Question for Guitar blokes

Grinner

Not fat gutted. Hirsuteness of shoulders TBD.
Joined
May 5, 2003
Messages
72,631
Location
I love free dirt and rocks!
Supports
Arsenal

I was watching this on the Grammys and thought the bloke was pretty bloody good at about 3:45.

Is this impressive guitar pickin' or just a bit of showing off?
 
If youtube videos worked on my work computer, I'd be able to regail you with my expert opinion, including a mark out of ten.
 
Very good imo

He's playing tight very short staccato strums, not necessarily picking as one would usually do it with some nice quick finger work at the neck. I'd say he's very good myself

As for Rodrigo and Gabriela. Absolutely fantastic. Her rhythm playing is sensational and together they are as tight as fk - wonderful stuff - percussive, melodic, vibrant - do love that earthy Spanish guitar sound and feel ....a whole technique on it's own that
 
Waiting for a "Look ma, no hands!" act to re-invigorate my interest in human music.



He's so fast the audio and video eventually go out of synch.

And in case you were wondering, I can pretty much play all the notes in the solo. Just not in the same order.
 
Yeah, the bloke knows his scales but it's nowt special.

Try these two:


Seen them live a few months ago they were brilliant especially the girl. You really need to see them live to get her full sound when she's slapping the beat on the guitar the place was bouncing.
That was so... boring.

:rolleyes:
 
As for Rodrigo and Gabriela. Absolutely fantastic. Her rhythm playing is sensational and together they are as tight as fk - wonderful stuff - percussive, melodic, vibrant - do love that earthy Spanish guitar sound and feel ....a whole technique on it's own that

Is that who's in the video Plech posted? (still at work)

And are those the two who were on Jools Holland not too long ago, on that new year thing?

If so, they were pretty cool
 
Diudn't they start off busking in Dublin?

Apparently they're both from death metal bands, before they decided to go all mellow.

Yea busking and playing in bars around Grafton street. Don't know about the metal part. I can't stress how amazing they are live it blew me away.


Don't know how Gabriela can play barre chords the whole night and her wrist not feel like it's on fire.
 
That was an alternate strumming technique where he also seemed to mute certain strings, it's nothing amazingly spectacular to be honest, just good rhythm and fret-work. If speed is what gets you going, check out EVanHalen or Yngwie Malsteen.
 
What the feck? :lol:

There's music in everything. At least according to my good friend August Rush (I had to apologize eight times a day to my eyeballs for four days before they grudgingly agreed to revert from armored steel plating back to rods and cones.)

But seriously. There's music in everything.
 
Here's one of the great guitar performances of all time:

 
:lol: Metal produces guitarists who can pick very fast and like pinch harmonics.

Being able to play fast doesnt make you a "great" guitarist in any way, shape or form.

Don't patronise me boy, I know. I'm talking about some of the best technical guitarists in the world, like Satriani, Dimebag, Petrucci etc. Cheesy but technically brilliant.
 
To be fair, I know a fair few guitarists, and all of the most natural/talented seem to be into metal.

It's actually quite annoying.
 
The heavier the distortion the easier it is to make it sound like you're a pro.
 
tbh its the age old syndrome - being technically proficient doe'snt amount to much when there's not much musicality behind it

A lot of shreders are that - lightning fast scalic techncians and although I can 'get with that' in a purely instrumental virtuosic way - it does have its own euphoria wizzing up and down an instrument at a massive speed - it is musically limiting

Although I know Via, Malmsteen, Satriani et al are great technical exponents I personally cant really name you two songs by each of them that amount to anything musical. Just my opinion before anyone gets 'hurt'
 
This reminds me of something I was talking about in the Avatar thread

No one loves Dragonforce for the music though, they're just easily impressed by technical ability. It's like looking at a piece of really shit art, but being impressed because the guy painted it with the brush in his arse.

Yes, metal guitarists often have excellent technique. Mainly because they spent their formative years locked in a dark bedroom practicing playing scales faster and faster between bouts of masturbation and failing to wash their hair. Unfortunately many of them never actually learnt about MUSIC.
 
This reminds me of something I was talking about in the Avatar thread



Yes, metal guitarists often have excellent technique. Mainly because they spent their formative years locked in a dark bedroom practicing playing scales faster and faster between bouts of masturbation and failing to wash their hair. Unfortunately many of them never actually learnt about MUSIC.

Wait... the teenage years weren't like that for everybody?
 
I saw them at the Apollo a few months back, absolutely brilliant. Who'd have thought that 2 people with accoustic guitars could make so much noise.

Now they are what I define as people probing, creating, stretching all the known parameters of what we call music and it leaves such a fine and delicious feeling in the ear - fantastic