And I was never arguing it doesn't work. I don't know if it works or not. What I'm saying is that I believe the concept to be fundamentally and in its very core unsportsmanlike. What I'm also arguing is that it's not necessary. So that 17th overall pick for Favre (thanks for clearing that up) is something that would be available for precisely the kind of teams you mentioned. So would the picks for Brady or Rodgers. Or those for Klay Thompson and Draymond Green. Now we can argue if that 7th overall pick fits that bill (I think so). But even if it doesn't, from the 2023 All Star Game alone, we have Donovan Mitchell picked at 13, Giannis was picked 15, De Rozan 9, Haliburton 12, Holiday 17, Adebayo 14, Siakam 27, Sabonis 11, Paul George 10, SGA 11, Jokic 41.
So yeah, it can be done. It can very well be done. All these picks are somewhat available for precisely the kind of teams you mentioned. And they are picks you can quite well acquire via trade. The kind of teams you mentioned could have drafted Giannis and Jokic without any trading whatsoever. Two top 5 players in the league.
There simply is no excuse for tanking. And I might add that there is no divine right for mediocre teams to become good. So being mediocre doesn't justify that sort of strategy. At least not in my view.
On the Favre trade there is a context that goes to my initial point about value. In 1990 and 1991 the Packers were bad and drafted in the top 5 or 6. In 1991 they traded down to get an additional first in 1992, that additional first became Favre.
And no one told you that it can't be done, the point is what is the best strategy, what is the strategy that is more likely to put you in a position to pick a superstar? If it was your job on the line, would you gamble on maybe picking an all NBA player in the second round or have the first pick in the draft? And if these teams that picked great players late seldomly do it more than once in a decade?
And of course there is no divine right for any team to become good but your argument is essentially that they shouldn't do anything to increase their odds, they should just be content with mediocrity and hope that luck land them someone because in both cases you hope.