Manchester United Players' FIFA 23 Ratings

Fair rating IMO:

ST: Cristiano Ronaldo - 90 > 85
CDM: Casemiro - 89 >87
CAM: Bruno Fernandes - 86 > 85
LW: Jadon Sancho - 84 > 84
CB: Raphael Varane - 84 > 86
RW: Antony - 82 rated > 82
CM: Christian Eriksen - 82 > 84
LW: Marcus Rashford - 81 > 81
CB: Lisandro Martinez - 81 > 83
CB: Harry Maguire - 81 > 79
LB: Luke Shaw - 80 rated > 79
CDM: Scott McTominay - 80 > 80
ST: Anthony Martial - 80 > 80
CB: Victor Lindelof - 80 > 75 (he is one of the worst CBs in PL TBH, his defensive record is dreadful and he can't defend at all)
CM: Fred - 80 rated > 79
RB: Aaron Wan-Bissaka - 80 > 77
CM: Donny van de Beek - 79 > 77
LB: Tyrell Malacia - 79 > 81
RB: Diogo Dalot - 78 > 80
RW: Anthony Elanga - 74 > 74
 
Pexbo said:
Havent United always had questionably low ratings on FIFA and its suspected because they’ve never been on great terms with EA? I think they were partners with PES at one point and have pursued EA for image rights.
Click to expand...
I know you had a few responses to this already but I don't think we're unfairly rated now, although I think going back 10 years or so to when we were successful we certainly did have a number of massively underrated players on the game - particularly when you look at the ratings comparatively given to Liverpool players over the past couple of years.
 
JB7 said:
I know you had a few responses to this already but I don't think we're unfairly rated now, although I think going back 10 years or so to when we were successful we certainly did have a number of massively underrated players on the game - particularly when you look at the ratings comparatively given to Liverpool players over the past couple of years.
Click to expand...

Man Utd's League + UCL double team '08

Van Der Sar 84
Neville 80
Ferdinand 87
Vidic 85
Evra 78
Ronaldo 91
Scholes 84
Carrick 83
Giggs 86
Rooney 90
Tevez 87

Total: 935 points (average 85.0 points)

Liverpool League Cup + FA Cup double team '22
Alisson 89
Arnold 87
VVD 89
Matip 83
Robertson 87
Thiago 86
Fabinho 86
Henderson 84
Mane 89
Salah 91
Firminho 85

Total: 956 points (average 86.9 points)
 
I think Varane is still an 85/86 CB and is playing like one, that will probably get changed if they do updates.

90 very high for Ronaldo

Malacia, Sancho, Martinez will rise
 
JeffFromHK said:
Man Utd's League + UCL double team '08

Van Der Sar 84
Neville 80
Ferdinand 87
Vidic 85
Evra 78
Ronaldo 91
Scholes 84
Carrick 83
Giggs 86
Rooney 90
Tevez 87

Total: 935 points (average 85.0 points)

Liverpool League Cup + FA Cup double team '22
Alisson 89
Arnold 87
VVD 89
Matip 83
Robertson 87
Thiago 86
Fabinho 86
Henderson 84
Mane 89
Salah 91
Firminho 85

Total: 956 points (average 86.9 points)
Click to expand...

Interesting they gave Ronaldo a 91 back then when it is was before he had even hit his peak, which was a few levels above.
 
JeffFromHK said:
Man Utd's League + UCL double team '08

Van Der Sar 84
Neville 80
Ferdinand 87
Vidic 85
Evra 78
Ronaldo 91
Scholes 84
Carrick 83
Giggs 86
Rooney 90
Tevez 87

Total: 935 points (average 85.0 points)

Liverpool League Cup + FA Cup double team '22
Alisson 89
Arnold 87
VVD 89
Matip 83
Robertson 87
Thiago 86
Fabinho 86
Henderson 84
Mane 89
Salah 91
Firminho 85

Total: 956 points (average 86.9 points)
Click to expand...
Rating for VDS, Ferdinand, Vidic, Evra are scandalous by comparison. Also putting Ronaldo and Salah on the same level is comical.
 
JeffFromHK said:
Man Utd's League + UCL double team '08

Van Der Sar 84
Neville 80
Ferdinand 87
Vidic 85
Evra 78
Ronaldo 91
Scholes 84
Carrick 83
Giggs 86
Rooney 90
Tevez 87

Total: 935 points (average 85.0 points)

Liverpool League Cup + FA Cup double team '22
Alisson 89
Arnold 87
VVD 89
Matip 83
Robertson 87
Thiago 86
Fabinho 86
Henderson 84
Mane 89
Salah 91
Firminho 85

Total: 956 points (average 86.9 points)
Click to expand...
So, Ronaldo now is basically the same rating as in 2008? :lol:
 
It's not the ratings, the scans are the problem with the United squad. Stupid Greenwood I waited for ages to be scanned, only for him to end up in jail and removed from the game. I am not buying another FIFA unless they scan Martinez, Antony and Malacia and the 10 young players they leave as generic every season.
 
RedRonaldo said:
To be fair this season he wasn’t fully fit and has only played around 378 mins, which is around 4 games sample size.

Based on this season alone Casemiro wouldn’t be 89 either, should be well below Mctominay, who is at 80 rating.
Click to expand...
Agreed.
 
Fortitude said:
:lol:
Click to expand...
Transfermarkt has a habit of tagging players in their posts. They still post about Ronaldo's stats and market values, occasionally referencing to this incident. The comments on these posts are always hilarious.
 
To the people moaning about Ronaldo.... did you also moan about Messi being 90+ last year, when he played more like a 75 player in the farmers league?
 
JeffFromHK said:
Man Utd's League + UCL double team '08

Van Der Sar 84
Neville 80
Ferdinand 87
Vidic 85
Evra 78
Ronaldo 91
Scholes 84
Carrick 83
Giggs 86
Rooney 90
Tevez 87

Total: 935 points (average 85.0 points)

Liverpool League Cup + FA Cup double team '22
Alisson 89
Arnold 87
VVD 89
Matip 83
Robertson 87
Thiago 86
Fabinho 86
Henderson 84
Mane 89
Salah 91
Firminho 85

Total: 956 points (average 86.9 points)
Click to expand...
So Robertson i 9 points ahead of Evra. How ridiculous is that? Rio still better than VVD, but both at 89-90 would be OK. TAA better than Neville is OK, overall. Thiago, Fabinho and Henderson above Carrick and Scholes is just ridiculous. VDS is also rated too low.
 
The ratings given before launch are always almost changed upon release, aren't they? I can see some of our players being adjusted a fair bit. Liverpool should as well, but in a different direction.

Are we going to be the slowest team on FIFA again? A defense of Shaw, Maguire, Lindelöf and AWB was painful.
 
Rossa said:
The ratings given before launch are always almost changed upon release, aren't they? I can see some of our players being adjusted a fair bit. Liverpool should as well, but in a different direction.

Are we going to be the slowest team on FIFA again? A defense of Shaw, Maguire, Lindelöf and AWB was painful.
Click to expand...
You must be the first person I've ever seen who picked Lindelof over Varane.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.