Jose is probably top 3 in the world in terms of getting the most out of his players. Had he gotten here in 2013 instead of Moyes i am pretty confident we would have won another PL or two. Problem is that it always ends in disaster since he ends up in conflict with someone.
And i am not making excuses for Ole here, but on my last flight to Manchester i talked with a guy who claimed to be best mates with Daniel Berg Hæstad (was captain under Ole in Molde). He told me Ole trusted his coaches to conduct the training sessions and half the time he was not even there. He also mostly listened to his tactical coaches regarding team selections and in-game tactics. Now this was just some guy, but it seems like a strange thing to lie about and imo if this was how he did things at Molde i dont see why it is any different here. Regarding our coaches though, i seem to remember us getting significantly worse when Jose replaced Rui Faria with Carrick/McKenna and i also seem to remember Phelan was a big step down from Queiroz
Now Ole is the one who has picked the coaches so hes responsible in the end, but his coaching team are hardly pulling up trees either. Overall i think we look more solid in defense, but that might just be down to the fact that we actually have a competent RB now. Every single PL game this season we just seem to switch completely off and concede some cheap fecking goal. Like yesterday, granted it was well done by King, but why the feck do we allow him so much time? AWB could have done better, but its not his fecking job to look after their CF. The way Lindelof reacts is just bizarre. Get your body between him and goal, dont move in the opposite fecking direction, that is schoolyard stuff.
The lack of chances created is an even bigger problem and when we do get into decent positions we fail to make an impact because either the final ball is lacking or the finish is lacking. I dont know if this is mostly a player quality issue, a confidence issue or a coaching issue, probably a mix, but either way its fecking dire. Take yesterday again as an example. James get played through and squares it to Pereira who tries to to shoot first time despite having loads of time and space and then he misses the ball completely. Good chance that does not even result is an attempt. Fred gets a free shot a couple of minutes later and just blasts it into the stands. Corners for us is probably 0.1 xG since we have not scored from a corner in fecking ages
Another thing is the players mentality or lack there off. Remember when Ole first got here? Players who looked like they gave zero fecks in December suddenly looked like world beaters and played like men possessed and then they reverted back to playing like complete fecking fannies. The last couple of weeks has also been mirrored that albeit in a smaller scale. Liverpool, Norwich and Chelsea we actually looked like we gave a feck and most of the player delivered legit 7-8/10 performances and then we get served shite like yesterday were everyone bar maybe James and AWB looked like Championship players. Granted there were probably some tired legs out there, but so early in the season there is no excuses to turn off completely like that.
I would also ask questions about our medical staff and fitness coaches. Why the feck are sustaining so many muscular injures? Is everyone here made from paper? Liverpool and City play with much higher intensity than us and they dont have half of our injury problems. I also wonder what the feck our scouting department have been doing these past years. I dont know if is they, Ed or the former managers who should take most of the blame, but the amount of money we have pissed away on shite players is just astonishing. We have spent the second most only below City since Fergie left and most of those transfers have been utter shite.
Ole does deserve credit for his transfers though. Buying an actual RB, a good CB instead of 3 mediocre ones and a cheap, young RW is more than can be said about his predecessors. The fact that James and AWB have been head and shoulders above the rest this season says a lot imo.
I think Ole has the right ideas regarding squad building, but his coaching or lack thereof is seriously holding us back, and if his manager style is the same as it was in Molde i think his choice of coaches has been detrimental. I perfectly understand those who wants Ole out, because despite us being in a rebuild, midtable is clearly not good enough
BUT! There is a couple of more things i would like to see before the plug is pulled on Ole
- Assuming Ole does as he did in Molde and this guy i met is not full of shit: Getting some new coaches and especially a new world class attacking coach could hopefully change things for the better
- Some kind of change in both medical/fitness and scouting. We should not be having so many injuries early in the season and besides James we have not unearthed a hidden gem in ages
- See what happens in the January window. As i said i think Ole has done really well in the market and if we do one or two key signings in January we might suddenly look a lot stronger. We have also been heavily linked with Haaland who looks like the real deal, 6 goals in three matches in the CL (Messi 17, Ronaldo: 32 to reach the same). And honestly the only realistic way we are going to secure his signature is if Ole is managing us, considering their history and close personal relationship. Also, regarding our transfers i think Woody has promised Ole x amount of time to build his squad. If he was told this summer that top 4 was a minimum requirement then i am pretty sure we would have bought more players, even if they were stop gap solutions
- If we are sacking him, the nest guy has to be the right one. No point in getting a new manager if we just are going to keep threading water and scramble for a top 4 finish. We need someone with the skills, the stones to handle the pressure and a proper long term vision. Getting an interim would be utterly pointless since it does not solve anything really and if he turns out to be an unpopular character, things might actually get worse. Poch, Ten Haag, Marco Rose, Nagelsmann are all exciting young coaches, but honestly i dont think they have the gravitas and experience needed to turn this around (yet). Seeing Ole sacked, one of them hired and having them fail one or two years down the line would be absolutely heartbreaking, because that would turn us into a right graveyard for managers which would mean no one in their right mind would ever take the job. Also if we sack Ole now, the implication for the new manager is that you have to deliver RIGHT NOW and you will have the ghost of an immensely popular character hanging over you for the rest of the season. That does not sound like much fun to be honest. On the other hand, if we end the season on the lower half of the table (or something like that) with zero signs of progress, then everyone would be in agreement that Ole has failed to meet the minimum requirements and deserves to be sacked. The pressure on the next manager would also be much more reasonable, because then he will be told he will at least be shown some patience and it will be a much lower bar to clear in terms of improvements and progress
That's my thoughts anyway. 2 points from B'mouth, Newcastle, Palace and Soton is clearly far from good enough, but now more than ever do we need to keep a cool head.