It's a forum league, you're going to have look at it.
NFL Dynasty League
- Thread starter Eboue
- Start date
It's a forum league, you're going to have look at it.
Do we have any fookin results yet of the vote?
Is it that close that the last doucher must be waited for?
Is it that close that the last doucher must be waited for?
Three proposals hang in the balance - @RedIceland
Check my trade offer too while you’re at it @RedIceland
Hopefully moving to Sleeper isn’t one of the proposals in balance; that app would help fix things like this.
That's unanimous
Could have just killed off Red Iceland - would mean I wouldn't have to lose all my players
It said fill in by 16th of january. Not the end of the world to do it on the 13th 
. I've voted now.
. I've voted now.Alto where are the results you feckhead
1. Move provider to Sleeper from MyFantasyLeague
Yes: 14
No: 0
Verdict: Enacted
2. Increase buy-in to $100 from $50
Yes: 12
No: 2
Verdict: Enacted
3. Weekly Highest Score Bonus only eligible during the regular season (Weeks 1-14)
Yes: 13
No: 1
Verdict: Enacted
4. What should the 'Week 14' format be? Choose as many as you like, one with most votes wins.
Verdict: League Average Enacted
5. Remove Kickers
Yes: 7
No: 7
Verdict: Rejected
6. Remove D/ST
Yes: 7
No: 7
Verdict: Rejected
7. Add one flex spot to the starting line-up
Yes: 5
No: 9
Verdict: Rejected
Yes: 14
No: 0
Verdict: Enacted
2. Increase buy-in to $100 from $50
Yes: 12
No: 2
Verdict: Enacted
3. Weekly Highest Score Bonus only eligible during the regular season (Weeks 1-14)
Yes: 13
No: 1
Verdict: Enacted
4. What should the 'Week 14' format be? Choose as many as you like, one with most votes wins.
Verdict: League Average Enacted
5. Remove Kickers
Yes: 7
No: 7
Verdict: Rejected
6. Remove D/ST
Yes: 7
No: 7
Verdict: Rejected
7. Add one flex spot to the starting line-up
Yes: 5
No: 9
Verdict: Rejected
Looks like the new teams fecked over with DST too
Playing against league average is so boring you suckers!
Yeah indeed, sucks.altodevil said:
I suggest we re-vote for the last 3 with a view to enacting them for 2023. I suspect they’d get over the line.
Shouldn't the FLEX protection for the expansion draft also be gone then since there won't be an extra FLEX spot added to the rosters?
No that was already going to be the case before that proposal.
@rpitroda I plan on running another form with proposals - with a 'tick as many as you'd like' for 2022/2023 enactments. Everyone should get proposals posted in here, all that are seconded will be included.
On that note - I second the remove kickers and defense proposals.
Still fecks us over though, one less starting spot but you get the same amount of protected players - I assume the expansion rules were proposed based on the assumption that K and D/ST were going to be removed in favour of the extra FLEX spot.
No kickers and defenses were planned to be removed, but an extra flex spot was my own fantasy that Eboue didn't buy in to.
@altodevil Can that extra flex spot be a QB? Or limited to RB, WR or TE?
Not sure how I feel about super flex leagues
It wasn't meant to be superflex, no.
I think superflex is the modern league and in favour - but safe to say I know that wouldn't be agreed-on.
I think superflex is the modern league and in favour - but safe to say I know that wouldn't be agreed-on.
You should feel great - you have Dak and Burrow
Hence my quandaryYou should feel great - you have Dak and Burrow
No DST or K is standard for modern dynasty formats. It’s RNG that holds no long term or trade value. Defenses change so much that holding them for years makes no sense; only individual players jibe with the dynasty format.
Plus, think about it in a 14 team league. There’s barely two to go around for everyone. Lazy people that don’t want to research players and build a deep bench can hold extras so that others can’t stream them, holding them for ransom from someone facing a bye week. It creates the potential for unsportsmanlike behavior that goes against the idea of the format in a league this size.
If you must keep defense in there, it should be individual defenders you are keeping.
I propose that if someone was valuing those positions more and invested in them with multiple placeholders, they can get a compensatory pick at the end of the 3rd or something.
Plus, think about it in a 14 team league. There’s barely two to go around for everyone. Lazy people that don’t want to research players and build a deep bench can hold extras so that others can’t stream them, holding them for ransom from someone facing a bye week. It creates the potential for unsportsmanlike behavior that goes against the idea of the format in a league this size.
If you must keep defense in there, it should be individual defenders you are keeping.
I propose that if someone was valuing those positions more and invested in them with multiple placeholders, they can get a compensatory pick at the end of the 3rd or something.
Last edited:
Also, I propose if we do another set of votes that an early (~2ish weeks after the draft) or late (August or whatever like last year) rookie draft be on the ballot.
threadmark this
What would you guys be willing to give up Saquon for in dynasty if you're not contending at the moment (I'm the Barkley owner and not contending)? Guy in my home league (16 teams) with a shitload of picks keeps harrassing me to trade him for 2 1st rounders this year (10 and 14), I've stood my ground so far in wanting 3 first rounders (1.10 this year, and a 23 and 24 first rounder).
Hard to figure out whether Barkley's worth is still at 3 first round picks. I don't like the Giants and their offense sucks so might be that Barkley will never be an elite RB again for fantasy purposes but feels like I'd be selling at a low point right now.
Hard to figure out whether Barkley's worth is still at 3 first round picks. I don't like the Giants and their offense sucks so might be that Barkley will never be an elite RB again for fantasy purposes but feels like I'd be selling at a low point right now.
No comment from me
That 14 doesn’t move the needle for me this year where I think the second tier break (after 1.1-1.3) will be around 1.11. That’s assuming 1QB.
Yeah 1QB league. I think there are only 3 viable RBs with immediate fantasy value in this class, but the tier 1-2 WR pool is 6, maybe 7 deep. So agreed that the drop-off would likely be around 1.10-1.11.
Nice one Gabe - save that performance for when it’s utterly useless
Where would be a good space to find an additional league?
Now that I’m actually into it I’ve got a hankering to try my hand with a 2nd team, but I’ve heard horror stories of getting into bed with randoms.
Now that I’m actually into it I’ve got a hankering to try my hand with a 2nd team, but I’ve heard horror stories of getting into bed with randoms.
Aren’t we meant to be doing something soon
We got like 4 days to send protection lists, and then March 1st the expansion draft starts and everything will start to fall into place.
And then we have the draft which is…well, sometime or another.
I presume we're DMing protection lists to @altodevil and @Eboue?
@Eboue can't we be doing the expansion draft via PM on here rather than via email? Not sure about Rado and entropy but would be much more convenient for me.
Also I think league fees are due this Sunday, how do we go about that?
And when does the switch to Sleeper take place?
Also I think league fees are due this Sunday, how do we go about that?
And when does the switch to Sleeper take place?
I’m beginning to realise how deep I’m in over my head with this, I know nothing about the rookies coming through
I expect my teams is gonna suck but oh well!
I expect my teams is gonna suck but oh well!
eboue said to PM them to him.
Also, wouldn’t we move to Sleeper before the rookie draft? We’d have to start a new league year and add the newbies in MFL. We should be able to move once the expansion draft is done.