- Joined
- Dec 13, 2018
- Messages
- 67
One of the worse takes on here. Including Herrera is better.Anyone remember the lunatics claiming Fred is just as good?
One of the worse takes on here. Including Herrera is better.Anyone remember the lunatics claiming Fred is just as good?
Anyone remember the lunatics claiming Fred is just as good?
Ah. I remember that. The best part about that thread was the timingWell, there was also that thread about Herrera vs Kante while Chelsea were dominating the league.
I mean I liked Herrera but back then it even looked stupid.
He probably won't be, but on merit he should be in the Balon d'or conversation this year.
Makelele, Gattuso, Essien, Kimmich and Busquets all in with a shout off the top of my head .Hard to have a mount Rushmore of midfielders but in terms of a box to box ball winner, no one beats Kante in the history of the game right ?
Makelele, Gattuso, Essien, Kimmich and Busquets all in with a shout off the top of my head .
If he wants to open his pockets and let our midfield out for next season I'd appreciate it
Makelele, Gattuso, Essien, Kimmich and Busquets all in with a shout off the top of my head .
It's ok bud. We all make silly comments sometimes. At least you had the balls to admit to yoursI once described Fred as “Kante with footballing ability”
Jesus...
I agree with you he's a level below the others.Gattuso doesnt deserve to be there. He was loud, charismatic and tried but limited. Did help make Pirlo in DM work though
There's a bit of recency bias there for sure but Kante is an incredible player and has the quiet humbleness that makes him very likable. Would love for United to have a player of his defensive quality in our midfield.Great to amazing players listed there Eagle, but none of them with 3 consecutive MOTM performances in the biggest competition of the sport. Kante transforms his team. It's said all the time so it sounds like a cliche, but it isn't. He IS two players! You can set up as 2 man midfield but with Kante it's basically a 3. Am I hyperbole here ? I don't know.
So as a Man City fan, watching your team play without this type of player and getting dominated by Kante, whats your take?
Play without one like Pep did in the final, keep faith with Rodri and the idea that he will improve to Fernandinho levels, or "find the next Kante" ?
Great to amazing players listed there Eagle, but none of them with 3 consecutive MOTM performances in the biggest competition of the sport. Kante transforms his team. It's said all the time so it sounds like a cliche, but it isn't. He IS two players! You can set up as 2 man midfield but with Kante it's basically a 3. Am I hyperbole here ? I don't know.
This is spot on and it's by far the biggest value Kante brings to the team - it's also why he was wasted under Sarri and Lampard playing in a midfield 3.
Last year during lockdown it seemed like Lampard had stumbled onto something by having Kante sit deeper and move from side to side, but the issue then is you miss out on his (generally underrated) ability to carry the ball and also to press vertically.
What's really interesting to me about Kante is that I think he has the same gift Dennis Rodman of the NBA did - a preternatural ability to instantly assess the flight of the ball, the angles, and where and how it might deflect. Rodman used this gift to become one of the greatest rebounders the NBA has ever seen, and I think Kante's intuitive understanding of where a ball is likely to end up makes him one of the greatest recoverers of the ball ever. A lot of people focus on his ridiculous physical attributes (for good reason; the man has the lungs of a horse), but I think his reading of the geometry of the game is almost equally key to his success.
This is spot on and it's by far the biggest value Kante brings to the team - it's also why he was wasted under Sarri and Lampard playing in a midfield 3.
Last year during lockdown it seemed like Lampard had stumbled onto something by having Kante sit deeper and move from side to side, but the issue then is you miss out on his (generally underrated) ability to carry the ball and also to press vertically.
What's really interesting to me about Kante is that I think he has the same gift Dennis Rodman of the NBA did - a preternatural ability to instantly assess the flight of the ball, the angles, and where and how it might deflect. Rodman used this gift to become one of the greatest rebounders the NBA has ever seen, and I think Kante's intuitive understanding of where a ball is likely to end up makes him one of the greatest recoverers of the ball ever. A lot of people focus on his ridiculous physical attributes (for good reason; the man has the lungs of a horse), but I think his reading of the geometry of the game is almost equally key to his success.
Well, there was also that thread about Herrera vs Kante while Chelsea were dominating the league.
I mean I liked Herrera but back then it even looked stupid.
He's like the CDM version of AWB absolutely terrific to nullify opponents, he can basically dry up any midfielder. Really helpful when facing top class opposition, but when facing lesser teams I don't think he adds to much offensively he's all hyped at the moment and deservedly but I wouldn't take it that far as him being the best player in the world.
He's like the CDM version of AWB absolutely terrific to nullify opponents, he can basically dry up any midfielder. Really helpful when facing top class opposition, but when facing lesser teams I don't think he adds to much offensively he's all hyped at the moment and deservedly but I wouldn't take it that far as him being the best player in the world.
Against a team like City he's your best shot but if having to choose overall I would rather have Kimmich or Casemiro which can do the defensive work while also adding offensive power.
Anyway lovely player we should had got him when we had the chance.
He might not have a Fabregas level distribution but his pressing can be incredibly effective for creating transitions of play. I've posted this before but he his reading of the game & tackling here created the goal just as much as a fantastic pass would've.
I rate other players higher, like Lewandowski or Messi at the moment.He just won them a Champions League and has been at the heart of their revival in the past 5 months.
They haven't lost a game while he was on the pitch. How is he not the best player in the world?
You are wrong about his distribution.
He's great, but facing a low block he has no use for that pressing. You need other skills to break them down.
Under Tuchels set up he's amazing, but I don't imagine him being a starter under one of Pep's teams for example or under current Bayern. He lacks some skills that limit him from playing in possession dominant teams.
He's great, but facing a low block he has no use for that pressing. You need other skills to break them down.
Under Tuchels set up he's amazing, but I don't imagine him being a starter under one of Pep's teams for example or under current Bayern. He lacks some skills that limit him from playing in possession dominant teams.
A low block is only a thing when the opponents are in their defensive shape, so someone like Kanté is actually exactly what you want against teams that plan to use a low block, his ability to stop the opposition transition from defense to attack and subsequent ability to quickly start the attacking transition of his own team are key and valuable.
The question is, can he win a B’allon Dor?
Fabio Canavaro, 2006?Not flashy enough. Last time a defensive player won it was 25 years ago (Sammer).
It's not impossible now that Messi and Rocaldo have slowed down a bit. IIRC van Dijk came very close a few years ago.Not flashy enough. Last time a defensive player won it was 25 years ago (Sammer).
Fabio Canavaro, 2006?
Yes, I'm not saying Kante is useless when in possession I'm saying he shines when facing a possession team.Chelsea are a "possession dominant" team in almost every game we play. We averaged 61.39% possession in the league this season (Man City averaged 63.82%).
Man City had more possession than us last night but we had more than them in the 2-1 League win a few months ago.
Yeah that Rodman comparison is a great call. His instincts are just razor sharp, he has a sixth sense for catching people out with marginally loose balls, particularly transitioning from defence to attack. Having him as a sitting midfielder never made sense. I had a slight hope we could nab him from you when it was obvious he wasn’t being utilised properly in the last couple of years. “Past it” apparently