I'm worried someone may nab them
MEN: Carrick and McKenna next in line for contract extensions
- Thread starter OleBoiii
- Start date
Most people won't stick around after a demotion.
feck me. Are we living in some sort of parallel universe?
Why and in what role? Apparently the players are less than impressed by his training methods/sessions, and he's a central figure in this absolute (tactical) shitshow.
This is one final feck you from woody to the fans isn't it 
Yeah. Probably the lower quality American version as well.
Get a podcast from Rangnick on there Michael you might just actually learn something about coaching then
This will be the sign one way or the other of whether Ole is staying or leaving.
what the hell is going on ? I'm really struggling to believe this isn't some giant piss take .
god that was awful.
SURELY not.
That must be a pisstake!
United fans SERIOUSLY need to use international break to let the Glazers know they need to act - immediately.
The situation at United is absolutely shameful.
Yep I agree. Actually carrick could have done with proper help too
Our deteriorating in the form happened when Rui Faria left, and McKenna became the training guy.
Of course, it might be a coincidence and the entire fault was with Mourinho and Ole. But we have been playing pretty badly since McKenna got promoted and in the last three years, he has been the main coach at the club.
He was but that's when he was managing the u18s, almost 5 years ago.
Yeah, this is a pretty damning piece of evidence on McKenna's time with the first team.
Plus there were complaints about his methods being too basic (which then were apparently resolved) from senior players.
Just saying, bad form started when that poster joined
We wouldn’t have been beaten 5-0 against Liverpool if it hadn’t been for this uncertainty regarding their contract situations. If our useless board had acted quicker we would’ve beaten them 3-1 and City 4-2, which would’ve left us in a much more favourable situation. The board only have themselves to blame for dithering.
McKenna is well respected within the industry. You've no idea what his coaching abilities are.
Most Managers will clear the decks when they take over a club, but some like to keep someone from the old regime - if the a new Manager keeps anyone I'd guess it would be McKenna.
After Jose left we went on an incredible run of form playing some absolutely amazing football - with players even commenting on specific bits of coaching after the game. At least in the first two games it was understood that the team had pretty much just been coached by McKenna and Carrick, so whilst Ole was purely and interim one could maybe imagine that they had far more influence. Ole then gets the job, we get injuries and immediately the tactics become very pragmatic.
There were rumours that McKenna and Carrick had a plan against Liverpool but Ole opted to play the exact same team that got torn apart by Atalanta. You say we've been playing pretty badly since he got promoted, but we've also had runs of forms where we've looked really really good, not just in moments but whole games.
It's just very hard to know quite how good coaches are when the buck stops at the manager and we don't actually see the work that goes on during training.
To be fair you can tell from what is going on the pitch no?
And in any case why are we extending the contracts of coaches when a new regime is imminent?
The answer to both your questions are things only within the club know.
People on here speculate and dream up scenarios that have no basis in reality, then argue about it.
Actually it was confirmed in an official United podcast he likes to listen to whale sounds as it helps him to concentrate on the action and keep the crowd noise out during games.
That is not even a valid argument. You can look at the quality of coaching of a side by looking at the end product which is the matchday performance especially if the same coach has been in a prominent position for close to 3 years.
I think it's a constant theme for us, we even rushed Giggs to be an assistant coach instead of having him learn from the bottom up. It's a conscience choice from the club. I think pretty much all of our coaches (who yes are bad) have had their careers hindered by starting too far up the ladder.
Wonder the success rate of coaches based on how they're integrated is. I know ZIdane and Pep were at youth level at some point. Were they assistant coaches to the manager of the first team originally? Obviously ours aren't learning from the best manager in the world compared to who they would have learned from.
I'm guessing the ideal scenario is: Have a good manager and assistant coaches. Throw a promising young coach into the mix so he can see how a club is run (correctly). Move him from that to a youth team. Then see how he does there and if he's either ready to have more responsibility or he needs to go out on his own.
We just thrust too many new coaches into the first team because they were promising without any real plan of who they would learn from.
It's astonishing that the Glazers never considered sacking Woodward. Even now he is undertaking yet more financial mismanagement in giving out contracts to coaches that will almost certainly be sacked by the next chairman.
Your opinion, as an outsider looking at the club from afar, is that McKenna is a bad coach and the matchday performance reflects that.
I'm simply saying that non of us have a clue about what individual coaches bring to the set up. We don't know how Ole and Phelan use the other coaches opinions etc. We're all just guessing.
But I'm basing my view on McKenna on things I've read others say about him. People within the club or within the wider game. He does have a good reputation - and people should remember that it was Mourinho, not Ole, that brought McKenna into the first team set up.
You can see what's going to happen here. "Mr Rodgers/TenHag/Rangnick/Bruce/Santos/Smith we would like to offer you the Utd job, but you must retain the current coaches, as ..well.. they are the Utd way".
McDonald’s wouldn’t give them a new Contract but here we are, Manchester United.
It would be interesting to see if Ole was let go but the coaching staff retained, what the incoming manager would do.
Jose brought McKenna in after Faria left, and if memory serves, we were doing quite well under Jose to this point. I'm going to have to look back at results, but this change and Sanchez arrival does sit in my mind as turning points for Jose.
Likewise… I’m at the point where I’m wondering if the club is being purposely sabotaged from the inside… seriously.
What ON EARTH have these coaches done other than fail in MULTIPLE regimes now!?
They should be first out the door ffs, even before Ole!
Glazers must use them as an ear in the dressing room or something because as coaches they’ve failed under multiple managers and are clearly not worth giving new contracts to.
Also the only tid bit about McKenna is his sessions are a bit "school mastery", yet people are bigging up Conte's team and impressed by fitness coach nicknamed "the marine"
He’s already had one of the best managers ever in Mourinho promote him to first team coach so that is clearly wrong. Mourinho has then gone on to glowingly praise him. He’s also loved by the technical director of the FA (the biggest producer of talent alongside France.) So clearly hasn’t had an issue impressing a decent level of people.
That’s also a pretty terrible list of managers who will “especially“ not keep him, considering he knows two of them. He worked with Pocchetino for over 4 years and they know each other well. Funnily enough he also spent some time with Brendan Rodgers when Liverpool tried to poach him. Another disciple of Mourinho, Rodgers is also Northern Irish and the two have often been compared. So two coaches that actually know him very well will actually be certain to keep him on.
McKenna isn’t going anywhere until he decides to be a manager himself.
McKenna’s “princely wage” during his entire time at the club amounts to less than Pogba’s wage while he serves his suspension for his moronic red card. So the fact you bring that up is laughable
Have no clue what you’re talking about so can’t provide a real response. As expected.
I think in fairness it’s more due to Mourinho’ tendency to go mad in his 3rd season, fall out with everyone and throw everyone else under the bus
From what I heard from people with mates in the club is that Mckemna is a great coach. However the rest (SAF's former players) are hopeless.
Okay, but that doesn't explain the next 2+ years. If he's as great as he's made out to be, surely, in the past 2+ years, we would've seen some signs of cohesive team football, but we haven't. It's all been relying on individuals to pull a piece of magic from out of their hat.
They all need to go. Ole, Carrick and discount Darren Fletcher. I don't know what the hell they do all day, certainly seems they are not doing any actual coaching.
If we're going to keep any of them it should probably be McKenna, but he needs to be surrounded by an experienced manager and coaches. Having our entire system be made up of inexperienced people is ridiculous. Phelan is the only one with any real experience, and he always 'felt' like the least impressive of Fergie's assistants. Obviously that's looking in from the outside though, so maybe he actually is good at the role. Nothing we've seen since he's returned really seem to indicate that though.