Modern Draft

New
1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420)

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27)

@P-Nut0712
 
1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420) 9. N.Sule (44)

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27)


@Michaelf7777777
 
1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420) 9.

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27)

@P-Nut0712 pick again
 
Lucas Hernandez and Rafinha will be my next selections please

1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420) 9.

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27) 9. L. Hernandez 10. Rafinha (2)
 
idmanager said:
Out of curiosity, has the drafting been the usual fun?
Click to expand...
At least for me, it has been different from the usual drafting.

Sometimes I have to choose between players who have the potential to be great but haven’t achieved much yet Vs. players who have done reasonably well in their careers but not spectacular

I chose De Ligt over another central defender whose early career performances got him to a “big club” but he’s pretty much hated by the Caf :lol:
 
Indnyc said:
At least for me, it has been different from the usual drafting.

Sometimes I have to choose between players who have the potential to be great but haven’t achieved much yet Vs. players who have done reasonably well in their careers but not spectacular

I chose De Ligt over another central defender whose early career performances got him to a “big club” but he’s pretty much hated by the Caf :lol:
Click to expand...
It's been good to get away from the cross-era stuff that dominates a lot of the all-time drafts, like 'modern defenders are shit' or 'pre-war players were pub standard'. I quite like the more focused drafts to zone in on the specifics and compare like with like.
 
Gio said:
It's been good to get away from the cross-era stuff that dominates a lot of the all-time drafts, like 'modern defenders are shit' or 'pre-war players were pub standard'. I quite like the more focused drafts to zone in on the specifics and compare like with like.
Click to expand...
Yeah that’s fair
 
Gio said:
It's been good to get away from the cross-era stuff that dominates a lot of the all-time drafts, like 'modern defenders are shit' or 'pre-war players were pub standard'. I quite like the more focused drafts to zone in on the specifics and compare like with like.
Click to expand...
Era specific drafts are the best and closest to an objective discourse with plenty of evidence thrown in to boot.

Few of the earliest ones were the 60s, 70s and 50s born players which were quality. We've had the 40s one and this now that kinda covers it all from 40s to present.

Wouldn't really a 30s or rather "30s or before" one to give the pre war names a proper run out away from the cross era criticism you alluded to. Could really be interesting in terms of either going with the tactics of the time or with the modern renditions of those teams. Probably a bit of an effort in terms of digging out 16x11 players so might need to assess the pool before diving in.
 
Moby said:
Era specific drafts are the best and closest to an objective discourse with plenty of evidence thrown in to boot.

Few of the earliest ones were the 60s, 70s and 50s born players which were quality. We've had the 40s one and this now that kinda covers it all from 40s to present.

Wouldn't really a 30s or rather "30s or before" one to give the pre war names a proper run out away from the cross era criticism you alluded to. Could really be interesting in terms of either going with the tactics of the time or with the modern renditions of those teams. Probably a bit of an effort in terms of digging out 16x11 players so might need to assess the pool before diving in.
Click to expand...
If we do a draft of pre war players, then probably worth making it a smaller with say 8 managers..

Generally I feel there is slightly less interest in those players because of limited information
 
Moby said:
Era specific drafts are the best and closest to an objective discourse with plenty of evidence thrown in to boot.

Few of the earliest ones were the 60s, 70s and 50s born players which were quality. We've had the 40s one and this now that kinda covers it all from 40s to present.

Wouldn't really a 30s or rather "30s or before" one to give the pre war names a proper run out away from the cross era criticism you alluded to. Could really be interesting in terms of either going with the tactics of the time or with the modern renditions of those teams. Probably a bit of an effort in terms of digging out 16x11 players so might need to assess the pool before diving in.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I think you could do one with 8 teams as Indnyc suggested. Alternatively could extend the pool to something like pre European Cup era because the players who peaked in the late 1940s and early 1950s suffered from the same problems as the pre-war players do within all-time drafts - namely a lack of TV coverage and European or inter-continental competition to evidence their standing in the game.
 
Any scope for a different approach one time ? Perhaps no draft just put your 11 in against everyone doesn't matter if players are in every team ?
 
Should have carried on without me. Sorry guys give me a second
 
1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420) 9. D. Rugani (?) 10. J. Oblak (181)

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27) 9. L. Hernandez 10. Rafinha (2)

@BIG DUNK
 
The Cat said:
Any scope for a different approach one time ? Perhaps no draft just put your 11 in against everyone doesn't matter if players are in every team ?
Click to expand...
Drafting is the best part because you have fun seeing the thinking and strategy behind everyone’s picks
 
Edgar Allan Pillow said:
1985 is too late a cut off. Many players will be based on potential and not on actual peak. I have a couple of 21 and 22 year olds on my team, so looking forward to my usual 1st round exit.
Click to expand...

But that is the point on this draft.. We are basing a lot of things on potential and on what they have achieved so far.. It's a fair comparison against people of the same era?
 
Indnyc said:
But that is the point on this draft.. We are basing a lot of things on potential and on what they have achieved so far.. It's a fair comparison against people of the same era?
Click to expand...

Problem comes with comparing the oldies to the young players. The perfect example was brought up earlier, young player with bags of potential Vs an old player with a steady career. Which do you rate higher?
 
BIG DUNK picks

Danilo Pereira (Primeira Liga)
Defensive Midfielder







Please post video too (8Y3-RiEpe00).
 
P-Nut0712 said:
Problem comes with comparing the oldies to the young players. The perfect example was brought up earlier, young player with bags of potential Vs an old player with a steady career. Which do you rate higher?
Click to expand...
Yup.. That’s a problem but most teams would have 1 or maybe 2 players who are pure potential right now (De Ligt in my team for example). All the others should be more experienced?
 
valencia.jpg

@Enigma_87 @The Red Viper
 
1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70) 10. A. Valencia (6)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10) 10. Asamoah (26)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10) 10. M. Caldara (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10) D. Pereira (100)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420) 9. D. Rugani (?) 10. J. Oblak (181)

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27) 9. L. Hernandez 10. Rafinha (2)
 
1. Jim Beam/Sjor/Tuppet - 1. D. Godín 2. R. Varane 3. R. Firmino 4. L. Gustavo 5. A. Sandro 6. A. Turan 7. M. Brozovic 8. J. Vardy 9. Heung-Min Son (∞)

2. Willhse456 - 1. L. Suarez 2. V. Kompany 3. N. Matic (17) 4. T. Alcântara (4) 5. M. Ozil (35) 6. J. Cuadrado (420) 7. N. Subotic (11) 8. T. Lemar (70) 9. T. Meunier (10)

3. Don Alfredo - 1. Neymar 2. L. Nani 3. E. Cavani (2) 4. F. Luis (4) 5. M. Pjanic (1) 6. M. Dembele (4) 7. G. Cahill (7) 8. A. Florenzi (10) 9. A. Rudiger (10)

4. The Cat - 1. G. Bale 2. Isco 3. M. Icardi (90) 4. S. Umtiti (120) 5. S. Mane (2) 6. Fernandinho (240) 7. K. Strootman (130) 8. N. Sule (10) 9. Ederson (10)

5. Isotope - 1. E. Hazard 2. D. Costa 3. J. Boateng (180) 4. I. Gundogan (24) 5. I. Rakitic (170) 6. B. Pavard (420) 7. D. Mertens (10) 8. I. Akinfeev (72) 9. Allan Marques Loureiro (140) 10. Allan (140)

6. MJJ - 1. L. Modric 2. L. Bonucci 3. C. Fabregas (10) 4. Benzema (67) 5. K. Walker (5) 6. G. Clichy (54) 7. L. Sane (10) 8. Y. Carrasco (40) 9. G. Lo Celso (15)

7. 2mufc0 - 1. A. Griezmann 2. R. Falcao 3. M. Verratti (10) 4. V. v. Dijk (258) 5. D. Costa (5) 6. Juanfran (2) 7. Ramires (42) 8. D. Sanchez (1) 9. R. Rodriguez (25)

8. Skizzo - 1. S. Aguero 2. S. Busquets 3. D. Alaba (7) 4. D. De Gea (1) 5. T. Alderweireld (10) 6. I. Perisic (10) 7. K. Manolas (10) 8. S. Roberto (10) 9. J. Callejon (30) 10. Oscar (1)

9. Gio - 1. K. de Bruyne 2. A. Vidal 3. M. Neuer (57) 4. K. Koulibaly (60) 5. M. Hamsik (2) 6. Marquinhos (20) 7. F. Coentrão (8) 8. E. Džeko (68) 9. A. Rabiot (20) 10. E. Lavezzi (58)

10. Enigma/TRV - 1. N. Kanté 2. A. Sánchez 3. M. Hummels (45) 4. J. Rodríguez (1) 5. D. Carvajal (8) 6. J. Giménez (1) 7. R. Sterling (8) 8. G. Higuain (2) 9. N. Sahin (8) 10. F. Ghoulam (4)

11. Indnyc - 1. R. Lewandowski 2. M. Reus 3. C. Azpilicueta (10) 4. P. Coutinho (37) 5. J. Alba (5) 6. L. Koscielny (10) 7. S. Nzonzi (10) 8. E. Banega (2) 9. M. de Ligt (70) 10. A. Valencia (6)

12. Moby - 1. W. Rooney 2. K. Mbappé 3. A. Di Maria (18) 4. R. Mahrez (435) 5. Koke (180) 6. P. Zabaleta 7. Saul (40) 8. A. Laporte (9) 9. A. Romagnoli (10) 10. Asamoah (26)

13. Edgar - 1. T. Muller 2. T. Kroos 3. C. Marchisio (375) 4. R. Lukaku (10) 5. J. Vertonghen (10) 6. Jorginho (10) 7. C. Smalling (10) 8. M. Skriniar (10) 9. F. Chiesa (10) 10. M. Caldara (10)

14. Big Dunk - 1. S. Ramos 2. H. Kane 3. Marcelo (30) 4. R. Nainggolan (50) 5. L. Piszczek (90) 6. Pedro (309) 7. L. Insigne (22) 8. J. Mata (3) 9. R. Albiol (10) D. Pereira (100)

15. P-Nut - 1. D. Silva 2. C. Eriksen 3. P. Aubameyang (10) 4. Casemiro (10) 5. J. Kimmich (250) 6. B. Matuidi (9) 7. A. Kolarov (10) 8. L.Goretzka (420) 9. D. Rugani (?) 10. J. Oblak (181)

16. Michaelf7777777 - 1. P. Dybala 2. M. Salah 3. P. Pogba 4. G. Piqué (16) 5. S. Khedira 6. J. Martinez (9) 7. H. Lozano 8. M. Benatia (27) 9. L. Hernandez 10. Rafinha (2)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.