He hasnt really done anything wrong this season. Came on in preseason and scored us a last minute winner, came on today and changed the game without a doubt. His physical presence offered us more of a threat than anything we had come up with in the first half, and sure enough he got his goal.
Thing is, regardless of what he does, there are plenty of "fans" on here and in OT who have nailed their colours so firmly to the anti-Fellaini mast, that they will point blank refuse to give him any sort of credit irrespective of performance. I find it pretty sad and frankly disgusting the amount of abuse he gets.
Here are some fachts;
1) Fellaini was signed by Moyes and thus is instantly associated with what was largely a very unsuccessful tenure.
2) Fellaini was signed instead of getting the world class midfielders such as Fabregas and Kroos, that we were linked with (I agree that we should have prioritised other players, by the way).
3) We paid over the odds.
4) Fellaini missed out on preseason last year and spent most of the first half of the season with a wrist injury, which he later had surgery on.
Now im not claiming that Fellaini is a world beater, nor am I claiming that he was/is the answer to all our problems last year or this. Fellaini offers us something very different to any other player in the squad, perhaps any other player in the league. He is a great option to have in the squad, and showed at Everton that in the right sort of setup he can be an incredibly dominant and influential player.
As I said, he isnt a world beater, but nor has he been given a proper chance yet to show what he is capable of. Fortunately, LVG isnt an idiot and seems to recognise the value of Fellaini, even if just to the extent of being prepared to give him a chance - which is more than a lot of the fans do. Fellaini didnt decide how much we paid, he didnt decide when we signed him and by and large he wasnt responsible for what happened last year. He didnt hit the ground running (but again, with no preseason and a wrist injury, is that really a surprise?) but the entire team was a shambles last season and you can pretty much write it off when assessing players.
Basically, he deserves to be given a chance without fans giving him abuse. So far this season he has played well when he has featured, and LVGs post-match comments imply that he [LVG] certainly sees a use for him in the squad.