesive team, honestly feel like they can do it, and contributing to their downfall like this doesn't sit right with me.
How does our discussing this contribute to their shocking performances?
 
Wish we would cut this out seriously. Yes fecking Maguire is looking like an average defender, yes Rashford is having a horrible season, but for feck sake can we quit with the scape goating. I actually want these two to become giants in a cohesive team, honestly feel like they can do it, and contributing to their downfall like this doesn't sit right with me.

I want a lot of things, but these two will never make it here mate I hate to break it to you. It's not contributing to their "downfall" they did that themselves.
 
Very poor thread indeed. We can make about 10 of these giving our current state. Martial vs Pogba, Lindelof vs Shaw or prehaps Matić vs Fred.
 
Very poor thread indeed. We can make about 10 of these giving our current state. Martial vs Pogba, Lindelof vs Shaw or prehaps Matić vs Fred.
Not a good example there. One’s a proven winner and the other is someone we completely fall apart without, and who’s been one of our best players this season.

As for the thread, I’ll have to go for Maguire.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.